Yahoo
Yogurt machines
Arcade games!
Magic shop area.
Magic shop in the back.
Peering through the window into the back.
Front entrance from the road, Sheridan side.
Outside: back picnic area.
Magic Twist Shop Ice Cream & Yogurt

Open now

  • Fri 3:00 PM - 9:00 PM

656 Millersport Hwy Amherst, NY 14226 ·345.44 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
4.0 16 reviews
5 star
11 4 star
2 3 star
0 2 star
1 1 star
2
Darlene B. 09/17/26

Finally, had a chance to stop in with my two friends to check the place out, as before it was a coffee / game place. Love the yogurt by the oz concept , and variety of flavors and toppings galore...

More
Vicky B. 09/01/25

They now offer 21 flavors of frozen yogurt! During my most recent visit, I got froyo instead of ice cream, and really enjoyed it. The cost is by weight but luckily there's a price cap. It's...

More
Greg O. 08/26/25

I had heard and read about small scoop size, and yes the scoop sizes are smaller than many other local ice cream places, but the topping bar is included. It's not clear how many toppings you can...

More
Heather J. 10/13/25

5/5! 10/10! So many delicious flavors to choose from, both soft serve and hand scooped. And toppings galore! (Yummy and perfect for ice cream, too; small but wonderful details include that the...

More
Linda M. 06/22/25

So excited for a new ice cream and froyo place that's easy to get to. It has plenty of parking, inside and outside seating, and a nice family who owns the place. The ice cream flavors are...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: