Yahoo
Cookie
Cheese pizza and a Magooey brownie
Counter view and menu
Couldn't even wait to take the picture. Had to dig in!
My medium Vegetarian Pizza
Beef pepperoni, and mushroom hand tossed pizza w garlic sauce!!!
Pizza is delicious
Homemade ranch dressing (so good you can eat it with a spoon!)
Magoo's California Pizza Pizza ·$$

Try our Creamy Garlic sauce that people enjoy or the Tomato sauce on your favorite pizza!

Website: magooscalpizza.com

Phone: (317) 271-4411

Cross Streets: Between Thunderbird Rd and N German Church Rd

Closed now

  • Sun 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

10584 Pendleton Pike Indianapolis, IN 46236 ·389.80 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly
  • Accessible
  • Wifi

Reviews

yelp
4.5 268 reviews
5 star
208 4 star
32 3 star
9 2 star
7 1 star
12
Ally R. 07/15/26

The last review is not kidding, this is the best pizza in the Midwest! We've been eating here for 10 years and it's still my favorite pizza spot. The food is consistent, fresh, & the customer...

More
Sarah M. 05/30/26

Magoo's is our household's go-to pizza spot for when we want a hot, delicious pizza for takeout or delivery on the west side of Indy. They have their original location on 38th street that I think...

More
Kendra A. 03/10/26

Spicy Hawaiian pizza & Chicken Tikka Magzone with ranch. Fast service, great food, fun vibes inside.

More
Dustin G. 11/29/25

Continued our new (as of last year) day after Thanksgiving tradition and took the family to Magoos. Forgot to grab pics as everyone just dug in, but we had a large chicken Tikka and a large...

More
Lisa C. 06/04/26

The service was so friendly and fast! He made excellent suggestions. The pizza was delicious. We ordered meat lovers with the garlic sauce based on recommendation from employee and a gentleman...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: