Yahoo
Salad
Triple meat (16
Half Italian Combo (8
Inside dining
Kids meal (4
Papa Kelsey's
Mozzarella Sticks
More bread. Less filling.
Cinnamon roll
Papa Kelseys Sandwiches
Interested in our services?

Closing soon · 9 PM

  • Wed 10:00 AM - 9:00 PM

1545 E Iron Eagle Dr Eagle, ID 83616 ·1969.24 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
3.5 20 reviews
5 star
8 4 star
5 3 star
0 2 star
3 1 star
4
Jessica J. 07/16/26

Best Italian Sub around! My son loves the pizzas so it's a win-win for both of us. Restaurant is always clean and well kept. Staff is very friendly, especially Graham. He's always got a smile...

More
Randy W. 08/08/25

Walked in the door & BOOM! We were greeted with a big smile & a counter full of freshly baked cinnamon rolls, each one bigger than any I have ever seen! So.. yes, definitely had to pick one of...

More
Terrence C. 06/12/26

We had a nice dinner out, the salad was fresh, fries were crispy, the pizza was hot and fresh and the cinnamon roll was ginormous. The staff was friendly, a little quite bit good service.

More
Robert A. 08/06/26

The bread on my sub was easily some of the best bread I've ever had on a sandwich. Super fresh, soft yet a little crunchy. The meatball was tasty, the service was good, and the place was clean....

More
Karen T. 09/24/26

The brisket sandwich was not very good. Wasn't tender or sliced thin, like they said. It was more like chunky. Don't get me wrong, I've had great sandwiches there,

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: