Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie is your gateway to Brooklyn’s most delectable pies. Grab a slice and pull a chair by their colorful picnic tables to set yourself an indulgent fare. In addition to the melt-in-the-mouth key lime pies, the bakery offers an assortment of tempting desserts such as the Swingle, which is a signature tart dipped in Belgian chocolate. The fame and allure of the decadent offerings here are quite widespread; do head to Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie at the earliest for a slice of pure deliciousness.
Website: keylime.com
Phone: (718) 858-5333
Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Van Dyke St and Barnell St
Open now
- Wed 12:00 PM - 7:30 PM
185 Van Dyke St Brooklyn, NY 11231 ·344.85 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Accessible
- Family friendly
Reviews
yelpAuthentic Key Lime Pie is a celebrated waterfront bakery operating for over 30 years. Famous for its walk-up window service and views of the New York Harbor, the shop specializes in traditional,...
MoreCute little storefront. Long lines. Managed to avoid them because we came right before closing. They pies were dang good folks. The filling was sweet, creamy, and fresh. The crust had the...
MoreVibe/ambiance: window pick up with picnic tables outside Service: quick, line was ~10 mins Items ordered: Raspberry swingle: a little too sweet, but the raspberry added good tartness
MoreChocolate and key lime pie is a great combo, I love that the tartness is cut through with the chocolate. My only complaint was that the pie still felt a bit frozen when I bit into it, I assume...
MoreThe famous desserts here once inspired me to devise an email subject header entitled Their A&R Man Said I Don't Hear a Swingle, but the truth is I don't recall if I've gotten one of these as I...
More