Yahoo
Ok.... So explain...why this T-shirt is $18.99, but a COLD WATER CREEK  blouse is only $12.99
Thin, cheap cotton sundress from Old Navy priced at $15?! They have them right now brand new for $9 in their stores....
Proof
Proof she puts out 50/50
Proof
Proof
Proof
Castaway's Consignment Thrift Store ·$$

1239 Peoria St Washington, IL 61571 ·564.91 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
2.5 10 reviews
5 star
3 4 star
0 3 star
1 2 star
2 1 star
4
Ady D. 12/14/16

I used to adore this store until I realized their questionable consignment practices. After frequent mislabeling, which leads to crediting wrong accounts, and inconsistencies in what pieces will...

More
Sarah G. 03/11/26

I received a final notice from the States Attorney's office regarding my complaint against Castaway Consignment. The owner never replied to any communication from the State's Attorney's office....

More
Lura L. 08/30/25

Always find amazing things. It's a drive for me but worth it. If I was closer I would go more often!!

More
Colleen S. 10/15/25

This is a fabulous place to find current fashions at a great price. Very friendly staff! Good lelection for both women and children!!

More
Linda Martin 08/05/25

I had been consigning clothes over the last 4 years, and, never had a good feeling about how they picked their clothes. And, I felt like the clothes that I did leave with them...were sold, but,...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: