Yahoo
Chicken Quesadilla
Outside seating and live music
Great vibes!
Key Lime Pie.
Guavarita
Classic Top Shelf Margarita
Casa Maya Mexican Restaurant ·$$

Casa Maya serves Latin food in the Spanish historic district of St. Augustine. The menu features twists on plates like the Spanish and Cuban 'Ropa Vieja' (pulled beef or pork) atop a fried corn tortilla or chicken mole enchiladas served alongside Mayan soup. Another highlight is the back patio bar 'El Escondite' (The Hideout), it has phenomenal oyster-on-the-half-shell options; ask your server about daily deals. 

Website: casamayasta.com

Phone: (904) 823-0787

Cross Streets: Between The Court and Charlotte St

Closed now

  • Fri 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM

22 Hypolita St St Augustine, FL 32084 ·570.85 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Accessible
  • Wifi
  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
3.5 1016 reviews
5 star
449 4 star
205 3 star
121 2 star
105 1 star
136
David E. 10/02/26

First. Yelp and the clowns that give low ratings need to go gator hunting with some raw chicken in their left hand. This place has an excellent staff,Authentic food and variety. Just go. Have...

More
Hunt F. 10/19/26

Casa Maya is one of our faves in downtown St Augustine. Truly authentic Mexican food with top notch quality. Our server Jae went above and beyond taking care of us. My husband and I especially...

More
Ammara W. 07/31/26

Casa Maya was our last meal before heading to the airport, and it was a memorable way to end our Florida trip. Tucked down a charming alley in St. Augustine, the restaurant has a great atmosphere...

More
Ilana M. 07/28/26

Terrific Fajitas ! So delicious Clean establishment Service was Terrific Loved the chips and salsa too

More
Candy K. 05/27/26

Casa Maya has a nice outdoor seating area with lots of shade. The service was prompt and friendly. They have a fun drink menu and we tried the Green Bee, Luna Blu and It's in the Bag (it comes in...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: