Yahoo
Deluxe pizza
Xtrordinary personal pizza.
Meat lovers lunch special
Equivalent of supreme pizza
Inside the seating area
Medium Supreme
All meat 1/2 Mushrooms!!!
Calzone
Medium with everything, minus a few ingredients.
Inside the seating area
Xtrordinary Pizza Pizza ·$$

Open now

  • Thu 9:00 AM - 12:00 PM, 4:00 PM - 8:00 PM

7639 E Southeastern Ave Indianapolis, IN 46239 ·373.37 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly

Reviews

yelp
4.0 104 reviews
5 star
60 4 star
14 3 star
4 2 star
4 1 star
22
Jennifer M. 05/17/26

Xtraordinary has been a longtime favorite of mine! If you enjoy a tick topping, Sloppy, piled high pizza.... this is for you! I can't find another one like it that satisfies my pizza craving.

More
Teresa L. 08/08/26

Wanted to try a new pizza joint but guess it's not going to happen. Tried calling to place an order as it says to call but no one answered. Guess we'll just have to order elsewhere. Shame they...

More
Kelly B. 03/07/26

I had heard such good things about this pizza spot I had to try it. Boy I so glad I did. We were greeted as soon as we walked in. Since we were newbies the lady did go over the menu. I...

More
MIchelle C. 11/10/25

Our first trip to Xtrordinary Pizza is in the books! The pizzas and calzone were great! We ordered what was basically a supreme pizza and it was LOADED with toppings! I needed a fork to gather the...

More
To F. 06/12/26

I'm not in the mood to write a long review. Xtrordinary Pizza doesn't need a long review. The Pizza tastes better than the pictures look. Good service and product. Space clean and neat. If it is...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: