Yahoo
Fresh Bagels
Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese (hot honey pecan cc)
Fort Greene on bagel
Entrance
Entrance
Signature Zatar Bagel with Sriracha Cream Cheese
Everything bagel with jalapeño cc
Signature Zatar Bagel
Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe Bagel Shop ·$

Website: oldebrooklynbagelshop.com

Phone: (718) 622-6227

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of Vanderbilt Ave and Prospect Pl

Closed now

  • Mon 6:00 AM - 5:00 PM

645 Vanderbilt Ave Brooklyn, NY 11238 ·347.09 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Reviews

yelp
3.0 374 reviews
5 star
103 4 star
87 3 star
43 2 star
69 1 star
72
Fiona W. 11/06/26

Kinda a phenomenal bagel. I got the everything bagel with jalapeño chive cream cheese. I think it was the jalapeño chive or chive jalapeño. The cream cheese was quite spicy. Bagel ready fast....

More
Minah M. 05/28/26

Here's the thing, I didn't realize the cream cheese was Jalapeño cream cheese and it had bite. I ordered (I believe) the Sailor, lov, cream cheese and capers on a rainbow bagel toasted to...

More
Sabrina H. 07/14/26

Bagels tasted kind of dense and stale. The scallion cream cheese was pretty mid. Thought it was pretty expensive for the quality. Took a while to get my bagel because there was a long line.

More
Carolina C. 04/25/26

I ordered Olde as delivery, and it sounds like it would be faster than waiting at the actual brick and mortar. I got an everything with lox, and they were pretty generous with the filling, but the...

More
Scott S. 06/04/26

Was in the neighborhood and saw a sign for za'atar bagels. So I had to come in. Seemed like a real local bagel joint. I wanted a dozen of the Za'atar but had to settle for 4. Next time I will...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: