'The evidence is starting to mount': physicists at the Large Hadron Collider have found a possible 'anomaly' that could unlock 'a new understanding of how the universe works' — and 'charming penguins' may hold the key to understanding if the Standard Model of particle physics is out of date

When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission.

• A rare decay exposes cracks in physics that refuse easy explanation

• The Standard Model shows strain under one of its toughest tests

• Four-sigma anomaly hints something subtle may be missing in physics

Scientists at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) have found something strange inside a particle decay process called an electroweak penguin decay, which could signal a major problem for modern physics.

The LHC is a 27-kilometer circular tunnel buried under the French-Swiss border where proton beams smash together at nearly the speed of light, recreating conditions similar to those just after the Big Bang.

Experiments like LHCb analyze the collision debris to look for cracks in the Standard Model, the rulebook for particle physics that has passed every test for over 50 years despite being known to be incomplete.

How scientists spotted the glitch in a million-to-one event

In their experiment, the researchers observed a B meson, a short-lived particle, breaking apart into three other particles.

This transformation is extremely rare, happening only once in every million B meson collisions.

That rarity makes it a powerful tool for spotting hidden influences from unknown particles.

Think of it like hearing a faint whisper in a noisy stadium. The whisper might be nothing, or it might be the most important message you have ever heard.

The scientists measured two things: the angles at which the particles fly apart, and how often the decay happens.

Both measurements disagreed with what the Standard Model of physics predicts, which sounds impressive, but physicists demand much higher certainty for a formal discovery.

The odds of this disagreement being a random fluke are about 1 in 16,000, as the current finding sits at four sigma.

The gold standard for a discovery is five sigma, which is a 1 in 1.7 million chance of being wrong.

Imagine rolling a die and getting the same number six times in a row. That is unusual, but not impossible.

Now imagine rolling the same number 20 times in a row. That would make you seriously question whether the die is fair. That is the difference between four sigma and five sigma.

There are several possible explanations if this anomaly turns out to be real.

One idea involves particles called leptoquarks, which would unite two different types of matter: leptons and quarks.

Another possibility is the existence of heavier versions of particles we already know about, extending the Standard Model rather than replacing it.

This kind of indirect evidence has happened before in physics. Radioactivity was discovered 80 years before scientists found the particles responsible for it.

This proves that you can detect something's effects long before you can see it directly.

The current anomaly could be a similar early warning. The LHCb experiment analyzed about 650 billion B meson decays between 2011 and 2018 to find this penguin process.

Since then, the team has already collected three times more data, which will help confirm or rule out the anomaly.

Future upgrades in the 2030s will increase the dataset by 15 times, giving physicists the statistical power needed to reach a definitive conclusion.

The main complication comes from something called "charming penguins." These are Standard Model processes involving charm quarks that are very hard to calculate precisely.

Recent estimates suggest these effects are not large enough to explain the anomaly. But the calculations are so tricky that physicists cannot be completely sure yet.

Think of it like trying to measure the thickness of a hair with a ruler. The ruler is simply not precise enough for the job.

The current available data is like that ruler. It is pointing in an interesting direction, but we need a sharper tool to be certain.

The four-sigma tension is genuinely exciting, but particle physics has seen promising anomalies disappear before.

More data and better calculations could still bring the results back into line with the Standard Model.

Last year, there was an independent LHC experiment known as CMS, which published results in agreement with the current study, albeit with lesser precision.

Together, both studies make the strongest combined case yet that something genuinely new may be operating at the most fundamental level of reality, but both share similar uncertainties.

For now, the Standard Model remains standing, but for the first time in decades it appears to be wobbling.

Whether that wobble is the beginning of a collapse or just a statistical mirage will be decided by the next few years of data.

Either outcome will teach us something profound about how science progresses when the most successful theory in history meets its first real test.

Via Phys.org