By continuing to use this website you agree to our terms and conditions. If you don't agree with our terms and conditions, you are not permitted to continue using this website.
Table of Contents
Carrie Underwood’s new role as a judge onAmerican Idolmight be surprising to some, but not to Kelly Clarkson.
The two icons, both formerIdolwinners, have long been compared in their respective careers, but Clarkson’s foresight into Underwood’s judging potential dates back over a decade.
With Underwood now confirmed as a new judge for the hit reality competition, Clarkson’s prediction feels more relevant than ever.
Keep reading for more details!
Kelly Clarkson’s Early Prediction
Back in 2012, Kelly Clarkson made a bold statement that Carrie Underwood would be an ideal fit as a judge onAmerican Idol.
While Clarkson herself had moved on to become a coach onThe Voice, the originalIdolwinner had no hesitation in expressing her confidence in Underwood’s ability to excel as a judge on the show that launched both of their careers.
“She would [be the perfect judge],” Clarkson said in an interview withUs Weeklyover ten years ago.At the time, Clarkson was busy mentoring contestants on the showDuets.
Clarkson also highlighted that Underwood had majored in journalism, noting that this background could serve her well in delivering precise, well-thought-out critiques.
With her ability to maintain a calm and collected demeanor, Clarkson knew Underwood’s “bluff face” would be a significant asset in a judging role.
Kelly Clarkson made history when she won the inaugural season ofAmerican Idolin 2002.
Her victory catapulted her into a wildly successful career that spans numerous Grammy Awards, chart-topping albums, and a presence on multiple television programs.
Carrie Underwood, who became the first country artist to winIdolin 2005 during the show’s fourth season, has followed a similar trajectory.
She has gone on to win numerous accolades, including Grammy Awards, and established herself as a dominant force in the world of country music.
The success stories of both Clarkson and Underwood demonstrate the profound impact thatAmerican Idolhas had on its winners.
Their experiences as contestants have given them unique perspectives, and now, in Underwood’s case, the opportunity to offer guidance to aspiring singers on the same stage.
Underwood’sappointment as a judge may have caught some off-guard, but the characteristics that Clarkson saw in her over a decade ago make her a natural choice.
When ABC officially announced Underwood’s addition to theAmerican Idoljudging panel, she expressed her enthusiasm about taking on this new challenge.
Underwood’s honesty, combined with her extensive knowledge of the music industry, positions her as an ideal guide for the next generation of singers.
“I can’t lie,” Underwood toldGood Morning America(GMA). “I feel like I’ll be very honest, but hopefully I can be very constructive and encouraging.”
Her no-nonsense approach to critique is likely to resonate with contestants and viewers alike, offering the perfect balance of guidance and motivation.
As a contestant onAmerican Idol, Underwood proved her resilience, work ethic, and natural talent. Now, years later, she’s poised to bring those same qualities to the judging table.
Her understanding of what it takes to winIdol, coupled with her extensive experience in the music industry, ensures that her critiques will be grounded in expertise and empathy.
A Long-Awaited Reunion
Carrie Underwood’s new role onAmerican Idolbrings her back to the very platform that jump-started her career.
She’ll be joining Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie on the judges’ panel, as well asIdol’slongtime host, Ryan Seacrest, with whom she has maintained a relationship since her 2005 win.
WithKaty Perry’sdeparture after seven seasons as a judge, Underwood’s arrival marks a new chapter forAmerican Idol.
While Perry was known for her eccentric style and playful critiques, Underwood’s more grounded and straightforward approach will offer a fresh dynamic to the judging panel.
Fans ofAmerican Idolare eager to see how Underwood will fit into this new role and how her style will differ from the judges who have come before her.
As Clarkson predicted, Underwood’s ability to balance kindness with constructive criticism will likely make her a standout judge.
Kelly Clarkson’s Coaching vs. Judging Preference
Interestingly, while Kelly Clarkson was quick to predict Underwood’s future success as a judge, she has always preferred a different role.
Instead of judging contestants, Clarkson has thrived in a coaching role, most notably as a coach onThe Voice, a direct competitor ofAmerican Idol.
In her interview withUs Weekly, Clarkson explained, “[Being a] mentor is more my style.
Not just mentoring but getting to be a part of the song with them, getting them amped up — from rehearsals to the stage, it’s so exciting being on stage. It’s fun!”
Clarkson’s enthusiasm for the coaching aspect aligns perfectly with her energetic and hands-on approach to mentoring.
For her, it’s about the process of helping contestants grow and develop their talent, rather than just offering critique from a judge’s seat.
AsAmerican Idolprepares for its next season, the addition of Carrie Underwood to the judging panel has sparked renewed interest in the show.
Fans are excited to see how Underwood, as both a former contestant and now a judge, will influence the competition and guide the contestants toward success.
Her experience as a contestant on the show gives her a unique perspective, and her ability to offer honest, constructive feedback will set her apart from previous judges.
Just as Kelly Clarkson predicted, Carrie Underwood’s calm, insightful approach will likely make her a favorite among contestants and viewers alike.
With a background in journalism, an unmatched career in music, and a wealth of experience from herIdoldays, Underwood is more than equipped to take on this new role.
As she joinsLuke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and Ryan Seacrest, fans can look forward to a new era ofAmerican Idol, one where the competition is fierce, the critiques are genuine, and the talent is undeniable.
Season
American Idol Winner
Career Milestone
Season 1
Kelly Clarkson
Multiple Grammy Awards, TV Show Host
Season 4
Carrie Underwood
Grammy Winner, Country Music Icon
A table showing the success stories of Clarkson and Underwood
Conclusion
Carrie Underwood’s journey fromAmerican Idolcontestant to judge is a testament to her incredible growth and success.
As Kelly Clarkson predicted years ago, Underwood is set to shine in this new role, bringing her honesty, expertise, and supportive nature to the forefront of the competition.
With her alongside industry veterans, the future ofAmerican Idollooks bright, promising a new wave of talent to be guided by one of the show’s greatestsuccessstories.
Watch Carrie Underwood perform her American Idol audition
Last Updated: September 23, 2024
Lucky you! This thread is empty,
which means you've got dibs on the first comment.
Go for it!