The Top 100 Position Players of the 20th Century
Title:
BASEBALL’S BEST: The TRUE Hall of Famers
Author:
Michael Hoban, Ph.D.
Formats:
PDF (ebook) | Paperback
Pages:
223
Click cover to order book |
The Best Players of the 20th Century |
Here is a list of the 100 best position players of the century according to the NEWS Hall of Fame Gauge.
There are only 93 position players who have definite Hall of Fame numbers according to NEWS (see below).
All numbers include the 2007 season.
Bold=Hall of Famer
Italic=Active Player in 2007
CWS=Career Win Shares
CV=Core Value (sum of win shares for 10 best seasons)
NEWS=Career Value(Non-traditional Evaluative Win Shares)
=CV+.25(CWS – CV)
Player | POS. | CWS | CV | NEWS | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1.
|
Babe Ruth | RF | 756 | 460 | 534 |
2.
|
Barry Bonds |
LF | 707 | 427 | 497
|
3.
|
Ty Cobb | CF | 722 | 419 | 495 |
4.
|
Honus Wagner | SS | 655 | 422 | 480 |
5.
|
Willie Mays | CF | 642 | 389 | 452 |
6.
|
Tris Speaker | CF | 630 | 388 | 449 |
7.
|
Mickey Mantle | CF | 565 | 399 | 441 |
8.
|
Stan Musial | LF | 604 | 378 | 435 |
9.
|
Ted Williams | LF | 555 | 394 | 434 |
10.
|
Hank Aaron | RF | 643 | 356 | 428 |
11.
|
Eddie Collins | 2B | 574 | 376 | 426 |
12.
|
Rogers Hornsby | 2B | 502 | 381 | 411 |
13.
|
Lou Gehrig | 1B | 489 | 384 | 410 |
14.
|
Joe Morgan | 2B | 512 | 341 | 384 |
15.
|
Mel Ott | RF | 528 | 335 | 383 |
16.
|
Nap Lajoie | 2B | 496 | 334 | 375 |
17.
|
Mike Schmidt | 3B | 467 | 338 | 370 |
18.
|
Frank Robinson | RF | 519 | 316 | 367 |
19.
|
Pete Rose | LF | 547 | 307 | 367 |
20.
|
Rickey Henderson | LF | 535 | 308 | 365 |
21.
|
Eddie Mathews | 3B | 450 | 333 | 362 |
22.
|
Jimmie Foxx | 1B | 435 | 325 | 353 |
23.
|
Joe DiMaggio | CF | 387 | 325 | 341 |
24.
|
Alex Rodriguez | SS | 369 | 332 | 341 |
25.
|
Sam Crawford | RF | 446 | 303 | 339 |
26.
|
Carl Yastrzemski | LF | 488 | 286 | 337 |
27.
|
Paul Waner | RF | 423 | 304 | 334
|
28.
|
Reggie Jackson | RF | 444 | 296 | 333 |
29.
|
George Brett | 3B | 432 | 296 | 333 |
30.
|
Gary Sheffield | LF | 418 | 305 | 333 |
31.
|
Craig Biggio | 2B | 428 | 294 | 328 |
32.
|
Frank Thomas | 1B | 400 | 301 | 326 |
33.
|
Arky Vaughan | SS | 356 | 308 | 320 |
34.
|
Wade Boggs | 3B | 394 | 291 | 317 |
35.
|
Willie McCovey | 1B | 408 | 285 | 316 |
36.
|
Dick Allen | 1B | 342 | 304 | 314 |
37.
|
Eddie Murray | 1B | 437 | 273 | 314 |
38.
|
Cal Ripken Jr. | SS | 427 | 276 | 314 |
39.
|
Robin Yount | SS | 423 | 278 | 314 |
40.
|
Jeff Bagwell | 1B | 388 | 287 | 312 |
41.
|
Al Kaline | RF | 443 | 268 | 312 |
42.
|
Johnny Mize | 1B | 339 | 296 | 307 |
43.
|
Charlie Gehringer | 2B | 383 | 280 | 306 |
44.
|
Paul Molitor | DH | 414 | 270 | 306 |
45.
|
Fred Clarke | LF | 400 | 273 | 305 |
46.
|
Duke Snider | CF | 352 | 289 | 305 |
47.
|
Ken Griffey Jr. | CF | 383 | 278 | 304 |
48.
|
Tim Raines | LF | 390 | 275 | 304 |
49.
|
Harmon Killebrew | 1B | 374 | 279 | 303 |
50.
|
Billy Williams | LF | 374 | 279 | 303 |
51.
|
Roberto Alomar | 2B | 375 | 278 | 302 |
52.
|
Luke Appling | SS | 378 | 275 | 301
|
53.
|
Yogi Berra | C | 375 | 276 | 301 |
54.
|
Al Simmons | LF | 375 | 276 | 301 |
55.
|
Manny Ramirez | LF | 349 | 282 | 299 |
56.
|
Mark McGwire | 1B | 342 | 283 | 298 |
57.
|
Dave Winfield | RF | 415 | 259 | 298 |
58.
|
Johnny Bench | C | 356 | 277 | 297 |
59.
|
Roberto Clemente | RF | 377 | 269 | 296 |
60.
|
Ryne Sandberg | 2B | 346 | 278 | 295 |
61.
|
Tony Gwynn | RF | 398 | 269 | 294 |
62.
|
Sherry Magee | LF | 354 | 272 | 293 |
63.
|
Zack Wheat | LF | 380 | 264 | 293 |
64.
|
George Davis | SS | 398 | 255 | 291 |
65.
|
Joe Jackson | LF | 294 | 290 | 291 |
66.
|
Joe Cronin | SS | 333 | 275 | 290 |
67.
|
Rafael Palmeiro | 1B | 387 | 257 | 290 |
68.
|
Willie Stargell | LF | 370 | 263 | 290 |
69.
|
Rod Carew | 2B | 384 | 257 | 289 |
70.
|
Harry Heilmann | RF | 356 | 267 | 289 |
71.
|
Ron Santo | 3B | 324 | 275 | 287 |
72.
|
Bill Dahlen | SS | 394 | 250 | 286 |
73.
|
Goose Goslin | LF | 355 | 263 | 286 |
74.
|
Mike Piazza | C | 325 | 273 | 286 |
75.
|
Frank Baker | 3B | 301 | 280 | 285 |
76.
|
Lou Brock | LF | 348 | 264 | 285 |
77.
|
Will Clark | 1B | 331 | 269 | 285 |
78.
|
Frankie Frisch | 2B | 366 | 256 | 284 |
79.
|
Chipper Jones
|
3B
|
327
|
269
|
284
|
80.
|
Elmer Flick | RF | 291 | 280 | 283 |
81.
|
Gary Carter | C | 337 | 263 | 282 |
82.
|
Jim Thome | 1B | 328 | 267 | 282 |
83.
|
Darrell Evans | 3B | 363 | 253 | 281 |
84.
|
Barry Larkin | SS | 347 | 258 | 280 |
85.
|
Rusty Staub | RF | 354 | 254 | 279 |
86.
|
Joe Medwick | LF | 312 | 267 | 278 |
87.
|
Jimmy Sheckard | LF | 339 | 257 | 278 |
88.
|
Jimmy Wynn | CF | 305 | 269 | 278 |
89.
|
Jason Giambi | 1B | 289 | 271 | 276 |
90.
|
Richie Ashburn | CF | 329 | 257 | 275 |
91.
|
Bobby Bonds | RB | 302 | 264 | 274 |
92.
|
Tony Perez | 1B | 349 | 249 | 274 |
93.
|
Brooks Robinson | 3B | 356 | 247 | 274 |
94.
|
Derek Jeter | SS | 301 | 264 | 273 |
95.
|
Sammy Sosa | RF | 325 | 255 | 273 |
96.
|
Max Carey | CF | 351 | 245 | 272 |
97.
|
Carlton Fisk | C | 368 | 240 | 272 |
98.
|
Bobby Grich | 2B | 329 | 253 | 272 |
99.
|
Jeff Kent | 2B | 331 | 252 | 272 |
100.
|
Earl Averill | CF | 280 | 268 | 271 |
|
Stan Hack | 3B | 316 | 256 | 271 |
|
Ken Singleton | RF | 302 | 260 | 271 |
According to the NEWS HOF Gauge, not all of these players have clear
Nine Other Players with
There are nine other players who did not reach the 280 NEWS figure because of a shorter career.They also have
Player | POS. | CWS | CV | NEWS |
---|---|---|---|---|
Earl Averill
|
CF | 280 | 268 | 271 |
Hank Greenberg
|
1B | 267 | 262 | 263
|
Lou Boudreau
|
SS | 277 | 255 | 261 |
Bill Terry
|
1B | 278 | 255 | 261 |
Larry Doby
|
CF | 268 | 257 | 260 |
Jackie Robinson
|
2B | 257 | 257 | 257 |
Mickey Cochrane
|
C | 275 | 250 | 256 |
Kirby Puckett
|
CF | 281 | 247 | 256 |
Bill Dickey
|
C | 314 | 235 | 255 |
As noted above, only ninety-three (93) 20 th
century position players have Hall of Fame numbers according to the NEWS
The Other Hall of Famers – Do Not Have
Player | CWS | CV | NEWS |
---|---|---|---|
Ernie Banks
|
332 | 247 | 268 |
Willie Keeler
|
333 | 246 | 268 |
Orlando Cepeda
|
310 | 251 | 266 |
Edd Roush
|
314 | 250 | 266 |
Enos Slaughter
|
323 | 246 | 265 |
Pee Wee Reese
|
314 | 246 | 263 |
Nellie Fox
|
304 | 242 | 258 |
Billy Herman
|
298 | 243 | 257 |
Bobby Wallace
|
345 | 227 | 257 |
Kiki Cuyler
|
292 | 244 | 256 |
Gabby Hartnett
|
325 | 229 | 253 |
Sam Rice
|
327 | 228 | 253 |
George Sisler
|
292 | 239 | 252 |
Ozzie Smith
|
325 | 226 | 251 |
Jimmy Collins
|
274 | 242 | 250 |
Heinie Manush
|
285 | 236 | 248 |
Harry Hooper
|
321 | 221 | 246 |
Joe Sewell
|
277 | 233 | 244 |
Ralph Kiner
|
242 | 242 | 242 |
Pie Traynor
|
274 | 228 | 240 |
Bobby Doerr
|
281 | 223 | 238 |
Johnny Evers
|
268 | 226 | 237 |
Dave Bancroft
|
269 | 222 | 234 |
Rabbit Maranville
|
302 | 206 | 230 |
Jim Bottomley
|
258 | 214 | 225 |
Tony Lazzeri
|
252 | 215 | 224 |
Joe Tinker
|
258 | 211 | 223 |
Chuck Klein
|
238 | 217 | 222 |
Phil Rizzuto
|
231 | 218 | 221 |
Hack Wilson
|
224 | 220 | 221 |
Earle Combs
|
227 | 217 | 220 |
Red Schoendienst
|
262 | 204 | 219 |
Luis Aparicio
|
293 | 193 | 218 |
Lloyd Waner
|
245 | 207 | 217 |
Frank Chance
|
237 | 206 | 214 |
Roy Campanella
|
207 | 207 | 207 |
Ross Youngs
|
206 | 206 | 206 |
Roger Bresnahan
|
231 | 191 | 201 |
George Kell
|
229 | 192 | 201 |
Travis Jackson
|
211 | 191 | 196 |
Fred Lindstrom
|
193 | 182 | 190 |
Bill Mazeroski
|
219 | 173 | 185 |
Ernie Lombardi
|
218 | 167 | 180 |
Chick Hafey
|
186 | 176 | 179 |
Ray Schalk
|
191 | 167 | 173 |
Rick Ferrell
|
206 | 150 | 164 |