The Top 100 Position Players of the 20th Century


baseballsbest.jpg

Title: BASEBALL’S BEST: The TRUE Hall of Famers
Author:
Michael Hoban, Ph.D.
Formats: PDF (ebook) | Paperback
Pages: 223

blank2.jpg

Click cover to order book
The Best Players of the 20th Century

Here is a list of the 100 best position players of the century according to the NEWS Hall of Fame Gauge.

There are only 93 position players who have definite Hall of Fame numbers according to NEWS (see below).

All numbers include the 2007 season.

Bold=Hall of Famer

Italic=Active Player in 2007

CWS=Career Win Shares

CV=Core Value (sum of win shares for 10 best seasons)

NEWS=Career Value(Non-traditional Evaluative Win Shares)

=CV+.25(CWS – CV)

Player POS. CWS CV NEWS
1.
Babe Ruth RF 756 460 534
2.
Barry Bonds
LF 707 427 497
3.
Ty Cobb CF 722 419 495
4.
Honus Wagner SS 655 422 480
5.
Willie Mays CF 642 389 452
6.
Tris Speaker CF 630 388 449
7.
Mickey Mantle CF 565 399 441
8.
Stan Musial LF 604 378 435
9.
Ted Williams LF 555 394 434
10.
Hank Aaron RF 643 356 428
11.
Eddie Collins 2B 574 376 426
12.
Rogers Hornsby 2B 502 381 411
13.
Lou Gehrig 1B 489 384 410
14.
Joe Morgan 2B 512 341 384
15.
Mel Ott RF 528 335 383
16.
Nap Lajoie 2B 496 334 375
17.
Mike Schmidt 3B 467 338 370
18.
Frank Robinson RF 519 316 367
19.
Pete Rose LF 547 307 367
20.
Rickey Henderson LF 535 308 365
21.
Eddie Mathews 3B 450 333 362
22.
Jimmie Foxx 1B 435 325 353
23.
Joe DiMaggio CF 387 325 341
24.
Alex Rodriguez SS 369 332 341
25.
Sam Crawford RF 446 303 339
26.
Carl Yastrzemski LF 488 286 337
27.
Paul Waner RF 423 304 334
28.
Reggie Jackson RF 444 296 333
29.
George Brett 3B 432 296 333
30.
Gary Sheffield LF 418 305 333
31.
Craig Biggio 2B 428 294 328
32.
Frank Thomas 1B 400 301 326
33.
Arky Vaughan SS 356 308 320
34.
Wade Boggs 3B 394 291 317
35.
Willie McCovey 1B 408 285 316
36.
Dick Allen 1B 342 304 314
37.
Eddie Murray 1B 437 273 314
38.
Cal Ripken Jr. SS 427 276 314
39.
Robin Yount SS 423 278 314
40.
Jeff Bagwell 1B 388 287 312
41.
Al Kaline RF 443 268 312
42.
Johnny Mize 1B 339 296 307
43.
Charlie Gehringer 2B 383 280 306
44.
Paul Molitor DH 414 270 306
45.
Fred Clarke LF 400 273 305
46.
Duke Snider CF 352 289 305
47.
Ken Griffey Jr. CF 383 278 304
48.
Tim Raines LF 390 275 304
49.
Harmon Killebrew 1B 374 279 303
50.
Billy Williams LF 374 279 303
51.
Roberto Alomar 2B 375 278 302
52.
Luke Appling SS 378 275 301
53.
Yogi Berra C 375 276 301
54.
Al Simmons LF 375 276 301
55.
Manny Ramirez LF 349 282 299
56.
Mark McGwire 1B 342 283 298
57.
Dave Winfield RF 415 259 298
58.
Johnny Bench C 356 277 297
59.
Roberto Clemente RF 377 269 296
60.
Ryne Sandberg 2B 346 278 295
61.
Tony Gwynn RF 398 269 294
62.
Sherry Magee LF 354 272 293
63.
Zack Wheat LF 380 264 293
64.
George Davis SS 398 255 291
65.
Joe Jackson LF 294 290 291
66.
Joe Cronin SS 333 275 290
67.
Rafael Palmeiro 1B 387 257 290
68.
Willie Stargell LF 370 263 290
69.
Rod Carew 2B 384 257 289
70.
Harry Heilmann RF 356 267 289
71.
Ron Santo 3B 324 275 287
72.
Bill Dahlen SS 394 250 286
73.
Goose Goslin LF 355 263 286
74.
Mike Piazza C 325 273 286
75.
Frank Baker 3B 301 280 285
76.
Lou Brock LF 348 264 285
77.
Will Clark 1B 331 269 285
78.
Frankie Frisch 2B 366 256 284
79.
Chipper Jones
3B
327
269
284
80.
Elmer Flick RF 291 280 283
81.
Gary Carter C 337 263 282
82.
Jim Thome 1B 328 267 282
83.
Darrell Evans 3B 363 253 281
84.
Barry Larkin SS 347 258 280
85.
Rusty Staub RF 354 254 279
86.
Joe Medwick LF 312 267 278
87.
Jimmy Sheckard LF 339 257 278
88.
Jimmy Wynn CF 305 269 278
89.
Jason Giambi 1B 289 271 276
90.
Richie Ashburn CF 329 257 275
91.
Bobby Bonds RB 302 264 274
92.
Tony Perez 1B 349 249 274
93.
Brooks Robinson 3B 356 247 274
94.
Derek Jeter SS 301 264 273
95.
Sammy Sosa RF 325 255 273
96.
Max Carey CF 351 245 272
97.
Carlton Fisk C 368 240 272
98.
Bobby Grich 2B 329 253 272
99.
Jeff Kent 2B 331 252 272
100.
Earl Averill CF 280 268 271
Stan Hack 3B 316 256 271
Ken Singleton RF 302 260 271

According to the NEWS HOF Gauge, not all of these players have clear HOF numbers.The NEWS benchmark for a position player to have definite HOF numbers is a NEWS score of 280.Eighty-four (84) of these players meet that criterion.That does NOT mean, for example, that Brooks Robinson should not be in the Hall of Fame.It simply means that his numbers are not as strong as those ranked above him.

Nine Other Players with HOF Numbers – Short and Great Career

There are nine other players who did not reach the 280 NEWS figure because of a shorter career.They also have HOF numbers.They each played fewer than 1800 games but still had a NEWS score of 255 or greater.And they are the ONLY PLAYERS to have done this.They have all been elected to the Hall of Fame.

Player POS. CWS CV NEWS
Earl Averill
CF 280 268 271
Hank Greenberg
1B 267 262 263
Lou Boudreau
SS 277 255 261
Bill Terry
1B 278 255 261
Larry Doby
CF 268 257 260
Jackie Robinson
2B 257 257 257
Mickey Cochrane
C 275 250 256
Kirby Puckett
CF 281 247 256
Bill Dickey
C 314 235 255

As noted above, only ninety-three (93) 20 th century position players have Hall of Fame numbers according to the NEWS HOF Gauge.

The Other Hall of Famers – Do Not Have HOF Numbers

Player CWS CV NEWS
Ernie Banks
332 247 268
Willie Keeler
333 246 268
Orlando Cepeda
310 251 266
Edd Roush
314 250 266
Enos Slaughter
323 246 265
Pee Wee Reese
314 246 263
Nellie Fox
304 242 258
Billy Herman
298 243 257
Bobby Wallace
345 227 257
Kiki Cuyler
292 244 256
Gabby Hartnett
325 229 253
Sam Rice
327 228 253
George Sisler
292 239 252
Ozzie Smith
325 226 251
Jimmy Collins
274 242 250
Heinie Manush
285 236 248
Harry Hooper
321 221 246
Joe Sewell
277 233 244
Ralph Kiner
242 242 242
Pie Traynor
274 228 240
Bobby Doerr
281 223 238
Johnny Evers
268 226 237
Dave Bancroft
269 222 234
Rabbit Maranville
302 206 230
Jim Bottomley
258 214 225
Tony Lazzeri
252 215 224
Joe Tinker
258 211 223
Chuck Klein
238 217 222
Phil Rizzuto
231 218 221
Hack Wilson
224 220 221
Earle Combs
227 217 220
Red Schoendienst
262 204 219
Luis Aparicio
293 193 218
Lloyd Waner
245 207 217
Frank Chance
237 206 214
Roy Campanella
207 207 207
Ross Youngs
206 206 206
Roger Bresnahan
231 191 201
George Kell
229 192 201
Travis Jackson
211 191 196
Fred Lindstrom
193 182 190
Bill Mazeroski
219 173 185
Ernie Lombardi
218 167 180
Chick Hafey
186 176 179
Ray Schalk
191 167 173
Rick Ferrell
206 150 164
Mobilize your Site
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: