Story by
Cleveland Guardians playoff scenarios, odds in division, wild-card races
- Story by
- Cleveland Guardians playoff scenarios, odds in division, wild-card races
CLEVELAND — The Guardians failed to take care of their own business i n Cleveland Sept. 26 , but they did receive some help in the form of a game-winning triple off the wall in the ninth inning in Boston .
Just a few moments before the Guardians officially lost 7-3 to the Texas Rangers , the Red Sox 's Ceddanne Rafaela drilled a ball off the centerfield wall at Fenway Park for a walk-off win over the Detroit Tigers .
Advertisement
It meant that despite the loss that became official a few minutes later, the Guardians at least retained control of their own destiny for another day. The Tigers loss not only brought Cleveland's magic number to win the division down to two, but it clarified some of the Guardians' potential paths in the playoff races with two games remaining.
The Guardians received another gift a few hours later when the Houston Astros lost to the Los Angeles Angels , which brought their magic number to clinch a wild-card spot down to one.
Heading into Saturday, Sept. 27, the Guardians know they will either be the No. 3 seed as division winners (and therefore hosting the Wild Card Series in Cleveland ), the No. 6 seed as the final wild card team to face the Tigers in Detroit or out of the playoffs entirely. The same situation now applies to the Tigers, as their loss to the Red Sox on Sept. 26 locked the two AL Central contenders out of the Nos. 4/5 seed matchup.
The New York Yankees , Toronto Blue Jays and Red Sox have all secured their playoff berths, along with the Seattle Mariners in the West. In terms of wild-card seeding, neither the Guardians nor the Tigers could catch the three AL East teams, who are now fighting for placement between the East division (which would earn a top-two seed), the No. 4 seed and the No. 5 seed.
Advertisement
In the cases of both the Guardians and Detroit, that means they individually will either be the No. 3 seed as AL Central winners, the No. 6 seed (facing the other in the wild card series) or missing out on the postseason.
To put it even simpler: the Guardians will either host the Wild Card Series in Cleveland, travel to Detroit or pack up for the winter.
Here's a breakdown of all the Guardians' potential playoff scenarios entering Saturday, Sept. 27.
If the Guardians win their two remaining games
If the Guardians finish out the season with two wins, the result is simple: they are the division champs and will be the No. 3 seed in the AL bracket. The best the Tigers could do in this scenario is tie Cleveland by record, and the Guardians own the tiebreaker.
Advertisement
The Guardians would face the No. 6 seed in a best-of-three Wild Card Series in Cleveland, which would be either the Tigers, the Red Sox or the Houston Astros . They would know they don't need to travel for the series and can just wait to see who they're playing at home.
In this way, the Guardians still control their own destiny.
If the Guardians split their remaining two games
This is where it gets more complex, though the Tigers falling to the Red Sox Sept. 26 did simplify things quite a bit, as it means what the Yankees or Blue Jays do no longer has any bearing on the Guardians' seeding.
Advertisement
One aspect of this scenario is straightforward: if the Guardians win one of their final two games, they clinch at least a wild-card spot. The Astros losing Friday night means Cleveland just needs to avoid losing the rest of the way to punch its ticket to October.
As for the division, if the Guardians win one of their two final games, the Tigers would need to win both of their remaining games to steal the No. 3 seed. If that happens, the Tigers are the No. 3 seed and host their series in Detroit against the Guardians as the No. 6.
The Astros not being able to sweep the Los Angeles Angels took a lot of pressure off the Guardians, as the only way they could miss the playoffs now is if they lose their remaining two games of the season.
Texas Rangers right fielder Billy McKinney, left, and relief pitcher Phil Maton celebrate after the Rangers beat the Cleveland Guardians on Sept. 26, 2025, in Cleveland.
If the Guardians lose their final two games
This is the scenario that potentially involves the Guardians suddenly having to pack up for the winter.
Advertisement
If they lose out, it's roughly an even chance as to where they end up — including out of the postseason altogether.
They could theoretically still pop champagne as AL Central champs without winning another game if the Tigers were also swept in Boston.
They could still make the playoffs as a wild-card team and the No. 6 seed to face Detroit if the Astros were to lose one more game over the weekend. That would leave Houston on the outside looking in even without the Guardians earning another victory.
But if the Guardians lose their two games, the Tigers win at least one game in Boston and the Astros win their final two, Cleveland's season will be finished.
Advertisement
Guardians magic number in playoff races
Cleveland's magic number to secure a playoff spot is down to one entering Saturday, Sept 27. One Guardians win or one Astros loss will send Cleveland to the postseason.
The Guardians' magic number to win the AL Central is two. A Cleveland win or a Tigers loss will lower it.
American League playoff bracket
If the season were to end the morning of Saturday, Sept. 27, the Blue Jays (No. 1 seed) and Mariners (No. 2 seed) would earn first-round byes.
The Guardians, as the No. 3 seed, would face the No. 6 Tigers in Cleveland.
The Yankees and Red Sox would meet as the Nos. 4 and 5 seeds in New York.
This article originally appeared on Akron Beacon Journal: Breaking down the Cleveland Guardians 2025 playoff scenarios, standings
