The Yankees hit .235 in 2026 and struck out in 24.7 percent of their plate appearances. Otto Lopez hit .305 and struck out 13.0 percent of the time. That's a trade possibility worth investigating before New York decides every infield assignment is untouchable.
I'd ask Miami about Lopez, then evaluate the cost and the positions together. George Lombard Jr.'s future matters, but protecting one penciled-in position shouldn't automatically rule out a player who could make the overall infield better. It also shouldn't give the Yankees permission to pay any prospect price the Marlins name.
September 2026 Marlins archive; Lopez has not been traded to the Yankees. Sep 19, 2026; San Diego, California, USA; Miami Marlins shortstop Otto Lopez (6) reacts after striking out during the sixth inning against the San Diego Padres at Petco Park. Mandatory Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images Credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Joseph Randazzo proposed the fit at Yankees On SI on Sunday . The underlying market reporting is narrower: Barry Jackson of the Miami Herald reported that Miami would listen to offers for Lopez and Xavier Edwards if the return were substantial, as MLB Trade Rumors relayed . No verified Yankees negotiations or proposed package accompany this idea.
His official 2026 line was .305/.349/.437 with 11 home runs, 34 stolen bases and 89 strikeouts in 687 plate appearances. Putting the ball in play that often would address a weakness New York showed over a full season. The appeal goes beyond his home run total.
There is a trade-off within the line. Lopez drew only 40 walks, a 5.8 percent rate. His on-base value depended heavily on collecting hits, so a buyer needs to examine how much of the .305 average can last. He had a .673 OPS in 2025 before improving to .786 in 2026.
I'd value the contact without assuming the best season becomes his permanent baseline. Miami controls him through 2029, according to the Jackson report relayed by MLBTR, and a meaningful acquisition cost would reflect that control as well as his recent production.
0What do you think? Post a comment.
Randazzo's concept puts Lopez at shortstop and moves Lombard elsewhere. That deserves evaluation, but it isn't the only alignment worth discussing. Lopez logged 1,357 innings at short in 2026; he also played 265 1/3 innings at second in 2025.
Past second-base work doesn't prove he'd provide identical defense there now. It does give the Yankees a reason to compare both arrangements before describing this as an automatic choice between acquiring Lopez and believing in Lombard.
The serious alternative is to keep the internal plan and buy a cheaper upgrade elsewhere if Miami's demand is too high. There is no actual package to endorse today. The useful next step is a market inquiry and a positional evaluation, with a price limit based on more than one excellent batting average.
Related Headlines
