Dallas Cowboys appeared to have the game under control after taking a 24-10 lead with 14:20 remaining. However, Tyler Allgeier's explosive runs and Gardner Minshew's passing turned the contest around. Arizona scored 20 points late in regulation before Chad Ryland sealed the 33-30 overtime win with a 42-yard field goal. It was the first time in Cowboys history that they had blown a fourth-quarter lead of at least 14 points at home.
Honestly, Dallas had opportunities to close out the game, including after recovering an onside kick and during overtime. Poor offensive execution, defensive breakdowns and questionable game management all contributed. Dak Prescott also refused to blame Schottenheimer alone, stressing that the entire team must take responsibility.
Why the Cowboys' Playoff Hopes Are Now at Stake
CBS Sports gave the Cowboys an 'F' grade for their Week 8 performance, describing the defeat as an inexcusable loss. Arizona piled up 222 offensive yards in the fourth quarter and scored touchdowns on all three of its possessions. The Cowboys' defense has now allowed at least 20 points in 15 consecutive games, the longest active streak in the league.
In contrast, Arizona received a 'B' from CBS Sports. Minshew's three touchdown passes after replacing Jacoby Brissett transformed the offense. His connection with Michael Wilson helped Arizona complete an improbable comeback.
At 3-5, the Cowboys are struggling to keep pace in the NFC East. They have scored 30 or more points in five games but have repeatedly failed to protect leads. Better defensive communication, improved tackling, and more decisive offensive play-calling are essential if Dallas wants to revive its playoff hopes.
Brian Schottenheimer's Job Status: Can the Head Coach Be Blamed Alone?

Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones looks looks on prior to the game against the Green Bay Packers at Lambeau Field.Jeff Hanisch-Imagn Images via Reuters Connect
Jerry Jones dismissed the possibility of an immediate coaching change, saying, "I made a change with Wade Phillips there in the middle of the season, and I don't see that here." He also admitted, "A lot of people let Brian down today." His comments suggest that he considers the defeat a collective failure rather than Schottenheimer's responsibility alone.
The head coach accepted responsibility, saying , "I'm a worker, I'm a problem solver." He also pointed to the positive first-half performance and Quinnen Williams' pass-rushing contribution. Dak Prescott backed him up, insisting that the blame should not fall on one person. Dallas now travels to face the Indianapolis Colts (2-6) on November 8. A victory would give Schottenheimer a chance to rebuild confidence and keep the season alive.
More Dallas Cowboys news
This story was originally published by Athlon on Nov 2, 2026, where it first appeared in the NFL section. Add Athlon as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
