Ex-NFL receiver Alshon Jeffery denies insurance fraud: 'Just miscommunication'

Story by

Story by
Ex-NFL receiver Alshon Jeffery denies insurance fraud: 'Just miscommunication'

Brent Schrotenboer, USA TODAY · USA TODAY Sports

Thu, Apr 23, 2026 ·

3 min read

About Our Ads

SAN DIEGO – Retired Super Bowl-winning NFL receiver Alshon Jeffery showed up in court here on April 23, and pleaded not guilty to two felony charges of insurance fraud after failing to show up in court for his last scheduled court appearance March 9.

Jeffery, who played for the Philadelphia Eagles and Chicago Bears, also issued a denial of the allegations against him through his attorney, Brian Watkins.

"This case is just a miscommunication mishap," Watkins told USA TODAY Sports after the court proceeding. "The insurance company didn't pay out any money or anything. It's all just miscommunication. It's not even really a case."

San Diego prosecutors disagree. The case stems from a car crash last September, when Jeffery rear-ended a Lyft driver's Tesla on northbound Interstate 5 in San Diego County. According to court records from prosecutors obtained by USA TODAY Sports , Jeffery had no insurance coverage when the crash happened on Sept. 21, but he filed a false claim stating the accident happened Sept. 28 − after he obtained a new insurance policy on Sept. 24.

Repair estimates showed $13,058.90 in damages to Jeffery's 2021 Mercedes, while the Lyft driver's Tesla sustained more than $10,000 in damage, according to a court filing from an investigator for the San Diego County District Attorney.

Jeffery, 36, was pulled over and arrested in Encinitas, California, April 15, after his failure to appear in court last time led to a warrant for his arrest, according to the San Diego County Sherriff's Office.

Jeffery appeared this time in front of San Diego Superior Court Judge Aaron Katz and let his attorney do most of the talking in court. Dressed in black dress pants and a light jacket, Jeffery affirmed to the judge he was waiving his right to a preliminary hearing within 10 court days of his not-guilty plea on April 23.

The preliminary hearing is now scheduled for July 13.

Highmark Stadium. Buffalo Bills. Opening in 2026.
(Shawn Dowd, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle)

Allegiant Stadium. Las Vegas Raiders. Opened in 2020.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

SoFi Stadium. Los Angeles Chargers and Los Angeles Rams. Opened in 2020.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Mercedes-Benz Stadium. Atlanta Falcons. Opened in 2017.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

U.S. Bank Stadium. Minnesota Vikings. Opened in 2016.
(Brace Hemmelgarn, USA TODAY Sports)

Levi's Stadium. San Francisco 49ers. Opened in 2014.
(Sergio Estrada, USA TODAY Sports)

MetLife Stadium. New York Giants and New York Jets. Opened in 2010.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

AT&T Stadium. Dallas Cowboys. Opened in 2009.
(Jerome Miron, USA TODAY Sports)

Lucas Oil Stadium. Indianapolis Colts. Opened in 2008.
(Aaron Doster, USA TODAY Sports)

State Farm Stadium. Arizona Cardinals. Opened in 2006.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Lincoln Financial Field. Philadelphia Eagles. Opened in 2003.
(Eric Hartline, USA TODAY Sports)

Ford Field. Detroit Lions. Opened in 2002.
(Tim Fuller, USA TODAY Sports)

NRG Stadium. Houston Texans. Opened in 2002.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Gillette Stadium. New England Patriots. Opened in 2002.
(Mark J. Rebilas, USA TODAY Sports)

Lumen Field. Seattle Seahawks. Opened in 2002.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Empower Field at Mile High. Denver Broncos. Opened in 2001.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Acrisure Stadium. Pittsburgh Steelers. Opened in 2001.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Huntington Bank Field. Cleveland Browns. Opened in 1999.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Nissan Stadium. Tennessee Titans. Opened in 1999.
(Christopher Hanewinckel, USA TODAY)

M&T Bank Stadium. Baltimore Ravens. Opened in 1998.
(Kirby Lee, USA TODAY Sports)

Raymond James Stadium. Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Opened in 1998.
(Aaron Doster, USA TODAY Sports)

Northwest Stadium. Washington Football Team. Opened in 1997.
(Kareem Elgazzar, Cincinnati Enquirer)

Bank of America Stadium. Carolina Panthers. Opened in 1996.
(Jim Dedmon, USA TODAY Sports)

EverBank Stadium. Jacksonville Jaguars. Opened in 1995.
(Douglas DeFelice, USA TODAY Sports)

Hard Rock Stadium. Miami Dolphins. Opened in 1987.
(Jasen Vinlove, USA TODAY Sports)

Caesars Superdome. New Orleans Saints. Opened in 1975.
(Chuck Cook, USA TODAY Sports)

Arrowhead Stadium. Kansas City Chiefs. Opened in 1972.
(Denny Medley, USA TODAY Sports)

Lambeau Field. Green Bay Packers. Opened in 1957.
(Jeff Hanisch, USA TODAY Sports)

Soldier Field. Chicago Bears. Opened in 1924.
(Matt Cashore, USA TODAY Sports)

By hiring Watkins, Jeffery is getting an attorney with experience in high-profile local cases. Watkins previously represented former NFL star tight end Kellen Winslow in his trial on rape charges in San Diego County in 2019. Watkins also represented aspiring marketer Lloyd Lake in his civil case against former USC football star Reggie Bush – a case that helped lead to sanctions against the USC football program .

Jeffery earned more than $63 million during his NFL career from 2012 to 2020, according to Spotrac. He played college football at South Carolina and was selected by the Chicago Bears in the second round of the 2012 NFL draft. He was named to the Pro Bowl after the 2013 season and later was named one of the team's best 100 players of all-time (No. 80) in the team's centennial scrapbook in 2019.

After signing with the Eagles in 2017, Jeffery caught three passes for 73 yards and a touchdown in the Super Bowl in 2018, when the Eagles beat the New England Patriots 41-33.

Court records show Jeffery recently has lived in Encinitas, a coastal city in north San Diego County.

Follow reporter Brent Schrotenboer @Schrotenboer . Email: bschrotenb@usatoday.com

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Former NFL receiver Alshon Jeffery denies insurance fraud allegations

Mobilize your Website

View Site in Mobile | Classic

Share by:

Ex-NFL receiver Alshon Jeffery denies insurance fraud: 'Just miscommunication'

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams

Take a look at the home stadiums for all 32 NFL teams