Yahoo
There is no stage. The show is done inside a restaurant's banquet room.
The Mystery Cafe Dinner Theater

Website: themysterycafeindy.com

Phone: (317) 684-0668

Cross Streets: Near the intersection of S Lynhurst Dr and W Southern Ave

Closing soon · 6 PM

  • Fri 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM

2610 S Lynhurst Dr, The Library Restaurant & Pub Indianapolis, IN 46241 ·384.79 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly
4.5
25 reviews
5 star
19 4 star
2 3 star
2 2 star
0 1 star
2
Tripadvisor traveler marlenae2021 05/18/26

We had such a fun time at the Murder Mystery Café dinner at The Library Restaurant Pub! It was entertaining from start to finish with no downtime at all. The whole night kept moving smoothly between drinks, food service, and the murder mystery itself, which made it so much fun. I loved that more than half the guests got speaking parts, which made it really interactive and engaging. The hosts were so friendly, kind, and professional, and the service was excellent. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a fun and different night out!

More
Tripadvisor traveler Susan R 11/17/25

My friend and I went there on an adventure to participate in a playful murder mystery where small parts were assigned and enacted between meal courses. We enjoyed wearing costumes and playing our parts, as well as the Hannah House setting, puzzles, and lively fun!

More
Tripadvisor traveler windyrocksindy1 04/05/25

The performers were funny, the dinner was great, and the atmosphere was fun.My family & friends all got to be in the show and we had a blast! The show was a very cute theme. Amber was a great waitress! JoeTraceyPetraZaneAmber& The Library Restaurant & Pub were all fantastic!

More
Tripadvisor traveler Dustin H 07/30/24

First time trying something like this and we had so much fun. The food was good and the entertainment was even better. Definitely recommend

More
Tripadvisor traveler Cheryl H 05/14/18

This is a Great Dinner/Theater. We had a group of 9 women out for some Mother's day fun. The food was delicious and the set up was awesome. They worked the show in between the food courses, making it easy for audience participation. Highly recommend it and will be back again.

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: