Yahoo
Traditional Combo Chicago Stuffed
The Beachum Thin Crust Pizza
Carne Special Stuffed Pizza
Huge bar inside the restaurant
Deep dish Carne Special Stuffed Pizza
Antipasto
Carne special
Great taste, plenty left over, must try! This was our first experience and definitely coming back.
Tortugas Pizza
Great deal
Tortugas Pizza Pizza ·$$

Website: tortugaspizza.com

Phone: (205) 730-9249

Cross Streets: Between 13th St S and 14th St S

Interested in our services?

Closed now

  • Fri 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

1304 2nd Ave S Birmingham, AL 35233 ·516.87 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly
  • Accessible
  • Wifi

Reviews

yelp
4.5 138 reviews
5 star
83 4 star
31 3 star
11 2 star
8 1 star
5
Jody M. 08/08/26

This was my second time eating at Tortugas. Since I don't live local, it is only when I am in the area to swing in and treat myself. They have amazing pizza...both their Chicago style, and their...

More
Brad H. 10/22/26

Fairly small, but not overcrowded on this Thursday night. Excellent selection of local and beers brewed nearby. Service was relatively quick and attentive to our needs. Pizza is very good and...

More
Morgan S. 08/06/26

Some people will tell you that Chicago style pizza isn't real pizza. Well, I'm from New York, and I say who cares? Tortuga's makes great pizza, real or not. I go back every time in Birmingham.

More
Bill D. 11/18/25

Great tasting and hot pizza Takes a little time but it's worth the wait. Pizza is definitely like the classic Chicago pizzas I've had in the Windy City.

More
Jada G. 02/24/26

This was my first time going to Tortugas Pizza, and I was very pleased with my experience! I came in about 30 minutes before they closed, so I was a bit worried I wouldn't be able to order just a...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: