Yahoo
Banana Cream
Salty Chocolate Chess
Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice
Inside
Coconut Custard
Petee's Cafe Cafe ·$$

We make the best pies money can buy using real ingredients. We also have a range of savory options, natural wine, local beer and craft cocktails.

Website: peteespie.com

Phone: (646) 494-3630

Cross Streets: Between Ryerson St and Grand Ave

Open now

  • Thu 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

505 Myrtle Ave Brooklyn, NY 11205 ·347.83 mi

Is this your business? Verify your listing

Amenities

  • Family friendly
  • Accessible
  • Smoke-free

Reviews

yelp
4.0 149 reviews
5 star
94 4 star
17 3 star
16 2 star
13 1 star
9
Carl B. 09/20/26

Epic late night desert! Some of the best apple pie & home made vanilla ice cream I have ever had! If you make it to Brooklyn, NY, save room for dessert!!!

More
Theo P. 05/21/26

So tasty! Authentic and locally sourced this place will have you wanting more. I had the classic apple pie. I'm a huge pie fan and let me tell you this has probably been one of the best pies I've...

More
Miranda M. 01/03/26

This weekend, I had 2 slices of pie from here (Petee's Pie is what this location is listed as online): a Wild Maine Blueberry Slice and a Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice. Upon delivery, we...

More
Serena X. 12/31/25

Tried a cappuccino and blueberry pie as I was walking in the neighborhood, and was pleasantly surprised with the winter special pies available as well. The blueberry pie was not too sweet, and the...

More
Leah O. 11/21/25

Petee's is the best. Every pie I've ever tried here is so good. We were in the neighborhood and decided to have a slice in stores. There's not much seating but it was just me & my partner so we...

More
Advertisement
Mobilize your Website
View Site in Mobile | Classic
Share by: