The Hoosier Mama Pie Company has taken their famous business offline and opened a pie shop baking their classic, old-fashioned recipes locally. All pies are made by hand and from scratch, so you'll feel like you're being spoiled the way you were as a child with every sweet bite. They bake just about every kind imaginable, including the classic all-American Apple Pie, Banana Cream, Coconut Cream, and Lemon Meringue. They throw some newer, deluxe recipes in the mix as well, offering irresistible delights such as the Chocolate Chess, Maple Pecan, Passionfruit Meringue, and Peanut Butter Pie. You won't know which to try first—you'll definitely be coming back again and again.
Website: hoosiermamapie.com
Phone: (312) 243-4846
Cross Streets: Between N Marshfield Ave and N Ashland Ave
Open now
- Sat 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
1618 W Chicago Ave Chicago, IL 60622 ·511.88 mi
Is this your business? Verify your listing
Amenities
- Accessible
- Family friendly
Reviews
yelpThe Hoosier sugar cream was a delight. The pie is very unassuming but has so much flavor. The texture is like a rich custard & that crust is a must! There should be more than 1 person working the...
MoreI'm not really much of a pie person. But I do love a good pie. I decided to finally check out Hoosier Mama and bought a Sugar Cream Pie for myself and an apple pie for my son. The staff here was...
MoreLove it! I recently tried the Queen Victoria which was banana, peanut butter, and meringue and it was even better than it sounded. The chocolate cream is also a go to. The space is very vintage-y...
MoreThis place is a slice of heaven. The pies are out of this world with the best crust ever. The chocolate chip scone is the best I've ever had. I brought the Apple Sour Cherry with Oatmeal Topping...
MoreI love the pie here. You can smell the butter browning as they make the homemade pies on site. The chocolate chess pie tastes like a brownie pie. Perfect level of sweetness and chocolate. The...
More