Story by
3 areas where Steelers HC Mike McCarthy will be different from Mike Tomlin
- Story by
- 3 areas where Steelers HC Mike McCarthy will be different from Mike Tomlin
While the names might be different, many Pittsburgh Steelers fans at the time of hiring Mike McCarthy believed he was Mike Tomlin 2.0, meaning that he was another copy-and-paste from what was previously the norm under Tomlin: 10 wins resulting in one-and-done playoff performances annually. It's easy to lament both coaches' playoff resumes, but if you take a better look underneath the hood, you'd see that McCarthy is nothing like his predecessors. In fact, he couldn't be more different in the way he operates. Previously, people became accustomed to a brand of football that wasn't in line with the modern NFL, but that's about to change starting next season. There are many areas where McCarthy has Tomlin beat; these three will truly separate him in no time: a philosophy that is offense-first, assembly of a corporate coaching staff, and total autonomy on defense.
1. Offense First Philosophy and Approach
Whether the Dallas Cowboys or Green Bay Packers , Mike McCarthy's game plans and roster construction were always centered on an offense-first approach. Under Tomlin, it was the other way around, with defense and a run-heavy, conservative approach. McCarthy brings a modern West Coast offensive system emphasizing horizontal spacing, rhythmic alignment between route depths and quarterback footwork, and timing tendencies that are aggressive downfield and fast-paced. Speaking of rhythm, receivers are expected to win their battles against cornerbacks attempting to jam them at the line of scrimmage, positioning themselves precisely where the quarterback hits them mid-stride. To sustain such a rhythm, maximum pre-snap autonomy is given to the quarterback on offense, as he will be auditing live at the line in coverage looks. One of his specialties will be aggressively passing on early downs, being uptempo, and showing no-huddle, where his best and most efficient units ranked near the top in first-down passing attempts, keeping his offenses ahead of their sticks. 55 touches is the benchmark, as maintaining ball possession, controlling tempo, and sustaining drives are prioritized over chunk gains.
Advertisement
Pre-snap motion/shift and positional versatility are also staples, as he'll motion players to isolate defensive backs and create spatial leverage, creating an illusion of complexity that forces defenses into schematic alignments that are predictable, allowing an offense to run concepts that are lightning-fast and basic. Route-wise, wideouts in this offense will run hitches, crossers, flat routes, and slants, horizontally stretching the field and creating major yards after the catch. McCarthy prefers his wideouts to be versatile, playing across all three wide receiver spots (Slot, Z, X) to take advantage of mismatches defensively. Personnel-wise, he's evolved from his predominantly used 11-personnel (3 wide receivers) to more 12-personnel or 22-personnel (2 tight ends, 2 running backs). On the matchup, he'll also dial up specific packages for the fullback position. Tight ends are not ignored, unlike what Arthur Smith would do, as the position is an extension of the offensive line, lining up out wide on pre-snap shifts, and often is peppering them with targets inside the red zone. For the running back position, McCarthy doesn't just rely on inside/outside zones and duo-heavy rushing attacks; he also takes conceptual advantage of short-yardage flats, defensive tempo, and protecting quarterbacks with clean pockets. While pass-heavy foundations invite higher threats of hitting the quarterback, he systematically uses various run packages that freeze pass rushers and help secure the pocket.
2. Hiring Practices and Analytical Embrace
For what was the smallest and least innovative coaching staff assembled, Mike McCarthy changed all that in just one offseason, constructing the largest staff in franchise history, with new dedicated roles specializing in areas such as game management, chief of staff, and analytics. He is someone who believes larger staffs lead to better player development, segmenting positions all the way down to coordinators overseeing the running and passing games, and multiple assistants at every position. McCarthy prefers adding new voices and ideas into the room, as preventing playbook staleness from taking root is key. With his staff being as large as it is, players will receive a strong dose of individualized attention. Assistants from each position are split up and tasked with coaching them on a smaller scale (see Jahri Evans , assistant offensive line coach, for example, working side by side with Gennings Dunker and Mason McCormick ).
McCarthy has put together a multi-layered teaching environment, with several coaches contributing to a single position, such as situational math, training fundamentals, and macro offensive design during live games. Essentially, he is in charge of the macro game plan, and everyone below him handles the micro components, leaving McCarthy to focus solely on running the offense, as clockwork, game logistics, and defensive play-calling are handled by his analytical and administrative staffers (this helps a ton in executing late-game situations without gaffes arising). While many head coaches hire people who are loyal to them, McCarthy does the exact opposite; he regularly seeks out those who are completely outside his coaching tree or from the collegiate ranks, wanting his own ideas to be challenged and sharpened simultaneously. He also values the experience of former players, as they teach the technicalities and finer details to rookies and younger players, accelerating their development.
Advertisement
3. Defensive Staff Receiving Total Autonomy
Mike Tomlin was the one who ran the Steelers defense left to right, micromanaging it till the very end, but that will be non-existent in Pittsburgh in 2026, as McCarthy has granted his newly hired defensive coordinator, Patrick Graham, creative freedom and final authority over the defense and playbook, practically making him the head coach on that side of the ball. This is a career-long approach of the Pittsburgh native, as outsourcing such responsibilities allows him to do what he does best: offense, where he can work one-on-one with his quarterbacks, call plays, and scheme up how the next drive will go. This also allows Graham to hire whomever he and assistant head coach/secondary coach Joe Whitt Jr. wish, aligning with their vision. They do not have to be dependent on the logic of a Texas Coast offense under McCarthy for the defensive coaching staff in how it chooses to innovate, rather than being tied to the biases of the head coach.
It is an independent operation separate from the offensive coaching staff, as they do not have to filter schematic adjustments and personnel changes through the CEO in charge of the whole show. McCarthy also believes forcing an offensive philosophy onto his defensive staff could potentially stunt how innovative they truly are. He has an immense amount of trust in his structure, completely detaching himself during games from defensive channels of communication, and refusing to meddle with the defense even in pivotal moments. As for practices and weekly preparation, McCarthy does not program specific drills or activities for them, nor does he ever inject blitzes, coverages, and stunts of his own mid-quarter; he only structures how long they go for in length. Defenses under him can implement even the most sophisticated of sub-packages, neutralizing opposing offenses. They don't have to compromise just to fit themselves within his scope, as they can do everything they want in real time on the sidelines without interference.
For up-to-date Steelers coverage, including any offseason moves, follow us on X @TheSteelersWire and give our Facebook page a like.
This article originally appeared on Steelers Wire: 3 areas where Steelers HC Mike McCarthy will be different from Mike Tomlin
