Columbus Blue Jackets fall 5-4 to Pittsburgh Penguins in overtime

Story by

Story by
Columbus Blue Jackets fall 5-4 to Pittsburgh Penguins in overtime

Dan Aulbach, Columbus Dispatch · The Columbus Dispatch

Sun, Jan 4, 2026 ·

6 min read

About Our Ads

The Blue Jackets built a 4-1 lead on Jan. 4 but failed to pressure the Pittsburgh Penguins on offense past the first period. The result was a 5-4 overtime loss, the third time the Jackets have lost against the Penguins this season after holding a multi-goal lead.

After Rickard Rakell pushed the puck past Columbus goalie Jet Greaves with 12.8 seconds remaining in regulation, Penguins star center Sidney Crosby delivered the game-winner in overtime.

"I feel like sometimes when we get a lead, we just resort to almost playing too simple and just giving the puck to the other team," Blue Jackets defenseman Zach Werenski said. "Obviously, good teams will make you pay like that."

The Penguins scored at the 1:50 mark with Ville Koivunen converting an unassisted shot. The Jackets turned on the afterburners shortly after. Getting the puck in the offensive zone, defenseman Denton Mateychuk fired a shot from the left side of the ice that Dmitri Voronkov tipped in for his 15th goal of the season.

Less than a minute later, Kirill Marchenko found Adam Fantilli , who pushed the puck to the goalie. The shot was blocked, but Mason Marchment converted the rebound to give the Jackets a 2-1 lead.

The Jackets got another boost before the end of the first period. Werenski fired a perfect pass to Marchenko on the left side of the net for his 15th goal of the season.

Werenski delivered again to begin the second period. Jackets captain Boone Jenner played physically behind the Penguins' net to regain possession on a forecheck and passed it to a swerving Werenski in the center of the ice. Werenski took it to the net himself to score.

After Werenksi's goal, the Penguins surmounted offensive pressure. Taking advantage of sloppy Blue Jackets' clearing efforts, Penguins fourth-line winger Noel Acciari received a through pass from Connor Dewar . He cut the deficit to two goals against a cooling Blue Jackets' offense.

A key to the Blue Jackets' late-December success was penalty kill, as they prevented goals on over nine power-play minutes against the Buffalo Sabres on Jan. 3. But the Blue Jackets had a breakdown on the Penguins' first power play minutes of the third period. Despite winning a faceoff in the defensive zone, Mateychuk lost the puck while the Penguins found a wide-open Tommy Novak to make it a one-score game.

With 12.8 seconds remaining, the Penguins got their clutch moment from the first line with 12.8 seconds remaining when Rakell scored directly in front of the net.

"We extended our shift at the end, too. We should have had more jump," Blue Jackets coach Dean Evason said. "We've got to trust our teammates in that situation as well."

Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman Ivan Provorov skates with the puck against the Pittsburgh Penguins in the second period at Nationwide Arena.

Ex-Blue Jacket Yegor Chinakhov makes return to Columbus after trade to Pittsburgh Penguins

Last month, Yegor Chinakhov was playing on the second line for the Jackets. On Jan. 3, he entered Nationwide Arena as a visitor for the first time in his career, playing third line for the Penguins six days after being traded for draft capital and Danton Heinen .

Chinakhov scored his first goal for the Penguins Jan. 3 against the Detroit Red Wings . He received some boos in the first period when shown on the Blue Jackets' jumbotron sitting on the bench. He finished with 12:39 time on ice and a +1 plus-minus rating.

Who was scratched for the Columbus Blue Jackets game against the Pittsburgh Penguins?

The Blue Jackets scratched Sean Monahan and Dysin Mayo in back-to-back games against the Sabres on Jan. 3 and Penguins Jan. 4.

Monahan was a late scratch for "maintenance" ahead of the Blue Jackets' road game against the Senators Dec. 28 and has yet to return to the lineup. Mayo, a defenseman, remains on the roster because of Brendan Smith 's lower-body injury, but Mayo was scratched because of the return of Zach Werenski . Smith went on IR on Jan. 2.

Columbus Blue Jackets schedule 2025-26

October

Oct 9: @ Nashville , 2–1, Loss
Oct 11: @ Minnesota , 7–4, Win
Oct 13: vs New Jersey , 3–2, Loss
Oct 16: vs Colorado , 4–1, Loss
Oct 18: vs Tampa Bay , 3–2, Win
Oct 21: @ Dallas , 5–1, Win
Oct 24: vs Washington , 5–1, Loss
Oct 25: @ Pittsburgh, 5–4 SO, Win
Oct 28: @ Buffalo, 4–3 OT, Win
Oct 29: vs Toronto , 6–3, Win

November

Nov 1: vs St. Louis , 3–2, Win
Nov 2: @ Islanders , 3–2, Loss
Nov 5: @ Calgary , 5–1, Loss
Nov 8: @ Vancouver , 4–3, Loss
Nov 10: @ Edmonton , 5–4 OT, Loss
Nov 11: @ Seattle , 2–1 SO, Win
Nov 13: vs Edmonton, 5–4, Win
Nov 15: vs Rangers , 2–1 SO, Loss
Nov 17: vs Montreal , 4–3 SO, Win
Nov 18: @ Winnipeg , 5–2, Loss
Nov 20: @ Toronto, 3–2 OT, Win
Nov 22: @ Detroit, 4–3 OT, Loss
Nov 24: @ Washington, 5–1, Loss
Nov 26: vs Toronto, 2–1 OT, Loss
Nov 28: vs Pittsburgh, 4–3 OT, Loss

December

Dec 1: @ New Jersey, 5–3, Win
Dec 4: vs Detroit, 6–5 SO, Win
Dec 6: @ Florida , 7–6 OT, Loss
Dec 7: @ Washington, 2–0, Loss
Dec 9: @ Carolina, 4–1, Loss
Dec 11: vs Ottawa , 6–3, Loss
Dec 13: vs Vegas , 3–2, Loss
Dec 16: vs Anaheim , 4–3 OT, Win
Dec 18: vs Minnesota, 5–2, Loss
Dec 20: @ Anaheim, 4-3 Loss
Dec 22: @ Los Angeles , 3-2 Win
Dec 28: vs Islanders, 4-2 Win
Dec 29: @ Ottawa, 4-3 Win
Dec 31: vs New Jersey, 3-1 Loss

January

Jan 3: vs Buffalo, 5-1 Win
Jan 4: vs Pittsburgh, 5-4 OT, Loss
Jan 6: @ San Jose , 10:00 PM
Jan 8: @ Vegas, 10:00 PM
Jan 10: @ Colorado, 4:00 PM
Jan 11: @ Utah, 7:00 PM
Jan 13: vs Calgary, 7:00 PM
Jan 15: vs Vancouver, 7:00 PM
Jan 17: @ Pittsburgh, 7:00 PM
Jan 20: vs Ottawa, 7:00 PM
Jan 22: vs Dallas, 7:00 PM
Jan 24: vs Tampa Bay, 7:00 PM
Jan 26: vs Los Angeles, 7:00 PM
Jan 28: vs Philadelphia , 7:30 PM
Jan 30: @ Chicago , 8:30 PM
Jan 31: @ St. Louis, 7:00 PM

February

Feb 3: @ New Jersey, 7:00 PM
Feb 4: vs Chicago, 7:00 PM
Feb 26: @ Boston , 7:00 PM
Feb 28: vs Islanders, 6:00 PM

March

March 2: @ Rangers, 7:00 PM
March 3: vs Nashville, 7:00 PM
March 5: vs Florida, 7:00 PM
March 7: vs Utah, 7:00 PM
March 10: @ Tampa Bay, 7:00 PM
March 12: @ Florida, 7:00 PM
March 14: @ Philadelphia, 7:30 PM
March 17: vs Carolina, 7:00 PM
March 19: vs Rangers, 7:00 PM
March 21: vs Seattle, 5:00 PM
March 22: @ Islanders, 7:00 PM
March 24: @ Philadelphia, 7:00 PM
March 26: @ Montreal, 7:00 PM
March 28: vs San Jose, 5:00 PM
March 29: vs Boston, 5:00 PM
March 31: vs Carolina, 7:30 PM

April

April 2: @ Carolina, 7:00 PM
April 4: vs Winnipeg, 7:00 PM
April 7: @ Detroit, 7:00 PM
April 9: @ Buffalo, 7:00 PM
April 11: @ Montreal, 7:00 PM
April 12: vs Boston, 6:00 PM
April 14: vs Washington, 7:00 PM

This story was updated to include quotes.

This article originally appeared on The Columbus Dispatch: Columbus Blue Jackets drop 1st period lead, lose 5-4 in OT to Penguins

Mobilize your Website

View Site in Mobile | Classic

Share by: