Wander Franco is guilty of sexually abusing a 14-year-old girl in 2023, a judge in the Dominican Republic made clear Monday.
Yet in his next breath, the same judge ruled that the former Tampa Bay Rays star shortstop will not be sentenced to prison because he was a victim of blackmail and extortion by the girl's mother.
Celebrity justice in the D.R. can be perplexing, and Judge José Antonio Núñez admitted as much. But he also contended that the judicial pardon he granted Franco was the result of "logical and legal reasoning."
"It seems contradictory to declare criminal responsibility and, at the same time, exempt him from punishment," Núñez said. "The court has granted Wander Franco a judicial pardon due to the particular circumstances that made him a material victim, but not a legal one."
The court found that the girl's mother extorted thousands of dollars from Franco. The woman was sentenced to 10 years in prison on charges of commercial sexual exploitation of a minor and money laundering.
Read more: Rays' Wander Franco found guilty in sex abuse case, receives two-year suspended sentence
The odds are long that Franco will return to Major League Baseball any time soon. The fact that the court found him guilty of repeatedly having sex with a minor puts him squarely in violation of MLB's Joint Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault and Child Abuse Policy.
The league is in the midst of an investigation into Franco's conduct.
"We respect the legal process and the decision issued by the court," the Rays said in a statement. "This is a serious matter, and our thoughts remain with those affected by the case.
"The Rays will continue to cooperate fully with Major League Baseball as it completes its review under the league's Joint Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault and Child Abuse Policy. Out of respect for the legal process and all parties involved, we will have no further comment at this time."
Franco's situation serves as a cautionary tale for MLB teams that hand out long-term contracts years before players become free agents. The Rays signed a 20-year-old Franco to an 11-year, $182 million deal in November 2021 after he batted .288 with 30 extra-base hits in 70 games as a rookie.
Franco appeared on his way to stardom during a stellar 2023 season, but according to court filings he carried on a relationship with the 14-year-old victim for several months.
Read more: A star pitcher at USC, he was cut after six years in the minors. Then Banana Ball came calling
An investigation was launched in August 2023. Franco was arrested Jan. 1, 2024, after failing to appear before Dominican authorities who sought to interview him.
Tampa Bay placed him on the restricted list early in the 2024 season, voiding his contract.
Franco was found guilty in a June 2025 trial. Although prosecutors sought a five-year prison sentence, he was given only a two-year suspended sentence by Justice Jakayra Veras.
"Look at us, Wander," Veras said in open court. "Do not approach minors for sexual purposes. If you don't like people very close to your age, you have to wait your time."
An appeals court in December ordered a new trial, which took place Monday and resulted in his pardon.
"Thank God for everything," Franco said as he embraced his mother, Nancy Aybar, after Judge Nuñez announced the pardon.
As he departed the courthouse, Franco was asked by a reporter how he felt.
"I feel calm," he said.
This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times .
