Story by
Jeremy Lin breaks down why the Knicks' Linsanity-era superteam never clicked and fell apart
- Story by
- Jeremy Lin breaks down why the Knicks' Linsanity-era superteam never clicked and fell apart
Nobody can blame the New York Knicks and their faithful for celebrating their recent title conquest the way they did. Five-plus decades, after all, is a very long time to wait for another championship. Add to that all the frustration and pain the franchise and its fans have endured from bad luck or underachieving rosters, and the Knicks have every reason to bask in their time under the sun.
One team that had the makings of a team that could make some noise in the Eastern Conference was the 2012 Knicks. With All-Stars Carmelo Anthony and Amar'e Stoudemire, they had plenty of firepower to go toe-to-toe with the league's elite teams. Add to that the emergence of Jeremy Lin , who proved himself capable of becoming an All-Star in the league, and the Knicks had a solid trio who could have pushed them to new heights.
Advertisement
But according to Lin, while the Knicks certainly had a strong roster at the time, they lacked continuity and a clear understanding of their roles.
The lack of a clear direction
As the Knicks' season concluded with a first-round loss to the Miami Heat , the team's front office had many questions to answer, all of which could have been resolved had they known which path to take.
"What I'm saying is so complicated because ownership is unsure. The front office is kind of split. The coaching staff is split. And the players are split because we're trying to figure out what direction this ship is going in," Lin said during his appearance on Anthony's podcast.
Advertisement
"Looking back, it's actually the same point that I've been making all along. We could have coexisted if we had the time and the intentionality to figure it out. And that's where we were trying to get to," Lin continued.
"But the reality was, even on the player side, things were kind of split, right? Some players were very suitable to complement Melo and what he was great at. Some of the younger role players, we had a thing going, and we had it figured out. So now everybody is kind of unsure," he added.
What made the situation murkier was Lin's contract situation. With him being a restricted free agent, the Knicks waited for other teams to tender their offer before deciding on whether or not to match it. The prolific guard who played college basketball at Harvard eventually signed a three-year, $25 million contract with the Houston Rockets .
Advertisement
The lack of communication doomed that team
The height of "Linsanity" in February 2012 came during a time when both Anthony and Stoudemire were sidelined by injuries. This meant that without the two ball-dominant players, Lin had complete control of possessions. However, their return complicated that dynamic.
Advertisement
At the same time, their return coincided with his knee injury in late March, which kept him from finishing the season.
"Honestly, looking back, I think it's just so confusing. At the same time, I'm also like, I don't know if anybody really knew what the other person was totally thinking. The reason is because when I came onto the scene, Stat and Melo were hurt," he recalled. "Then Stat comes back. A little bit later, Melo comes back. Then I get hurt."
"So the continuity isn't there. The conversations aren't there. The reps and the experience of winning games, losing games, and figuring things out weren't there either."
Advertisement
On paper, the Knicks had all the pieces to be a force to be reckoned with in the 2010s. But every fan knows that excelling in the NBA takes a lot more than just talent; a team also needs cohesion and trust — virtues this year's Knicks had plenty of.
This story was originally published by Basketball Network on Jun 15, 2026, where it first appeared in the Old School section. Add Basketball Network as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
