Story by
Looking for college football's magic bullet? It's academic eligibility
- Story by
- Looking for college football's magic bullet? It's academic eligibility
The solution is right there staring back at them, a lost standard from the past with a full tank just itching to get back in the fight.
Yet the current acting NCAA — the presidents and chancellors of the SEC and Big Ten — has virtually ignored it. In fact, all but walked away from it.
Advertisement
If you're looking for the magic bullet of change, if you're desperate to slow an out of control train barreling down the NIL era tracks, let me reintroduce a friend that has somehow been ignored for the past five years.
Academics.
Straight, no frills, classwork.
Freedom has a price: Players, cash, lack of consequences. What could go wrong in NIL world?
The next move: Trinidad Chambliss-led death of NCAA could lead to birth of SEC-only world
Want to get a grip on player movement and ridiculous appeals for extended eligibility? Start focusing on academics again — you know, the education in higher education.
Advertisement
More to the point: academic eligibility.
Forget about NCAA clock eligibility lawsuits from greedy attorneys, or the antitrust threat thrown around every time the NCAA steps foot in a courtroom. These are our academic standards, and you will abide by them. Period.
But when was the last time academics not only forced players to sit out a season, but prevented them from enrolling in school? Or prevented a transfer because credit hours from one school weren't accepted at another?
Look, I don't pretend to know the academic standards of every college and university, but I'm pretty sure a double transfer (or more) can't simply wind up at an Association of American Universities school with a clean transcript.
Advertisement
Or even be accepted.
It's not that difficult to scan transfer portal additions for any FBS school, and see the progression from school to school and realize the absurdity of this exercise.
These universities barely talk among themselves, and have distinctly different academic curriculum. There was a time when universities stood behind academic standards as a badge of honor, refusing to budge for anything or anyone.
Not even a star football player.
Now it appears they've simply decided to go along to get along. You scratch my back, I'll scratch yours. Who cares about transferable credit hours?
Advertisement
At the front of it all, leading the way with baton in hand and proudly stepping out the new beat, is the NCAA. Don't buy the righteous indignation they're selling, everyone.
This is the same group that in 2017, allowed North Carolina — one of the top five public institutions in the country — to argue systemic academic fraud (fake classes) was available to all students, and therefore didn't break NCAA rules.
And I know this is going to shock you (sarcasm alert), the argument worked.
I don't know what was more shocking: that UNC, a bastion of academic integrity, used the argument ― or that the NCAA bought it. All to protect the mighty basketball program.
Advertisement
Six years later, in the early NIL stages of what-the-hell-are-we-doing-here, the NCAA decided to drop standardized SAT and ACT scores for incoming freshmen and opted instead for a minimum 2.3 grade point average on 16 high school core courses.
That's a C-minus average on 16 courses over four years.
This is the same NCAA who decided players must only pass 6-9 credit hours a semester, and 24 over an entire academic year, to stay eligible. Low expectations, everyone, do not lead to high achievers.
Meanwhile, the presidents and chancellors who willingly built this mess and now realize it's not what they want, charged a couple of conference commissioners to lobby Congress — the only organization more dysfunctional than the NCAA — for help to clean up the carnage.
Advertisement
Two conference commissioners who, at this point, can't even agree on the format of a multibillion dollar College Football Playoff.
So players are earning foundational wealth without the restraints of contracts or limited mobility. Coaches are complaining about the system, but not the generational wealth they're earning.
Universities are complaining because once available media rights money and booster contributions are quickly being erased by pay for play and paradigm legal losses.
And here we are, engulfed in a transitory world of annual player movement with a longterm goal of what? That should — and really always has been — the No. 1 question for universities.
Advertisement
What are we working toward, and how do we make it better?
Instead those same universities (see: the NCAA) have systematically removed any academic governor that could slow the self destructive tsunami — when they didn't need to.
The only limitation to athletic and financial player opportunity should be the ability to stay academically eligible, and have classes that transfer toward a degree at your next stop.
But that would take 130-plus FBS schools to welcome back our old friend academic eligibility standards.
The magic bullet itching to get back in the fight.
Matt Hayes is the senior national college football writer for USA TODAY Sports Network. Follow him on X at @MattHayesCFB .
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Return of academic standards key to fixing college football instability
