Mets get more bad news as nightmare season continues

If you trade for an injury-prone player in MLB , expecting them to do anything other than find themselves on the Injured List is pretty shortsighted. The problem is, the New York Mets knew exactly what they were doing and getting themselves into when they traded for Luis Robert . And yet, they did it anyway.

The off-season heading into the 2026 MLB season didn’t go according to plan for the Mets. That might be putting it mildly. I’m not disputing whether or not they had a plan, but we can question the logic and correctness of that plan. The execution of the plan also left a lot to be desired.

MORE: 2026 MLB power rankings as April comes to an end

Unfortunately, the results are clearly evident on the field for the New York Mets. Manager Carlos Mendoza might unfairly pay with his job, as the Mets are showing little to no signs of turning things around. When a team underperforms this badly, changes are inevitable—even if they don’t address the real problem.

Panic Moves Come Back to Haunt Them

As the offseason market dried up, the Mets were left scrambling. That led to some expensive and risky decisions—most notably trading Luisangel Acuña for Luis Robert Jr. The hope was clear: bring in a high-upside talent and hope a change of scenery—and the spotlight of New York—would unlock his full potential.

There has never been doubt about Robert’s ability. But availability and consistency have always been concerns. He’s only played more than 110 games once (in 2023), and even when on the field, maintaining performance has been an issue.

His numbers reflect that decline:

• 14 home runs last season

• .223 batting average

• 53 RBI / 52 runs scored

• 33 stolen bases

The Mets weren’t wrong to take the gamble, but they may have overestimated the environment around him.

A Weak Supporting Cast Makes It Worse

The bigger issue? The lack of structure around him. This lineup has been hit hard:

• Jorge Polanco is on the IL

• Pete Alonso is gone, leaving a massive void

• Brett Baty , Mark Vientos , and Francisco Álvarez are struggling

• Rookie Carson Benge hasn’t found consistency

• Marcus Semien , acquired for Brandon Nimmo , has been a major disappointment

• Francisco Lindor remains out with an extended absence

In a stronger lineup, Robert could have been a complementary piece. Instead, he was asked to carry far more than he should.

Now Another Setback

Even with careful management, it wasn’t enough. Robert is now headed to the Injured List with a back injury, adding yet another blow to an already struggling roster. Before the injury, he was hitting:

• .224 average

• 2 home runs

• 2 stolen bases

• 8 RBI

Not disastrous, but far from what the Mets needed. Now, the Mets are without Robert and without a clear replacement. That’s been the theme all season. No depth, no consistency, and no answers.

The Mets took a calculated risk on talent. But without the right infrastructure, even the best gambles fall apart. And now, everything, from the roster to the manager’s job, is hanging in the balance.

— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead  —