When the Washington Commanders take the field at the OrthoVirginia Training Center on July 29th, most eyes will inevitably track Jayden Daniels ' footwork or search for splashy plays downfield. But if you want to know how effective David Blough 's offense will truly be in 2026, you may need to lock your eyes on the interior line.
Specifically, the spot immediately to the right of elite left tackle Laremy Tunsil : Left Guard.
While center and right guard appear settled with Nick Allegretti and Sam Cosmi , left guard is home to one of the most crucial head-to-head position battles in Ashburn. It's a classic clash of styles between fifth-year veteran Chris Paul and third-year athletic upside piece Brandon Coleman .
How this battle unfolds will dictate the rhythm of Washington's run game and, more importantly, the integrity of Jayden Daniels' pocket. Here is a breakdown of the two contenders fighting for the starting nod.
The Incumbent: Chris Paul's Power & Pass-Protection
Jan 4, 2026; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Washington Commanders guard Chris Paul (75) and guard Nick Allegretti (67) against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images
Chris Paul enters camp holding the upper hand after taking over the starting job early last season and starting 15 games. One of the few holdovers from the previous regime, Paul was considered a key reserve heading into 2025. Brandon Coleman started the first two games of the year, but struggled to establish a stranglehold on the job after missing significant training camp reps with a lower-body injury. Following Coleman's shaky outings against the Giants and Packers , Paul stepped in during Week 3 and never looked back. He quickly became a steadying presence on the Commanders' line, anchoring the interior as a stout pass protector.
However, Washington's offseason commitment to Paul felt somewhat lukewarm. After a solid campaign, the team allowed Paul to test the free-agent market. While it was reported he sought a contract hovering around $10 million annually, a major market never materialized. Consequently, Paul returned to D.C. on a reasonable, team-friendly deal—a quiet bargain for Washington's front office.
To that end, Paul's evaluation shows a stark contrast in skill sets, according to Pro Football Focus:
The Good:He posted a stellar 77.5 pass-blocking grade across 960 snaps,proving he can anchor against power rushers and hold his own in traditional drop-back sets.
The Concern:His 38.2 run-blocking gradewas among the lowest for starting guards, as he frequently struggled to sustain blocks on second-level defenders or move laterally in space.
Paul is the bigger, stronger hammer at the line of scrimmage. Known for his heavy hands, he excels at digging out defensive tackles on downhill runs and operates best in a tight "phone-booth" environment. He will maintain the pocket's integrity, but he can be a liability in zone-blocking schemes that require guards to move in space. In a David Blough offense that plans to put Jayden Daniels under center more frequently, Paul's sheer size and pass-blocking stability provide a baseline the coaching staff trusts—even if his ceiling remains capped in an offense that wants to stretch defenses horizontally.
The Challenger: Brandon Coleman's Athletic Ceiling
Jan 4, 2026; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Washington Commanders guard Brandon Coleman (74) against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-Imagn Images
Brandon Coleman, a 2024 third-round pick who spent his rookie season starting at left tackle, spent 2025 navigating a difficult position change. The former TCU Horned Frog was asked to absorb a massive learning curve last year. After initially shifting toward right tackle following the acquisition of Tunsil, he was asked to move again when Washington selected Oregon's Josh Conerly Jr. in the first round.
That positional shuffle, paired with minor training camp injuries, set back Coleman's development and left him at a distinct disadvantage to start the year. He was limited to just 390 snaps, serving primarily in a reserve role.
However, with a full offseason to settle in and an offensive system tailored to his strengths, Coleman could be poised for a breakout. His 2025 tape revealed a far more balanced profile than Paul's, finishing with an overall PFF grade of 65.4( 62.9 pass-blocking, 69.0 run-blocking).
What makes Coleman so intriguing is his movement ability:
Zone & Screen Scheme Fit:Coleman possesses the quickness to pull, execute reach blocks, and climb to linebackers on screen passes.
Versatility:His athletic profile allows him to operate in space in ways Paul simply cannot match.
If Blough intends to unleash a dynamic run game featuring wide-zone concepts and play-action, Coleman's movement skills represent the cleaner schematic fit. The lingering question in camp is whether Coleman can handle the raw power of elite interior pass rushers consistently enough to win back the coaching staff's trust. Former Offensive Coordinator Kliff Kingsbury openly questioned Coleman's toughness last season—giving the young lineman plenty of motivation to prove his grit this summer.
What's at Stake?
Nov 2, 2025; Landover, Maryland, USA; Washington Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels (5) looks downfield under pressure from Seattle Seahawks defensive end Leonard Williams (99) during the first quarter at Northwest Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Geoff Burke-Imagn Images
For an offense still developing its playmaker depth, the true engine of this system lies in the consistency and execution of the offensive line. Jayden Daniels will be asked to elevate the offense by distributing the ball efficiently and using his legs to extend drives.
That burden becomes significantly lighter behind a dominant front five. That's what makes this battle so compelling once the pads go on in August:
If Paul wins:Washington secures a proven, stout pass protector alongside Tunsil, but accepts a lower ceiling in the lateral run game.
If Coleman wins:The offensive line gains speed, mobility, and scheme flexibility -- provided he can hold his ground against bull rushers.
The Bottom Line
A franchise quarterback is only as comfortable as his interior protection allows him to be. With Laremy Tunsil anchoring the blindside, whoever wins the left guard job will enjoy clear sightlines and elite support to his left. Whether it's Chris Paul's raw power or Brandon Coleman's athletic ceiling, Adam Peters and Dan Quinn need one of these two contenders to seize the job outright and solidify the pocket.
Who would you like to see win this competition?
Commanders Roundtable also offers a fan community. We'd love to have you join us to talk all things Commanders. Create an account, click the "Join" button at the top of the page to join our free community and follow for all of our coverage, analysis and more!
