I Tried 12 Popular Maple Syrup Brands and the Winner Will Make Your Breakfast So Much Better

Saturday mornings were sacred in our house. No alarms, no rush, just the sound of butter sizzling on a hot griddle and the sweet smell of pancakes in the air. I can remember shuffling into the kitchen in my pajamas, rubbing sleep from my eyes, and there in the center of the table would be a familiar friend: Mrs. Butterworth.

Shaped like a lady, smiling sweetly, filled with thick, glistening syrup, it was the bottle I loved best. I'd pour that rich, dark brown sweetness over a steaming stack of hotcakes like it was liquid gold. As far as I knew back then, that was maple syrup.

It wasn't until years later that I had my first taste of real maple syrup at a diner while traveling through New England . It was light and smooth, not thick or artificial, with a flavor that was not only sweet but rich and complex. The amber color was warm and natural, like sunlight was captured in a bottle. It was in that moment that I realized what real maple syrup was and what I'd been missing all those years.

Ever since that breakfast epiphany, I've been exploring the world of maple syrup, sampling as many as I can find and diving deeper into their unique flavors. You might not think that different brands of maple syrup have different flavors, but they sure do. Where the syrup comes from and how it's processed can make a big difference in what ends up in the bottle.

To help you find the best maple syrupfor your next stack of pancakes, waffles or French toast , I grabbed a dozen different brands and did a blind taste test. My team of taste testers and I ranked all of the options from worst to best so you can find a stellar syrup for your next breakfast adventure. Read on for all the sweet and sticky details.

Related: I Tried 17 Different Pancake Mixes and the Winner Stole the Show

😋😋  SIGN UP to get delicious recipes, handy kitchen hacks & more in our daily Parade Eats newsletter . 🍳🍔

What Is Maple Syrup?

Maple syrup is a pure, all-natural sweetener made by concentrating the sap of maple trees, most commonly the sugar maple, although other varieties of maples are also tapped. To collect the sap, farmers tap maple trees during a brief period (sometimes only 4 to 6 weeks) in the freeze-thaw cycle in early spring, known as the "sugaring season."

The sap is boiled to remove excess water, leaving behind the rich, golden syrup we've come to know and love. According to the Vermont Maple Sugar Makers Association , it takes roughly 40 gallons of sap, composed of about 98% water and a small amount of natural sugar, to produce a mere one gallon of syrup.

Related: The Japanese Way to Make Boxed Pancake Mix 10x Better

Why Is Maple Syrup So Expensive?

Maple syrup carries a price tag that surprises some, but once you understand how it's made, the cost of that bottle makes a lot more sense. Unlike corn syrup or other mass-produced sweeteners, maple syrup can't be rushed or made in a factory at any time of year. It's a product of both nature and tradition, one that's deeply tied to the rhythm of the seasons—and it takes a lot of time to turn maple sap into maple syrup. That's why it's more expensive and why, when you taste real maple syrup, you're enjoying something rare, real and truly worth savoring.

Related: The Genius Pancake Trick We Wish We'd Known About Sooner

Does Maple Syrup Go Bad?

Unopened maple syrup can be stored for a long time in a cool, dark place without losing quality. However, once opened, the Vermont Maple Sugar Makers Associationrecommends refrigerating or freezing it to keep it fresh and prevent spoilage. Freezing is a great way to preserve the syrup's flavor and prevent mold from forming. We do this at our house because we don't go through it fast enough.
Related: How to Make Mother's Day Pancakes 10x Prettier, According to Martha Stewart

What To Look for When Shopping for Maple Syrup

First things first: always look for the label that says "100% pure maple syrup." Anything less is likely a "maple-flavored" syrup, which is usually a blend of corn syrup and artificial flavoring.

Next, there's the grading system. Maple syrup is classified based on color and flavor, which means a darker syrup doesn't necessarily correlate to a better or worse product. It just means it's different. The current system, recognized by both U.S. and Canadian maple syrup authorities, breaks maple syrup into four categories:

• Golden Color with Delicate TasteThe lightest syrup, harvested early in the season. Known for a subtle sweetness that is perfect for pancakes or waffles.

• Amber Color with Rich Taste
  A little darker in color and richer in taste. It's ideal for drizzling over oatmeal or adding to your morning yogurt .

• Dark Color with Robust TasteStronger in flavor. Great for cooking or baking, where you want the maple flavor to stand out.

• Very Dark Color with Strong TasteThe boldest of the bunch. It's typically harvested later in the season, and is fantastic for recipes that need a strong punch of maple.

This new grading system, which replaced the older Grade A/Grade B labels, is much clearer and more consistent. It also reflects when the syrup is made. Early-season maple syrup is light and delicate, while late-season syrup tends to be darker and more intensely flavored.

When you're shopping, go for maple syrup packaged in glass when you can. Glass bottles are ideal, not just because they store well, but also because you can see the syrup's color clearly. Plastic is fine, but glass lets you see exactly what you're getting.

Lastly, always check the origin. The best maple syrup tends to come from locations with the right climate and tradition, like Canada, Vermont and other areas in the Northeastern United States.

Related: The Canadian Way to Make Coffee 10x Better

How I Tested These Maple Syrups

To find the best maple syrup, I gathered 12 popular brands readily available at grocery stores and on Amazon. Then, my tasting team and I dove into a rigorous and delightfully sticky blind tasting.

Each syrup was poured into identical, unlabeled plastic cups, allowing only the natural color to hint at what we were about to taste. We started with straight spoonfuls, evaluating each syrup's purest qualities: its viscosity, depth and finish. Next, we dipped warm, fluffy mini pancake bites into every sample to see how the syrup held up—soaking, clinging and complementing every bite.

We judged the syrups based on texture, clarity, sweetness and complexity, all in pursuit of that perfect pour. We were looking for bold maple flavor with a thick, smooth texture.

Related: The IHOP-Approved Secret Ingredient for Tender, Fluffy Omelets

12 Popular Maple Syrup Brands, Ranked Worst to Best

12. Simple Truth Organic Maple Syrup

Though it earned points for being organic, Kroger's Simple Truth maple syrup didn't make a strong impression on any of us. The flavor was extremely mild and lacked the depth and richness we had hoped for. One taster summed it up as being very "light on the maple." It wasn't offensive, but it wasn't exciting either. It's perfectly fine if you need something in a pinch, but it wasn't a top contender in our ranking.

11. Great Value Maple Syrup

Unfortunately, this Walmart store brand option also missed the mark for most of the team. The maple flavor was faint—more of a whisper than a rich, satisfying note. Great Value's syrup poured thinner than the rest we sampled, a trait one taster actually preferred for its lightness, though the majority found the lack of body very disappointing. Sure, it could pinch-hit in a breakfast emergency, but at nearly $8 a bottle, there are better options, right on the same Walmart shelf, that offer more flavor and value for your money.

Related: I Tried 9 Frozen Waffles From the Grocery Store, and One Stood Out Instantly

10. Thrive Market Organic DarkMaple Syrup

If you like a syrup with a serious attitude, Thrive Market maple syrup is for you. Thick and full-bodied, the organic dark maple Vermont syrup hits hard with robust, almost charred-like notes that linger on the tongue, maybe a bit too long. While some tasters leaned in and loved the strong flavor, others felt it slipped into the too-intense category. We agreed it's similar in body to the TJ's version, but just a touch heavier. Another catch: You need a membership to buy it, which is a bit of a barrier for most.

9. 365 Organic Amber Maple Syrup

This option was smooth, inoffensive and what the tasting team all agreed was a little bit too well-behaved for their liking. Whole Foods' 365 syrup poured nicely and had faint caramel undertones that gave us hope, but the overall impression was just "ok." The maple flavor was present but muted, and the finish didn't stick around long. It's a solid option if you're looking for a syrup on the milder side, but not one I'd shell out $9 for.

Related: I Tried 11 Popular Cold Brew Concentrates To Find the One You Should Stock in Your Fridge

8. Trader Joe's Organic Maple Syrup

This one definitely sparked debate. Trader Joe's Dark Robust syrup lives up to its name, with a thick, velvety texture and an assertive maple flavor that's a bit mysterious. (Full disclosure: it's the one my mom uses. The half-empty bottle says it all.) Some on our panel loved its depth and intensity, while others found it a bit too bold for their liking.

As one taster put it, "It's the dark roast coffee of maple syrup," and I think that sums it up perfectly. It's best used when you want a statement-making sweetness, think ribs or maple bourbon-glazed chicken thighs. However, you may think twice about pairing it with delicate crepes or fruit-filled pancakes.

7. Butternut Mountain FarmOrganic Maple Syrup

Butternut Mountain Farms syrup went down smoothly, with a familiar, comforting sweetness that initially pleased the palate. However, our tasting panel unanimously noted a lingering aftertaste, which they found slightly bitter and cloying. While it poured nicely, that persistent finish prevented it from standing out as a top contender. It's a syrup that might work for some, but for those seeking a clean, balanced maple experience, not so much.

Related: I Tried 10 Popular Apple Cider Brands and You Can Buy the Winner at Costco

6. Roland Maple Syrup

I spotted Roland's syrup on the shelves of a local big-box store, and it turned out to be a delightful surprise. It leans a bit sweeter than some of the others, with a cozy, well-balanced, maple-forward flavor that won over a large portion of our panel. The texture also hit a sweet spot. It's not too thin and not too thick. It held up beautifully when tasted alone and paired with the pancake bites. However, the plastic bottle is what divided opinions. Some appreciated its lighter weight and easy pour, while others found it cheap-looking. As one taster put it, "Tastes premium, but looks like a cafeteria condiment."

5. Sprouts Organic Maple Syrup

There's nothing flashy about this one, just dependable, clean maple flavor with a smooth, balanced texture that pleased the entire group. It didn't dazzle, but it didn't let us down either. It's the perfect syrup to grab when you don't want to overthink things. And that's exactly its charm: approachable, easygoing and reliably good. At $6.50 a bottle, this is the kind of syrup you can finish and replace without a second thought.

Related: I Tried 13 Different Apple Cider Vinegars and Found a New Favorite Brand

4. Escuminac Great Harvest Maple Syrup

This is where things got special. Escuminac's Great Harvest, a small-batch syrup from Quebec, Canada, delivered a beautifully layered and complex flavor profile with notes of brown sugar, dried fruit and toffee. The distinct flavor had us all pausing for a moment of serious appreciation.

While we found the brand's other varieties less memorable, this particular one truly stood out. It was the highlight of their lineup, and the one we'd gladly splurge on again. And what a splurge it is, at about $25 a bottle! Rich, complex and beautifully balanced, it makes a thoughtful gift or a well-deserved treat for yourself.

3. CrownMaple Syrup

Crafted in New York's Hudson Valley, Crown Maple syrup quickly became a panel favorite. It offered a beautifully balanced flavor with subtle hints of baking spice, notes of clove and nutmeg that lent a cozy warmth, especially when paired with pancakes. The texture was smooth and perfectly pourable. It was a bit lighter than some of the others we sampled but still full of character. Widely available at Walmart, Costco, Whole Foods and Amazon, it's an easy syrup to find and an even easier one to love.

Related: I Tried 12 Different Brands of Cottage Cheese and the Winner Won by a Landslide

2. Spring Tree Maple Syrup

I was surprised to spot Spring Tree at my local grocery store, having only seen it on Amazon before then. One taste and I was in love with its clean, light, well-balanced flavor. The texture was smooth and just right. It's nothing flashy, just a solid, well-rounded maple syrup that consistently delivered throughout our tasting. We agreed it's a quietly impressive, all-purpose option that exceeded expectations, especially at only $5 a bottle.

1. Runamok Sugarmaker's Cut Maple Syrup

Runamok's Sugarmaker's Cut was the unanimous winner among our panel. It's a maple syrup that delivers everything we desired: a buttery-smooth pour, beautifully balanced sweetness and a flavor profile that evolves with each taste, from apple-like brightness to warm toffee notes. One taster even admitted, "I could eat this straight from the bottle," and honestly, I feel the same. It's a splurge at $29.95 for a 750ml bottle, YIKES, but when you taste it, you understand why. This is maple syrup at its most refined and most crave-worthy.

Up Next:

Related: Forget Pancakes—Your At-Home Brunch Needs Sheet Pan Crêpes Instead

This story was originally reported by Parade on Nov 9, 2025, where it first appeared in the Food & Drink section. Add Parade as a Preferred Source by clicking here.