Best roofers in Brooklyn, N.Y.

In Brooklyn, N.Y., brownstones, single-family homes and huge apartment blocks all vie for space, which means a good roofer needs the versatility to handle shingle roofs and flat roofs. Finding a roofer for your Brooklyn property can be daunting, but it doesn't have to be. The experts at Yahoo Local ranked Brooklyn roofers using our proprietary algorithm, which includes factors like Better Business Bureau (BBB) accreditation , online reviews and compliance with certification standards. We then spoke to the top roofers in Brooklyn to get a clearer image of what they offer.

Top Brooklyn roofers

The best roofing company in Brooklyn for YOU

When you're looking for the best roofing company in Brooklyn, take time with your research. Whether you're in the market for a shingle reroof on a single-family home or a landlord looking to recoat a flat roof with TPO, it's important to ensure that your roofer offers the roofing services you need. 

When you contact a roofer, don't forget to get into the details. Make sure their schedule lines up with your own roofing goals. Also ask them about their warranty, roofing materials, payment plans and financing options. 

If a quote feels off, consult another roofer. Many companies use satellite imagery or Google Maps to get a rough idea of what a job will entail. However, most companies won't supply you with a real quote until they inspect a roof in person.

The best overall roofer in Brooklyn is ACJ Remodeling . With exceptional customer service and a 41-year track record, it's a staple of the community. Beyond their customer service, the company offers excellent warranties, expertise in multiple roof types and good rates.

Table of contents

• Best overall roofer in Brooklyn

• Top alternative Brooklyn roofer

• More best Brooklyn roofing companies

• Why you should trust Yahoo Local roofing advice

• New York roofing FAQs

• Methodology

Best roofing companies in Brooklyn, N.Y.

ACJ Remodeling is the best overall Brooklyn roofing company

ACJ Remodeling is a family-owned roofer with all the personality and expertise you expect from a New York veteran contractor service. Owner Joseph Ashley quickly called us back and demonstrated a commitment to customer service throughout our call. He walked us through all aspects of what ACJ Remodeling offers, including pricing, warranties and factors that could make the job more difficult, such as whether the rafters are built on old cedar shakes.

While based in Staten Island, ACJ Remodeling regularly handles roofing projects in Brooklyn and other boroughs. The company has operated for 41 years. The business doesn't employ contractors; instead, it uses a team of full-time, background-checked roofers, many of whom have been with the company for over 25 years.

Ashley quoted us $13.50 per square foot for shingles. For a 1,500 square foot home with a roof at almost 900 square feet, this works out to around $12,000. ACJ Remodeling will charge one-third of the cost as a deposit before work begins. The rest of the agreed amount will be due when work is completed. You can pay in cash, credit, personal check or set up a financing plan. Credit card payments will trigger a 4.5% card fee.

Services offered

• Shingles

• Flat roofs

• Exterior remodeling

• Vinyl

• Stucco

If you're looking for shingles, ACJ Remodeling uses Owens Corning. These come with a 50-year transferrable warranty, which transfers to the next owner in case of a sale.

ACJ Remodeling brings out a dumpster for cleanup, which it usually parks in the street. As with all roofers, ACJ Remodeling keeps a close eye on the weather when booking. If a storm appears, it pushes the schedule back. Ashley told us that ACJ Remodeling uses a different method from most roofers and only tears down sections of the roof at a time. This means it more easily patches the roof to ensure it stays weathertight if the weather changes in the middle of a multi-day job. Ashley told us that jobs often last between three and four days.

ACJ Remodeling has a 5-star score on Google (31 reviews), a 5-star score on Yelp (nine reviews), and a 4.8-star rating on Angi (378 reviews). ACJ Remodeling is not BBB-accredited , but it maintains an A+ rating with zero complaints.

The company is located at 49 Elizabeth Street, Staten Island, N.Y., 10310. It is open Monday through Friday, between 9 a.m. and 4 p.m. For a free estimate, call 718-948-0201 or visit its website .

Customer testimonial

Joe is a professional. We used him for our home in 2022 for new siding, soffits, and roof, to prep for solar panels. His crew are hard workers and do excellent work. Even now in 2023, our siding and roof still look brand new. I would not hesitate to use Joe and I highly recommend him to others. I get compliments all the time for how good. our house looks. Thanks Joe! - Peter B., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

Smart General Contracting is our top alternative Brooklyn roofer

Smart General Contracting is a full-service roofing company that offers stand-out flat and shingled roofing services. The company operates in Brooklyn and the New York area and got its start in 2017. A general contractor as well as a roofer, it handles masonry, sidewalks, interior painting and other tasks as well as roofing.

For shingle roofs, it uses GAF shingles, which come with a limited lifetime manufacturer's warranty. Smart General Contracting supplements this warranty with a five-year workmanship warranty. Beyond shingles, the company will coat and waterproof flat roofs, repairing the substrate before replacing the roof coating. Recoats can make your building more energy efficient in addition to protecting the building from the elements.

When we asked for a quote, Smart General Contracting told us that most shingle roofing jobs in Brooklyn will run about $12 to $14 per square foot. This means a total price of around $10,667 to $12,432 for a 1,500 square foot home. However, this could vary considerably based on your roof's complexity, the building's height and whether the roof is installed over plywood decking or old cedar shakes.

Smart General Contracting asks for a 35% down payment before work commences, and it pulls any necessary permits. Another 35% is then due at the midpoint of the job, with the final 15% due at the end. The company takes checks, cash and credit cards, which are run with whatever fee the card company charges. The representative we spoke to assured us that Smart General Contracting doesn't add any extra fees on top of that rate. The company does not offer financing plans.

Services offered

• Shingle roofs

• Flat roofs

• Exterior remodeling

• Interior remodeling

• Tile work

• Sidewalks

• Painting

Smart General Contracting generally takes two or three days to fully replace a shingle roof. It is vigilant about potential weather interruptions and assured us that it always comes prepared for freak weather events with tarps. If rough weather is in the forecast, it will reschedule and push the entire schedule back. If your roofing job gets bumped, it will move you back to the next dry day.

Expect Smart General Contracting to bring out its dump truck on the day of the job, which will generally be parked in the street while construction is in progress. While its team isn't formally background-checked, the owner assured us that he has personally worked with everyone on his team for five or six years.

Smart General Contracting has a 4.8-star score on Google (128 reviews), a 4.9-star score on Yelp (34 reviews), and a 5-star rating on Angi (24 reviews). It is BBB-accredited with an A+ rating and zero complaints.

The company is located at 2534 W. 15th St., Brooklyn, N.Y., 11214. It is open from 7:30 a.m. to 6:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. on Saturdays and 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Sundays. For an estimate, call 917-251-0258 or visit the website .

Customer testimonial

Smart General fully renovated our entire exteriors (brickface, stucco, roofs, gutters, leaders, brick + granite stairs, demo, etc) and did an amazing job. The quote estimate was reasonable and work started within a week. - Alvin C., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

More best Brooklyn roofers

You can count on Yahoo Local roofing advice, and this is why 

At Yahoo, we've spent decades delivering reliable information on local businesses. We don't just ask you to trust us; we work to earn your trust. Yahoo Local uses a proprietary ranking system that draws on reviews from multiple established sources across the web and carefully weights them. We then combine this data with BBB-accreditation info, check for local certifications and contact the top businesses. This process creates what we believe is the most authoritative local business ranking available. We're transparent about the factors that go into our rankings. Unlike some competitors, Yahoo Local never accepts payment for inclusion or placement, and our independent recommendations are never "sponsored" or influenced by outside parties. Want more details? Visit our full methodology page .

Below is everything that went into the rankings for our list of the best roofing companies in Brooklyn:

• 63 roofers evaluated

• 3,375 customer reviews and ratings from five sources

• Eight ranking criteria incorporated

• Interviewed or connected with both featured roofers

• Independent price quotes collected from both featured roofing companies

• Independently researched and fact-checked by Yahoo

• Recommendations are maintained and updated regularly

New York roofing FAQs

How much does the average roof replacement cost in New York?

Roof replacements in Brooklyn and The Five Boroughs often run higher than the average roof replacement price elsewhere in New York. When we requested ballpark estimates for 1,500-square-foot homes with shingles, most local roofers quoted between $11,000 and $17,000. That's noticeably above the national average. Angi lists $9,519 as the typical cost for a shingle roof replacement in the U.S. Given that New York City is among the most expensive cities in the country, this price gap isn't surprising.

Several factors can drive reroofing costs higher, including the roof's size and complexity. Many older Brooklyn homes were originally built with cedar shakes beneath the shingles rather than plywood decking. Cedar shakes are very labor-intensive and expensive to replace. Often, past owners will have opted to layer shingles over older shingles to save money. If this is the case with your home, expect a full reroof to cost significantly more.

How do I know if my roof needs repairs or a full replacement?

Unless you're a skilled roofer, it's wise to have a professional inspect your roof to determine if a full replacement is necessary. However, a little common sense will go a long way, and savvy homeowners should be able to spot early warning signs themselves. Leaks and missing shingles are obvious red flags that should prompt an immediate inspection.

You can prepare for hurricane season , blizzards and summer storms in advance, but these events are also a good time to get an inspection. These storms can cause significant damage, and in some cases, your homeowner's insurance may be more likely to cover the cost of an inspection or complete replacement if you can prove that a storm caused damage.

Are there roofing regulations or permits required in New York?

New York has several roofing regulations. It's important to ensure that your roofing company follows these codes properly. Make sure that it is licensed to operate in Brooklyn and verify that it pulls the required permits that it will need before it begins construction on your building.

For more, read our full guide to New York roofing company licensing and regulations .

How long does a roof typically last in New York?

Many factors affect how long a roof will last , including the local climate and the roofing materials you choose. In New York, shingle roofs will generally last between 20 and 30 years, as is common elsewhere. That said, higher-end shingles may last much longer. 

Flat roofs are common in Brooklyn and often have shorter lifespans than shingle roofs. According to Apple Roofing, a company based out of Texas, these roofs usually last from 10 to 40 years , depending on the type of material they are finished with.

Higher-end materials like slate, tile and metal can come with advantages. These premium materials can last from 40 years to 100 or more.

What is the best time of year to replace a roof in New York?

New York state is known for its distinct seasons and varied geography. New York City has a humid coastal climate distinct from the cooler climate found across most of the rest of the state. The city is surrounded on most sides by river, estuary and ocean, and experiences a full palate of weather, including deep snows, scorching summers, leafy falls and potential seasonal hurricanes.

Generally, spring, summer and fall are the best times of the year to consider a roof replacement. While summer can bring storms, it offers the most consistent roofing weather of all the seasons. 

While fair weather means better conditions for roofing, it can also bring more competition for roofing companies' time. If you choose to schedule roofing work in the summer, be aware that you may need to book well in advance. Thankfully, the best roofing companies in New York, and featured in this list, are on-call for roof repairs well into the winter months.

More Yahoo Local-approved New York providers

Best New Yorkroofers

Brooklyn / Staten Island

• See all Yahoo Local roofing

Best New York movers

Albany / Binghamton / The Bronx / Brooklyn / Buffalo / Clifton Park / Hamburg / Ithaca / Kingston / Manhattan / New Rochelle / Poughkeepsie / Queens / Rochester / Syracuse

• See all Yahoo Local moving articles