Best roofers in Evansville, Ind.

Lining a bend of the Ohio River, Evansville is one of Indiana's most populous cities, and an important part of the Tri-State Area of Illinois, Indiana and Kentucky. With such a large population in the region, it's no surprise that there is no shortage of roofing companies serving the area. With so many choices, choosing the best roofer for your home requires real research. We took care of this step for you, evaluating the roofers serving the Evansville area and ranking them based on a number of factors, including online reviews, accreditation by the Better Business Bureau (BBB) , proper licensing and more.

Top Evansville roofers

The best roofing company in Evansvillefor YOU

There's a lot that goes into picking the best roofing company for you. It's a good idea to approach any roofing company you're considering with a number of questions in mind. If you're looking for a specific roofing material, such as slate, be sure to ask whether the company can meet your needs. If you have specific scheduling needs, you should also ask about these.

Most companies will book an inspection before providing you with a quote. Generally, they will be able to check for decking issues and specific pain points that might arise in a reroof or roof repair; however, if you know of these in advance, point them out. 

The top overall roofer in Evansville is Storm Guard Roofing and Construction . The company is a great pick when you need emergency repairs or tarping, but it is an equally good choice for a full reroof, whether you pick asphalt shingles or metal. It's also accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating.

ACE Construction, Roofing, Fence & Plumbing is our top alternative roofer in Evansville. It's a one-stop shop for roofing and construction work, and carries excellent warranties. The company has served the Evansville area since 1976. It's also accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating.

Table of contents

• Best overall roofer in Evansville

• Top alternative Evansville roofer

• Best national roofing company

• More best Evansville roofing companies

• Why you should trust Yahoo Local roofing advice

• Indiana roofing FAQs

• Methodology

Best roofing companies in Evansville, Ind.

Storm Guard Roofing and Construction is the best overall Evansville roofing company

Storm Guard Roofing is a national franchise with local customer service. The representative we spoke to was eager to help and personable. This ethos seems to be a company standard, in that even the payment plan is customizable based on the company-client relationship, and the down payment required can be tweaked to fit your needs.

Storm Guard Roofing provides residential and commercial roofing, installing shingles and metal pitched roofs. The company primarily uses Owens Corning shingles, which come in various models, from value-priced Oak Ridge to the many colorways of the Designer line . These come with a variety of manufacturers' warranties, which we were told start around 25 years. Additionally, the company supplies a supplemental five-year workmanship warranty.

The company offers financing through partners. Credit card payments are accepted; however, they accrue a 3.2% fee. While a real quote will require a full estimate, the representative we spoke to told us that a 1,000 square foot reroof with basic options could cost anywhere between $5,000 and $10,000.

Services offered

• Residential roofing

• Commercial roofing

• Emergency tarping

• Repairs

• Gutters

When we asked how long a 1,000 square foot home would take for a reroof, we were told that a standard job of that size would usually take half a day to a full day, depending on the decking underneath and other factors. Sudden weather changes can mean that schedules get pushed back — in these cases, Storm Guard Roofing pushes the whole schedule back, ensuring that client homes are roofed in the order in which they are booked. 

Storm Guard Roofing takes cleanup seriously. Its teams bring out dump trailers on the day of the job, then, when work is done, the production manager will return for a nail sweep using magnets. The background-checked roofing team has worked with the company for a full decade.

The company is accredited by the BBB , with an A+ rating and only one complaint in the last three years, which was addressed and closed. It has 4.8 stars on Google (219 reviews), five stars on Yelp (one review) and 4.7 stars on Angi (16 reviews).

Storm Guard Roofing is located at 1326 E. Division St., Evansville, Ind., 47711. It is open 24 hours a day, from Monday through Saturday. It is closed on Sundays. For an estimate, call 812-525-2078, or visit the website .

Customer testimonial

Storm Guard did a great job replacing my house and shed roofs! Matt was awesome to work with, very friendly, and kept me up-to-date. He made a couple of great recommendations to me and I appreciated his input. The crew got both of my roofs installed all in one day. They also went over the lawn and landscaping with a magnet to pick up the loose nails. I highly recommend Storm Guard for all your roofing needs. - Chris, Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

ACE Construction, Roofing, Fence & Plumbing is our top alternativeEvansville roofer

While you might not think ACE Construction, Roofing, Fence & Plumbing is all that focused of a roofing company based on its name, you'd be wrong. In fact, the company's different specialties fall under different departments: Ace Roofing & Construction, Ace Plumbing and Ace & Sons Fence Co. The family-owned company has served the Evansville area since 1976. With so many different specialties under the same umbrella, it's a one-stop shop for many home renovation needs. 

ACE Construction, Roofing, Fence & Plumbing primarily works with GAF shingles. We were told that these shingles come with a 50-year manufacturer's warranty, and ACE supplements with a workmanship warranty that starts at five years, but is available for longer with Silver or Gold plans. 

The company does not charge a down payment; instead, all fees are due at the end. It offers financing services through its web portal. Payments are accepted via check, cashier's check and card, with card payments adding a 4% transaction fee. The representative was careful to note that this fee is not a source of revenue for the company; instead, it goes to the outside vendor that handles card transactions. When we asked for a quote, we were told that the company would have to send an estimator out before providing a ballpark figure.

Services offered

• Residential roofing

• Outdoor remodeling

• Fencing

• Plumbing

• Siding

• Gutters

When we asked how long a 1,000 square foot home would take for a reroof, we were told that we could expect one day. Weather delays cause the whole schedule to push back accordingly, so that all jobs are completed in the order in which they were scheduled. 

ACE Construction, Roofing, Fence & Plumbing's team is fully background checked. It will arrive with a dump truck on the day of the move and then sweep the yard afterward for nails, using a magnet. 

The company holds an A+ rating and is accredited by the BBB . It has no complaints filed against it. It has 4.6 stars on Google (213 reviews), 3.2 stars on Yelp (five reviews) and 4.5 stars on Angi (32 reviews). 

ACE Construction, Roofing, Fence & Plumbing is located at 1429 W. Franklin St., Evansville, Ind., 47710. Its hours are 8 a.m. through 4:30 p.m. from Monday through Friday. It is closed over the weekend. For a quote, call 812-226-0277 or visit the website .

Customer testimonial

We have used Ace four times for different jobs. Every time we received a contract that completely spelled out what they would do - and they did it! Their prices were fair, and they did excellent work. We will use them again for future projects. - Tamara H., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

Erie Home is the best national Evansville roofing company

At Yahoo Local, our goal is to provide people with the resources they need to make confident and informed choices. While our coverage usually focuses on local businesses, there are times when choosing a national roofing company could make more sense. If you're deciding between the two, check out our guide comparing national and local roofing companies . For those leaning toward a nationwide provider, our top pick in the Indiana area is Erie Home .

Founded in 1976, Erie Home is a major residential roofing company operating throughout the Central U.S. and beyond. The company provides standard services such as asphalt shingle installation, replacement, and repair, along with specialized options like metal roofing and waterproofing. Erie runs more than 100 offices across 38 states. While its main coverage area is the Central and Eastern U.S., it also ranks among the top national roofing companies in the Southeast and Pacific Northwest, with branches stretching from Washington down to Florida.

Based in Toledo, Ohio, Erie maintains a 4.4-star average on Google from nearly 1,400 customer reviews and is considered the top choice among large providers in its service regions. On Yelp, the company has a lower rating of 1.9 stars from around 40 reviews, though national contractors typically see low Yelp scores, making this fairly standard. Considering its ratings, offerings, and performance, Erie Home stands out as the best large-scale roofer in the Central U.S., while also being a strong pick for homeowners in the Southeast and Northwest.

As with most large roofing contractors, Erie Home does not share prices by phone. According to a company representative, the pricing process depends heavily on the specific project details and requires an on-site inspection for both firm quotes and rough estimates.

Customers who choose Erie Home may be eligible for zero-down financing, which lets you delay payment on a roof repair or replacement for 90 days. Erie notes that financing is the most common payment method among its clients, and details are available on the company's website . For alternative options, such as a credit card, debit card or check, you can consult with your local Erie office regarding availability and any related fees.

Services offered

• Nationwide roofing services

• Roof repair, replacement and installation

• Metal and asphalt roofing options

• Foundation repair and waterproofing (in select locations)

• Free consultations

Dedicated to high-quality service, Erie specializes in long-lasting metal roofing systems and a variety of asphalt shingles in multiple colors, ranging from granite black to Monaco Red. All roofing jobs come with a limited lifetime labor warranty, plus manufacturer warranties that vary by material. Erie also maintains specialized repair teams ready to respond quickly when issues arise. In most cases, installations are completed in less than a day.

Because Erie operates a wide network of crews, cleanup procedures may vary. Customers are encouraged to ask their estimator during the consultation how their particular team will manage site cleanup during and after the project.

The company is accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating and has logged about 383 customer complaints over the past three years — a figure that is notably lower than the industry average for nationwide roofing firms. A representative stated that Erie employs only in-house crews rather than subcontractors, although we were unable to confirm whether formal background checks are part of its hiring process.

For additional details, you can call 800-998-8301 or request a free estimate on the company's website. Erie Home's headquarters is located at 3516 Granite Circle, Toledo, Ohio, 43617, though its network spans 38 states. A complete map of office locations is available online. In Evansville, it is located at 2400 Kotter Ave., Suite B, Evansville, Ind., 47715. Customer service is available 24/7, while local office hours may differ.

Customer testimonial

"Erie Home installed our fairly complex 2-story roof in 1 day. We were absolutely impressed with their superior American made products. The install went smoothly and as expected, and the clean-up after was stellar. I have already recommended Erie Home to family. That says it all." - Ed G., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

More bestEvansville roofers

You can count on Yahoo Local roofing advice, and this is why 

Yahoo has spent decades delivering trusted information about local businesses. We don't just ask for your trust, we work to earn it. Our proprietary ranking system gathers reviews from multiple respected sources, weighs them carefully, and produces what we believe is the most reliable local business ranking available. To ensure transparency, we share the details of our methodology so you can see exactly how our picks are made. And unlike some competitors, Yahoo Local never accepts payment for inclusion or placement. Our recommendations are always independent, never sponsored, and free from outside influence. Want more details? Visit our full methodology page .

Below is everything that went into the rankings for our list of the best roofing companies in Evansville:

• 26 roofers evaluated

• 2,732 customer reviews and ratings from five sources

• Eight ranking criteria incorporated

• Interviewed or connected with all three featured roofers

• Independent price quotes sought from all three featured roofing companies

• Independently researched and fact-checked by Yahoo

• Recommendations are maintained and updated regularly

Indiana roofing FAQs

How much does the average roof replacement cost in Indiana?

Storm Guard Roofing told us that a small shingle reroof in Evansville could cost as little as $5,000 to $10,000. The bottom end of this ballpark is just a little below the national average: $5,800 to $20,000 . In most of Indiana, a reroof should come close to this price, with urban centers generally commanding higher prices and rural areas often falling slightly below the pricing standards of other parts of the country.

How do I know if my roof needs repairs or a full replacement?

Unless you have roofing expertise, it's a smart idea to bring in a professional to evaluate whether your roof needs a full replacement. Still, a bit of common sense can help homeowners catch problems early. Obvious warning signs — like leaks or missing shingles — should trigger a call for an inspection right away.

Planning ahead for heavy snow or summer hailstorms is always wise, but these events are also a perfect time to schedule an inspection. Severe weather often causes significant roof damage, and in many cases, your homeowner's insurance may be more likely to cover the cost of an inspection or even a full replacement if you can show the damage was caused by a storm.

Are there roofing regulations or permits required in Indiana?

At the state level, Indiana doesn't regulate roofing companies. Instead, this is often left to municipal governments, if it is regulated at all. In some smaller cities, there may be few regulations at all. In these cases, industry associations can help you pick a good contractor. The Indiana Roofing Contractors Association (IRCA) is a trade organization that can be helpful for finding a good roofer.

For additional guidance, read our guide to Indiana roofing licensing and regulations .

How long does a roof typically last in Indiana?

Several elements influence how long a roof will last , including the type of material used and the region's climate. According to Indy Roof & Restoration , an Indianapolis roofer, a shingle roof in Indiana should last for 20 to 30 years. This is in line with the national average. More expensive shingle varieties can often extend well beyond that range.

For longevity, premium roofing products like slate, tile, and metal stand out. These higher-end materials can provide durability for 40 years or more, with some lasting well over 100 years.

What is the best time of year to replace a roof in Indiana?

Indiana has hot summers, cold winters and everything in between. While the cold and snows of winter can cause problems for roofing work, all four seasons are viable for roofing, though winter can cause the most trouble. Spring and autumn rains can derail scheduling, but these seasons are often ideal for roofing work. 

Talk to your roofer about the best time period for your specific job. Most companies will be clear about weather policies, and any issues that seasonal conditions will cause.

More Yahoo Local-approved Indiana providers

Best Indiana movers

Fort Wayne / Indianapolis / South Bend

• See all Yahoo Local moving

Best Indiana roofers

Evansville / Fort Wayne / Indianapolis

• See all Yahoo Local roofing