The Giants have a huge decision to make between JJ McCarthy & Jameis Winston Joe DeLeone reacts to the Giants falling to the Saints in shocking fashion 1:31 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Jameis Winston on J.J. McCarthy taking over in Giants loss to Saints 1:13 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Giants should start J.J. McCarthy ahead of Jameis Winston from here on out 2:39 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing McCarthy gave Giants a 'spark' in loss to Saints 2:15 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing J.J. McCarthy Makes His Case to Replace Jameis Winston 2:42 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Giants Turn to J.J. McCarthy, Fall 34-27 to Saints After Late Rally 1:10 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Are Giants using McCarthy to motivate Winston? 3:46 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing 'No-brainer' for Giants to stick with McCarthy 4:47 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Throwdown Thursday: Does the Giants QB change say more about J.J. McCarthy or Jameis Winston? 'GMFB' 3:51 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing JJ McCarthy May Start for Giants, Replacing Jameis Winston 2:01 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Giants to start J.J. McCarthy against Texans, bench Jameis Winston 2:27 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing The Giants have a huge decision to make between JJ McCarthy & Jameis Winston AtoZ Sports Sun, Oct 18, 2026 Joe DeLeone reacts to the Giants falling to the Saints in shocking fashion The Giants have a huge decision to make between JJ McCarthy & Jameis Winston Joe DeLeone reacts to the Giants falling to the Saints in shocking fashion 1:31 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Jameis Winston on J.J. McCarthy taking over in Giants loss to Saints 1:13 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Giants should start J.J. McCarthy ahead of Jameis Winston from here on out 2:39 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing McCarthy gave Giants a 'spark' in loss to Saints 2:15 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing J.J. McCarthy Makes His Case to Replace Jameis Winston 2:42 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Giants Turn to J.J. McCarthy, Fall 34-27 to Saints After Late Rally 1:10 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Are Giants using McCarthy to motivate Winston? 3:46 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing 'No-brainer' for Giants to stick with McCarthy 4:47 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Throwdown Thursday: Does the Giants QB change say more about J.J. McCarthy or Jameis Winston? 'GMFB' 3:51 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing JJ McCarthy May Start for Giants, Replacing Jameis Winston 2:01 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing Giants to start J.J. McCarthy against Texans, bench Jameis Winston 2:27 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing