Yankees Make History vs A’s, But We Need to Talk

The Yankees just dropped a historic 13-run inning on the Athletics, but does that actually answer the biggest questions surrounding this team? We discuss the Yankees’ feast-or-famine offense, why they continue to dominate bad pitching while struggling for consistency against elite starters, and whether Ben Rice has a legitimate case to be the team MVP over Aaron Judge . Plus, the bullpen concerns refuse to go away, Yankees fans debate Cody Bellinger vs. Kyle Tucker , wild CJ Abrams and Yordan Alvarez trade ideas take over social media, Max Schuemann ’s surprising roster case, and whether Tommy Kahnle could be headed back to the Bronx.