Is Thrive Market worth it? We tried it for a month to find out

As a dietitian, my friends assume I've tried every healthier food brand and meal delivery service out there. While I try to live up to that reputation, it's nearly impossible to keep up. One that I get asked about the most? Thrive Market. As a mom of two young kids, snacks eat up a big chunk of my grocery budget, so Thrive's promise of healthier food for less has kept it on my radar for a few years now. But every time I'd hit the subscription page, I couldn't justify another recurring charge. So when Senior Health Editor Holly Pevzner and I got the chance to test it out, I jumped.

Thrive Market's pitch is simple: healthier groceries, lower prices and items you won't find at your regular store — all without setting foot in one.

Over the course of a month, Pevzner and I put that pitch to the test with two very different households: hers, with teenage boys, and mine, with picky 3- and 5-year-olds. Here's what we ordered, what we thought of it as health editors and parents and whether it's actually worth the subscription.

Thrive Market at a glance

Sign up now and get $20 off your first three orders + a free $60 gift! (Minimum purchase is $49+!)

How it works

Thrive Market is a subscription-only service. To get started, pick a payment plan — $59.95 annually (about $5 per month) or $12 per month if billed monthly — and enter your billing and delivery info. From there, you can dive into the service's seriously impressive — and at times overwhelming — selection of products. Add items to your cart, then check out. Opt into recurring deliveries to choose how often and when your order ships.

Deliveries arrive two to four days after you place your order. Non-perishables come wrapped in recyclable materials, while frozen items ship with dry ice to keep them cold.

You can stick with the same shipment each time, which is handy if you buy the same staples on repeat, or switch things up; just make sure to do it before the cutoff date.

Because my grocery shopping is all over the place (depending on whether I hit Costco that week, am testing meal kits or have dinner plans), I skipped the automatic deliveries and just ordered on the fly when I needed to.

A quick look at how it performed during testing

Let's get to the good stuff: how it performed in testing. Pevzner and I had slightly different experiences, yet came away with about the same overall score. We both gave it high marks for accommodating a variety of diets, offering nutritious options, delivering high-quality items and a smooth delivery process.

Where we differed: our experience with the website and our take on overall value.

As the scores suggest, our biggest difference was value: Holly didn't think the savings justified the membership, while I felt it made sense for shoppers who regularly buy specialty health products.

What we liked

No shortage of healthier items to choose from

Looking for snacks made with chickpea or whole wheat flour, or free of artificial flavors and colors? Thrive won't disappoint. At time of publish, the site stocks 1,326 items in healthy snacks alone, plus 220 cereals and granolas, 314 grains/pastas/breads, 356 condiments and 235 baking items — and that's just a handful of aisles.

The selection is a strength, but it's also a lot. Both Pevzner and I found it overwhelming without a shopping list already in mind. "There's so much available that it's a bit of a time-suck shopping," she said.

Organization is top-notch

This is where Thrive pulls ahead of most online grocery services. Every diet filter I clicked into turned up a genuinely deep selection.

Diets include:

• Gluten-free

• Vegan

• Vegetarian

• Organic

• Paleo

• Whole30

• Mediterranean

• Ketogenic

• Low FODMAP

• AIP

• GLP-1 friendly

• Raw

You can also filter by:

• Certifications, like Certified Kosher or Certified Fair Trade

• Ingredients, like paraben-free or free of the top 9 allergens

• Values, like pasture-raised or BIPOC-founded (Black, Indigenous and people of color-founded)

• Health concerns, like acne, aging, joints or brain health

Zero complaints with food quality

Pevzner and I both gave the service a perfect score here.

"I focused on pantry staples and snacks. The kids were super happy with the protein bars — especially the almond butter IQ bar, which we'd never tried — plus the Thrive jerky, Stellar Pretzel Braids, Maui Monk and OWYN plant-based protein shakes . I especially liked the Thrive Date Syrup, the Thrive Sicilian Gravy and the Whole Earth Stevia & Monk Fruit Sweetener — all new to me," Pevzner said.

As a dietitian, what stood out wasn't just the taste — it was how well-curated the selection is for health-conscious shoppers. Thrive prioritizes organic products and restricts more than 1,000 ingredients, including artificial flavors, antibiotics, parabens and synthetic nitrates and nitrites. That makes it a genuine timesaver if you're used to spending extra minutes at the store scrutinizing labels.

As for actual products, I was already a fan of many of the items I bought: Kodiak Protein-Packed Power Waffles, Alxia Sweet Potato Puffs, The Good Crisp Company Crisps, Brami Protein Pasta and Gomacro Bars. But I also discovered a few new favorites including Feel Good Foods Mozzarella Sticks (heat them up in the air-fryer, so good!), Love&Cookies Gourmet Cookie Dough and Daily Harvest protein smoothies.

SO many baby and toddler products

If any one group stands to benefit most from Thrive, it's parents of babies and toddlers. The lineup includes kid-friendly snacks from Annie's, Once Upon a Farm, Kidfresh and Evergreen, plus formula from Bobbie, Kabrita and Bubs — the last of which, an Australian brand, I used with my youngest. Diapers, wipes, creams, lotions and bath products round it out.

When I compared prices against my local grocery store, King Soopers, baby and kid items were consistently cheaper at Thrive.

Keep in mind

Fresh and frozen food orders require their own minimum

If I could pick just one complaint, this would be it. Unlike other grocery delivery services Pevzner and I have tried, Thrive sets separate free-shipping thresholds for groceries, fresh and frozen — three thresholds in one order.

Here's the fee structure:

It adds up fast if you're not paying close attention. I initially wanted just a few freezer items, but once I saw that separate minimum, I had to decide: order more frozen items I didn't need, or skip them entirely. I chose the former, and my bill came in higher than planned. It's one of the main reasons I don't see Thrive as a weekly service — more one to use occasionally, for stocking up on niche items.

Pevzner ran into the same wall, but handled it differently. "One thing I was baffled by was the differentiation between ordering dry goods and items that required a cold pack. In my experience with Imperfect Foods in 2020 and 2021, there were no extra fees for cold packs and there was no distinction between unlocking free shipping with cold vs. not cold. That made me stick to pantry staples only, which was unfortunate."

Some items have to be purchased in pairs

Another surprise I wasn't a fan of. Some items, like Good Crisp Company chips and Brami Protein Pasta, require buying two at a time. For products my family already loves, that's fine — just more food than I'd budgeted for. But for anything new, the two-item minimum was enough to make me skip it altogether.

No fresh produce or refrigerated items

Thrive sticks to shelf-stable and frozen products. Want fresh fruit, vegetables or anything from the fridge aisle — yogurt, oat milk, eggs? You'll still need a store run.

You can't select your actual delivery date

Unlike Amazon Fresh, which lets you pick both a delivery date and a time window, Thrive doesn't give you control over arrival day. If you opt into recurring orders, you can only adjust the processing date and delivery frequency.

Groceries typically arrive within two to four days, and you'll get a text with an estimated date — but the actual arrival may be earlier or later than expected. That's a real problem if you're traveling. My shipment showed up a day earlier than the text predicted, while I was 40 minutes away and planning to sleep at a friend's that night. I ended up driving back at 9 p.m. just to get everything inside before the freezer items got too warm.

Does it actually save you money?

Setting aside the added complication of separate grocery, fresh and frozen minimums, I wanted to know: Is Thrive actually cheaper than my local King Soopers (owned by Kroger)? To find out, I picked a mix of items available at both stores (things I'd typically buy) and compared prices.

Here's how the costs shook out:

Not counting potential shipping fees if you miss a minimum, it's essentially a wash between Thrive and King Soopers when you're buying a mix of everyday staples — pasta sauce, olive oil — and specialty snacks like Chomps beef sticks or Kodiak frozen waffles. Which brings us to our last category: value.

Value

This is the category where Pevzner and I differed most.

"I'm a coupon-clipper, a loyalty card user and a lover of the clearance section of my local grocery store. And I'm also a Costco member, so I don't think I saved much," said Pevzner, who scored it 2.5 out of 5. "For instance, the Fruit Rolls Variety Pack and the store-brand jerky are markedly cheaper at Costco."

Her biggest gripe was the fee structure itself: "I'm not looking to do all that math, and I certainly don't want to pay all of those shipping fees for an order with a variety of items."

I landed somewhere more favorable. For shoppers who regularly buy niche health-brand snacks , Thrive offers real value — those items tend to run cheaper than what you'd find locally, and the selection is wider than anything I've found in Denver. I also like that members get one free product sample per order.

On subscription cost: if you go annual, $5 a month feels reasonable, especially given Thrive's promise to refund the difference if your savings don't cover the fee. But Pevzner's complaint stands as the sharpest edge here — the separate fees and minimums for frozen and fresh items are the real friction point.

So, is it worth it?

Sign up now and get $20 off your first three orders + a free $60 gift! (Minimum purchase is $49+!)

Our health content is for informational purposes only and is not intended as professional medical advice. Consult a medical professional on questions about your health.