Best roofers in Carmel, Ind.

Carmel homeowners know that Midwest weather can be unpredictable, with strong storms and heavy snow that wear down a roof. We researched local Carmel roofers by reviewing customer feedback, Better Business Bureau (BBB) accreditation , licensing, services offered and more. We also called each of our featured roofers to get the details you need to choose the right one. If you're trying to decide which local roofer is worth calling, this guide can help you cut through the noise.

Top Carmel roofers

The best roofing company in Carmel for YOU

Choosing a roofing company in Carmel comes down to a few key factors. Start with your budget and how quickly you need pricing. Some roofers offer fast ballpark estimates online, while others require an on-site visit before sharing numbers. You'll also want to think about timing, especially after storms, and whether you need emergency services or can plan the project in advance.

For homeowners who want quick price estimates and hands-on job oversight, Indy Rooftops stands out as our best overall pick. It offers an online pricing tool, emergency services and an on-site manager for every project. If long-term experience and in-house crews matter more to you, Bone Dry Roofing is our top alternative Carmel roofer. It has decades of experience, full-time employees and no deposit requirement. Keep reading to learn more about the best roofers in Carmel.

Best roofing companies in Carmel, Ind.

Indy Rooftops is the best overall Carmel roofing company

Indy Rooftops was founded just three years ago, but it's already built a strong reputation across Carmel and the greater Indianapolis area. It is a family-owned and operated business that focuses on personalized service while still using high-quality materials and systems.

When we called to learn more, we spoke with the general manager, Brian. He was friendly and took genuine pride in the work his team does and the standards it follows. The company's website offers a quick online pricing tool that gives a ballpark estimate in about two minutes. It priced a typical three-bed, two-bath home between $15,000 and $16,000. After that, the company sends an estimator to your home to inspect the roof, take photos, check the attic and provide a detailed estimate.

A 50% deposit is required to schedule the job. Indy Rooftops accepts cash, cashier's checks, bank checks, and debit or credit cards. Credit card payments include a 2% to 3% processing fee. Financing is available, including 12 months same-as-cash and longer-term options up to 84 months.

Services offered

• Roof installation

• Replacements

• Repairs

• Inspections

• Emergency services

• Siding

Your total estimate includes cleanup. The crew hauls away all debris and uses metal rakes to remove nails from the yard. If bad weather is expected on your roofing date, the company will contact you at least 24 hours in advance to reschedule for the next available day.

All full-time employees undergo background checks. However, Indy Rooftops uses fully vetted subcontractor roofing crews and places a company manager on-site for every job. The company offers a three-year workmanship warranty, and Brian explained that if there's a workmanship issue following the warranted period, the company still stands behind its work and will fix it.

Indy Rooftops is a young business, but already accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating. It has strong overall customer reviews, with five stars on both Google (422 reviews) and Angi (21 reviews). It also has a nearly perfect 4.9 rating on Yelp (40 reviews).

The office is located at 4254 North Raceway Rd., Indianapolis, Ind., 46234. You can stop by between 8 a.m. and 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday. It is closed on Sundays, except for emergency situations. Give the team a call at 317-617-3928 to start your estimate. You can get an instant ballpark estimate on the company's website .

Customer testimonial

After we had some wind damage to our roof over the summer, we reached out to several companies for quotes and bids and decided to go with Indy Rooftops. Carl worked with us the whole time and we were very happy with how he handled things! He fought with our insurance company for months to get our claim to go through. Once the claim was processed, the actual process of picking out the shingles and getting on the schedule went very fast. The roof looks beautiful and we are very happy with it! - Payton S., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

Bone Dry Roofing is our top alternative Carmel roofer

Bone Dry Roofing has been serving the Carmel area since 1989. It started in a small garage and continues today as a family-owned and locally operated roofer. While the company specializes in residential and commercial roof replacements and repairs, it also provides several home exterior upgrade services.

When we called, a friendly receptionist answered our questions and took time to look up details when needed. We received a ballpark quote between $15,258 and $19,735 for asphalt shingles for a typical three-bedroom home. The exact price depends on the material type, roof size and pitch.

Final pricing can increase if the roof has multiple stories, more than one layer of shingles, decking issues, steep slopes, skylights, complex layouts or chimney flashing work. Bone Dry Roofing reviews these details during the on-site inspection before providing a final proposal.

The estimate includes removal of existing shingles, ice and water shield (if needed), underlayment, hip and ridge installation, new pipe jacks and chimney flashing, debris cleanup and city permits.

Services offered

• Roof installations and inspections

• Roof replacements and repairs

• Soffit and fascia services

• Gutters and downspouts

• Insulation, siding and drywall

• Emergency services

• Solar installation and repairs

No deposit is required to book your roof replacement. The company accepts cash, checks, debit or credit cards. There's a 3.6% fee applied to credit card payments. It offers financing options through third-party lenders with 12-month, same-as-cash options.

The roofing crews are all full-time employees who have passed background checks. Each roof replacement is backed by a five-year workmanship warranty. The company keeps an eye on the weather and will notify you in advance if it needs to reschedule to the next available day.

Bone Dry Roofing has been BBB-accredited since 1995 and has an A+ rating. While the roofer has had 20 complaints in the past three years, many have been answered or resolved. The company holds a 4.8-star rating on Google (2,368 reviews), 3.3 on Yelp (75 reviews) and 4.7 on Angi (2,340 reviews).

The office is located at 7735 Winton Dr., Indianapolis, Ind., 46268. It's open from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. daily and has a 24/7 answering service for emergency services. You can call 463-244-5442 or visit the company's website to start your estimate.

Customer testimonial

Bone Dry Roofing is an excellent company! My salesperson Richard even helped me to pick a shingle color that would match the current one so that it would be in compliance with my HOA. They recently installed my new roof and I was impressed with their level of professionalism, and they sent me pictures throughout each step of the installation. And it was installed rather quickly. They also did a great cleanup job after the install and made sure no nails or other debris was left in my yard. They showed great respect to my property. I also appreciated that the project manager did a final inspection and sent me a video of it. My roof looks excellent and I will refer them to anyone needing a new roof. - Angela P., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

Erie Home is the best national roofing company serving Carmel

Yahoo Local helps people make smart decisions about the services they choose. While working with a local business can be a great option, there are situations where a national roofing company is the better fit. If you're weighing both paths, our guide compares local roofers with national providers . For homeowners looking at larger companies, Erie Home is our top national recommendation for Carmel and the surrounding area.

Founded in 1976, Erie Home has grown into one of the largest residential roofing companies serving the Central U.S. and beyond. It offers standard roofing services, including asphalt shingle repair, replacement, and installation, as well as specialty options like metal roofing and waterproofing. Erie operates more than 100 locations across 38 states. While its primary service area includes the Central and Eastern regions, it's also a leading national roofer in the Southeast and Pacific Northwest, with offices stretching from Washington state to Florida.

Headquartered in Toledo, Ohio, Erie Home has an average Google rating of 4.4 stars based on more than 1,400 reviews, placing it among the top large roofing providers for overall service. Its Yelp rating is lower at 2.1 stars from more than 40 reviews, which is fairly typical for nationwide contractors. Considering its reviews, services, and long-standing performance, Erie Home stands out as the best national roofing company for the Central U.S. and remains a strong option for homeowners in the Southeast and Northwest.

Like many large roofing companies, Erie Home does not provide pricing over the phone. A representative explained that pricing varies based on the details of each project, which is why an on-site consultation is required for all estimates, including rough ones

Services offered

• Nationwide roofing services

• Roof repair, replacement and installation

• Metal and asphalt roofing options

• Foundation repair and waterproofing (in select locations)

• Free consultations

Homeowners who choose Erie Home may qualify for its zero-down financing option, allowing payments to be deferred for 90 days. According to the company, financing is the most common payment method among customers, and additional details are available on Erie's website . Other payment methods, such as credit cards, debit cards, or checks, may be accepted, depending on the local office, and processing fees may apply.

Erie Home is known for its durable metal roofing systems, but also offers affordable asphalt shingle options in a range of colors, including granite black and Monaco red. All roofing projects include a limited lifetime labor warranty, along with manufacturer warranties that vary by material. Erie also employs dedicated repair teams that can respond quickly when needed, and most roof installations are completed in less than a day.

Because Erie operates so many offices and roofing crews, cleanup procedures are not standardized. During your consultation, ask your estimator how cleanup will be handled during and after your roofing project.

Erie Home is accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating and has received approximately 388 customer complaints over the past three years. While that number may seem high, it's not uncommon among national service providers. According to the representative we spoke with, Erie works exclusively with in-house crews rather than subcontractors, though we were unable to confirm whether formal background checks are conducted.

To learn more, call 317-934-2391 or request a free estimate online . Erie Home's closest office is located at 5757 W. 73rd St., Indianapolis, Ind., 46278. The customer service line is available 24/7, and office hours vary by location.

Customer testimonial

Erie Home installed our fairly complex 2-story roof in 1 day. We were absolutely impressed with their superior American made products. The install went smoothly and as expected, and the clean-up after was stellar. I have already recommended Erie Home to family. That says it all. - Ed G., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

More best Carmel roofers

Why you can trust Yahoo Local roofing advice

For decades, Yahoo has helped people make confident decisions about local businesses. That experience shapes how we research and compare roofers today through our Yahoo Local guides. Our team reviews licenses, services and customer feedback across multiple trusted review platforms. Then, we apply a consistent scoring system so companies can be compared fairly. Businesses cannot pay to be featured or ranked higher. Our goal is to give you clear, helpful and accurate information so you can choose a roofer that feels right for your home. Want more details? Visit our full methodology page .

Below is everything that went into the rankings for our list of the best roofing companies in Carmel:

• 44 roofers evaluated

• 12,906 customer reviews and ratings from five sources

• Eight ranking criteria incorporated

• Interviewed or connected with three featured roofers

• Independent price quotes sought from three featured roofing companies

• Independently researched and fact-checked by Yahoo

• Recommendations are maintained and updated regularly

Indiana roofing FAQs

How much does the average roof replacement cost in Indiana?

The average cost of a roof replacement in Indiana is between $10,000 and $18,000, according to one of our best roofers, Cochran Exteriors . The price may vary based on the actual size of your roof, materials, complexity and potential underlying issues that need repair. For more information on what goes into pricing, read our guide to roof replacement costs .

How do I know if my roof needs repairs or a full replacement?

Small leaks and missing shingles don't always mean you need a full replacement. Sometimes small issues can be repaired, especially if your roof is still relatively new and the damage is limited to one area. A full replacement is more likely if your roof is older, has widespread damage or shows signs of long-term wear. Curling shingles, frequent leaks, sagging areas, or visible damage after hail or windstorms can all point to a roof that has reached the end of its life. If you're unsure which option makes sense, a professional inspection can help clarify your next step. Learn more in our guide to roof replacements vs. repairs .

Are there roofing regulations or permits required in Indiana?

Roofing regulations and permit requirements exist in Indiana, but they are set at the local level, rather than statewide. Indiana does not have a statewide roofing license, so cities and counties decide their own rules for permits and contractor requirements. In many areas, a roofing permit is required for full replacements and, in some cases, for major repairs. Larger cities often have stricter rules, including inspections and proof of insurance. When comparing roofing companies in Carmel, ask about permit requirements and if the company handles them. Learn more in our Indiana roofing licensing and regulations guide .

How long does a roof typically last in Indiana?

According to one of our top roofers, Bone Dry Roofing , the lifespan of your roof in Indiana depends on the material, weather and how well it's maintained. Asphalt shingle roofs are the most common and typically last about 20 to 30 years with proper care. Metal roofs last much longer, often 40 to 70 years with good maintenance. Regular inspections, good attic ventilation and clean gutters all help extend the life of your roof. Read more about how long roofs last here .

What is the best time of year to replace a roof in Indiana?

Spring and early summer are usually the best times to replace a roof in Indiana. Spring brings milder temperatures and is a good time to spot damage from winter storms. Early summer can also work well because of longer days and good working temperatures. However, Indiana summers can be hot and humid, which may slow work and make scheduling harder. Planning ahead and booking early can help you secure better availability during these peak seasons.

More Yahoo Local-approved Indiana providers

Best Indiana roofers

Carmel / Evansville / Fort Wayne / Indianapolis

• See all Yahoo Local roofing

Best Indiana movers

Fort Wayne / Indianapolis / South Bend

• See all Yahoo Local moving