Best roofers in Noblesville, Ind.

Roof repairs and replacements can be a big investment, so you want a roofer you can trust to do exceptional work. The Yahoo Local team is here to help with a guide of the best roofers in Noblesville, ranking options on customer reviews, service offerings, Better Business Bureau (BBB) accreditations and more. We designed this list to help you compare reliable roofers and choose the best fit for your home and budget.

Top Noblesville roofers

The best roofing company in Noblesville for YOU

There isn't one right roofing company for every home or business in Noblesville. The best choice depends on what work you need done, how quickly it needs to happen and how much flexibility you have in your budget. If you are dealing with storm damage, response time and experience with insurance claims may matter most. For planned replacements, it helps to compare prices, warranty coverage and other exterior services you may need later.

If you want a strong all-around option with consistent reviews, a lifetime manufacturer warranty and emergency support, Element Roofing is our best overall roofer in Noblesville. If you prefer quick online estimates, financing options and five-star customer reviews, Indy Rooftops is our top alternative. Read on to find the best Noblesville roofer for you.

Best roofing companies in Noblesville, Ind.

Element Roofing is the best overall Noblesville roofing company

Element Roofing is a local company founded in 2019 by Jeremy Rytych. It provides residential and commercial roofing and siding services in Noblesville and nearby communities. The company also offers emergency roof repairs with a 24-hour response time. Crews can tarp damaged areas to prevent leaks and assist with insurance documentation during the claims process.

When we called to get a roof replacement estimate, we talked with a friendly sales manager named Mehdi. He explained that the process begins with scheduling an on-site visit. During the inspection, the team evaluates the roof surface, decking and attic space. They also look for signs of storm damage and can help document findings for insurance claims. After the inspection, you will receive a detailed written quote. The company doesn't offer ballpark quotes over the phone.

A 50% deposit is required before scheduling the project. Element Roofing accepts ACH payments, personal checks and credit cards. Credit card payments include a 3% processing fee. Financing is available through three lending partners, though approval depends on your credit.

Services offered

• Roof installation

• Replacements

• Inspections

• Repairs

• Emergency storm damage restoration

• Siding

Your estimate includes debris cleanup. The crew brings a dumpster and hauls it away when the project is complete. If bad weather is expected on installation day, the company monitors conditions and typically reschedules within one to two days to avoid quality issues.

This roofer didn't specify whether crews are background-checked, but confirmed that each employee is vetted and covered under its liability insurance. Each roofing project is backed by a three-year workmanship warranty covering installation and repairs. Shingles come with a lifetime manufacturer's warranty.

Element Roofing is not accredited by the BBB , but it has only had one complaint in the past three years. Across other review sites, the company holds a 4.9-star rating on Google (149 reviews), 4.6 on Yelp (13 reviews) and a 4.8 on Angi (20 reviews).

You can find the local office at 1717 East 116th St., Suite 112, Carmel, Ind., 46032. It's open from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. daily. Call 317-548-8445 or contact Element Roofing online .

Customer testimonial

Element Roofing was fantastic from start to finish! They came quickly and tarped the siding. The team was incredibly timely and communicative, keeping me updated every step of the way. They handled everything with my insurance company, which made the entire process so much easier and stress-free. The crew completed the entire job in just one day, and the cleanup was spotless...you wouldn't even know they were there except for the beautiful new siding. Jeremy was extremely personable, professional, and genuinely cared about making sure everything went smoothly. Highly recommend Element Roofing to anyone needing roofing work done! - Peter S., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

Indy Rooftops is our top alternative Noblesville roofer

Founded in 2023, Indy Rooftops has quickly made a name for itself in Noblesville and the surrounding Indianapolis area. It is a local, family-owned and operated company with experience working in the area's weather conditions. Indy Rooftops offers a wide selection of residential and commercial roofing services.

When we contacted the company, we spoke with the general manager, Brian. He was easy to chat with and passionate about the company's workmanship and high standards. Indy Rooftops offers an online pricing tool that provides a rough estimate in about two minutes. For a typical three-bedroom, two-bathroom home, the tool estimated a roof replacement cost between $15,000 and $16,000. After that initial estimate, the company schedules an in-person visit where an estimator inspects the roof, takes photos, checks the attic and prepares a detailed written quote.

Indy Rooftops requires a 50% deposit to set your reroof date. Payment options include cash, cashier's check, bank check and debit or credit cards. Credit card payments add a processing fee of 2% to 3%. Financing is available, including 12 months same-as-cash and longer repayment terms up to 84 months.

Services offered

• Roof replacement

• Repairs

• Inspections

• Maintenance

• Siding

• Gutters and downspouts

• Window replacement

• Soffit and fascia

• Attic insulation

• Skylights

Before completing the job, crews remove all debris and use magnetic tools to collect nails from the yard. If rain or bad weather might impact the scheduled work date, the company will contact you at least 24 hours ahead of time to reschedule for the next available day.

All full-time employees go through background checks, but the company also works with subcontracted roofing crews. However, each project has an in-house manager who's on-site for every job. The company offers a three-year workmanship warranty. Brian also shared that even outside the warranty period, the company is willing to address workmanship-related issues as needed.

Even though it's a newer business, Indy Rooftops is already accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating. Customer feedback is consistently strong, including five-star ratings on Google (428 reviews), Angi (21 reviews) and Yelp (21 reviews).

The office is located at 4254 North Raceway Rd., Indianapolis, Ind., 46234. Business hours are 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday. It's closed on Sundays except for emergency calls. You can call 317-617-3928 to get started or use the website for an instant ballpark estimate .

Customer testimonial

I had a great experience working with Indy Rooftops! Carl was excellent from start to finish—he handled everything with the insurance company, kept the process moving smoothly, and was incredibly responsive to all my questions. I was out of town during the roof install, and Carl made sure to be onsite and kept me updated the entire time. The roof and gutters are absolutely beautiful! His professionalism and communication gave me total peace of mind. Highly recommend! - Matt J., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews

Erie Home is the best national roofer serving Noblesville

Yahoo Local is designed to help people make confident, informed decisions. While choosing a local business is often a great option, there are times when a national roofing company may better suit your needs. If you're comparing the two, we have a guide that outlines the differences between local and national roofers . For homeowners considering a larger provider, Erie Home is our top national recommendation for the Central U.S.

In operation since 1976, Erie Home has grown into one of the largest residential roofing companies serving the Central U.S. and beyond. The company provides standard roofing services, including asphalt shingle repair, replacement, and installation, along with specialty offerings such as metal roofing and waterproofing. Erie maintains more than 100 offices across 38 states. While its primary coverage includes the Central and Eastern regions, it's also regarded as a leading national roofer in the Southeast and Pacific Northwest, with offices ranging from Washington State to Florida.

Headquartered in Toledo, Ohio, Erie Home has earned a 4.4-star average rating on Google from more than 1,400 reviews, making it one of the highest-rated large roofing providers in its service areas. Its Yelp rating is lower at 2.1 stars from about 43 reviews, though that's fairly typical for nationwide contractors. Considering its service range, reputation, and long-standing presence, Erie Home ranks as the best overall national roofing company for the Central U.S. and remains a dependable option in the Southeast and Northwest.

Like most large roofing companies, Erie Home does not provide pricing estimates over the phone. A representative explained that costs depend on the specific details of each project, which is why an on-site consultation is required before any estimate, even a rough one, can be given.

Homeowners who decide to work with Erie Home may qualify for its zero-down financing option, which allows payments to be delayed for 90 days. According to company representatives, financing is the most common payment method among customers, and additional information can be found on Erie's website . Other payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, or checks, may be accepted depending on the local office, and processing fees could apply.

Services offered

• Nationwide roofing services

• Roof repair, replacement and installation

• Metal and asphalt roofing options

• Foundation repair and waterproofing (in select locations)

• Free consultations

Erie Home is particularly known for its durable metal roofing systems but also offers affordable asphalt shingle options in several colors, including granite black and Monaco red. All roofing projects come with a limited lifetime labor warranty, along with manufacturer warranties that vary based on the material selected. Erie also employs dedicated repair crews who can respond quickly to issues, and most roof installations are completed in less than a day.

Because Erie operates numerous offices and work crews, cleanup procedures are not standardized across all locations. During your consultation, ask your estimator how your assigned team will manage cleanup during and after the project.

Erie Home is accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating and has received approximately 391 customer complaints over the past three years. While that number may appear high, it's actually lower than the average complaint rate for national roofing companies. According to the representative we spoke with, Erie relies exclusively on in-house crews rather than subcontractors, though we were unable to confirm whether formal background checks are conducted.

To learn more, call 317-934-2391 or request a free estimate online. Its closest office is located at 5757 West 73rd St., Indianapolis, Ind., 46278. A full list and map of locations are available on the company's website. Customer service is available 24/7.

Read Yahoo Local's full review of Erie Home for even more details.

Customer testimonial

Erie Home installed our fairly complex 2-story roof in 1 day. We were absolutely impressed with their superior American made products. The install went smoothly and as expected, and the clean-up after was stellar. I have already recommended Erie Home to family. That says it all. - Ed G., Google reviews (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

See Google reviews See Yelp reviews

More best Noblesville roofers

You can count on Yahoo Local roofing advice, and this is why 

Yahoo Local builds these guides to help you find reliable home service providers in your community. Rather than rating companies on a single detail, we look at a combination of customer reviews, services offered and business credentials to get a clear picture of how each company operates. Our rankings come from an internal review process that draws on trusted rating platforms and independent research. We also explain our approach so you can understand what we consider and how we make decisions. Yahoo Local does not accept payment for placement and companies cannot pay to be included. To learn more about our evaluation process, visit our methodology page .

Below is everything that went into the rankings for our list of the best roofing companies in Noblesville:

• 102 roofers evaluated

• 12,013 customer reviews and ratings from five sources

• Eight ranking criteria incorporated

• Interviewed or connected with three featured roofers

• Independent price quotes sought from three featured roofing companies

• Independently researched and fact-checked by Yahoo

• Recommendations are maintained and updated regularly

Indiana roofing FAQs

How much does the average roof replacement cost in Indiana?

According to Cochran Exteriors , the average roof replacement in Indiana costs between $9,800 and $16,290 for asphalt shingles and between $34,301 and $57,015 for metal roofs. Costs vary depending on roof size, material choice and how complex the roof design is. Asphalt shingles are typically the most affordable option, while metal roofing costs significantly more.

Final pricing may also increase if the roof has multiple stories, steep slopes or underlying damage discovered during inspection. You can get an accurate estimate for your home project through a free inspection with a reputable roofer.

How do I know if my roof needs repairs or a full replacement?

Another top roofer in Noblesville, Moss Roofing , explains that the decision of replacement or repair typically comes down to the age of your roof and the type of damage. If your roof still has 10 to 15 years of life left and the issues are minor, you likely just need repairs. Common signs of needing repairs include missing shingles, loose flashing, overflowing gutters or excess shingle granules in the gutters.

A full replacement might be the best option if you have an older roof with widespread damage. Your estimator will help determine the best option for your roof during the inspection and quote process.

Are there roofing regulations or permits required in Indiana?

Yes, roofing regulations and permit requirements exist in Indiana, but they are handled at the local level rather than statewide. Permits may be required for full roof replacements and some major repairs, depending on your city or county. Typically, your roofing company will handle the permitting process for you, but it's worth asking to confirm before you pay a deposit or sign a contract. Learn more in our guide to Indiana roofing licensing and regulations .

How long does a roof typically last in Indiana?

One of the top companies on this list, Bone Dry Roofing , explains that a roof's lifespan depends on the material, local climate and how well it's maintained. Asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 30 years and metal roofs can last 40 years or more. Regular inspections, good attic ventilation, clear gutters and trimmed nearby trees can help extend your roof's lifespan.

What is the best time of year to replace a roof in Indiana?

Cochran Exteriors recommends scheduling your replacement for the spring , fall or early winter months for the best prices. Summer is the busy season for roofers in Noblesville, which makes scheduling more difficult and prices increase. If you're able to plan ahead, choosing a slower season may give you more flexibility with installation dates and help you save money. If your roof has serious storm damage, choose a company that can respond quickly and handle the next steps.

More Yahoo Local-approved Indiana providers

Best Indiana roofers

Carmel / Evansville / Fort Wayne / Indianapolis / Noblesville

• See all Yahoo Local roofing

Best Indiana movers

Fort Wayne / Indianapolis / South Bend

• See all Yahoo Local moving