These Under-$25 Secret Santa Gifts Are So Good, Your Partner Will Think You Went Over Budget
All products and services featured are independently chosen by editors. However, StyleCaster may receive a commission on orders placed through its retail links, and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.
Even though we can see them coming, gift exchanges are a fun holiday tradition that still stresses us out. This is especially true when it's an office Secret Santa, and we get paired with someone we barely know (even if their questionnaire is thorough). If you're feeling stuck on what to get your Secret Santa partner this year—or just want some fun and unique ideas that will make the gift-giving season a tad less stressful, we've got you covered with the best Secret Santa gifts under $25.
Today's Top Deals
Best Secret Santa Gifts Under $25, at a Glance
-
Best Gift for Travelers: Nordstrom Mini Travel Jewelry Case Key Chain , $18
-
Best Self-Care Gift: 100% Mulberry Silk Sleep Mask , $23
-
Best Makeup Gift: Ilia Mini Overglaze Lip Gloss Trio Set , $25
-
Best Skincare Gift: Peter Thomas Roth Eye Patch Travel Pack , $12
-
Best Coffee Table Book Gift: 1000 Record Covers Coffee Table Book by Michael Ochs , $18 (was $25)
-
Best Gift for Matcha Drinkers: Anthropologie Greta Matcha Bowl , $24
-
Best Yoga Gift: Tumaz Yoga Strap for Stretching with Adjustable D-Ring , $7
-
Best Style Gift: Craftsmans by Jonathon Pearl Sweater Pins Set of 6 , $11 (was $19)
-
Best Gift for Commuters: Baggu Puffy Earbuds Case , $10 (was $15)
-
Best Nostalgic Gift: Tamagotchi Original Fresh Strawberry , $20
Holiday shopping stress aside, part of what makes Secret Santa so fun is getting to know your partner's interests and shopping with those in mind. If you've been paired with someone who can't get enough of the 90s nostalgia, a $20 Tamagotchi is a great gift to give. Commuters who are always losing their AirPods case in their giant work bag will also appreciate the Baggu Puffy Earbuds Case (which is on sale for $10 right now!), and the Hydro Flask Micro Water Bottle is a useful gift to give the person who is always on the go.
Secret Santa aside, these budget-friendly gift ideas also make for some of the best stocking stuffers that aren't junk, as well as gifts for friends, teachers, and co-workers.
Nordstrom Mini Travel Jewelry Case Key Chain
If you get paired with someone who loves jewelry and traveling, the Nordstrom Mini Travel Jewelry Case Key Chain is the best Secret Santa gift under $25. This gift idea is both a bag charm and a mini jewelry case, with plenty of fun designs to choose from, including one that looks like a stick of butter.
100% Mulberry Silk Sleep Mask
Give the gift of self-care with this 100% Mulberry Silk Sleep Mask from Amazon. This silk eye mask looks so similar to the coveted Drowsy eye mask , only much cheaper. Unlike traditional styles, this one features a thicker Velcro band that actually stays put, plus excellent padding for slight compression against the eyes.
Ilia Mini Overglaze Lip Gloss Trio Set
The Ilia Mini Overglaze Lip Gloss Trio Set is one of the best gifts to give this holiday season, especially if you have a makeup lover on your list. However, the set of three meets that $25 limit exactly, so you could split it up into three separate gifts (and perhaps gift the other two to your friends or co-workers).
World Market Teeny Tiny Turntable Mini Kit
If your Secret Santa gift recipient noted their love of music on their form, the World Market Teeny Tiny Turntable Mini Kit is a fun gift to give. The miniature record player even comes with three mini vinyls for them to play.
Peter Thomas Roth Eye Patch Travel Pack
Gift sets are the best thing about shopping for skincare this holiday season—because when else would you be able to get a pack of four Peter Thomas Roth eye patches for just $12? This set is so budget-friendly that you can throw in a lip balm or even one of the glosses from the Ilia Mini Overglaze Lip Gloss Trio Set to meet the $25 limit.
Hydro Flask Micro Water Bottle
On Sale 17% off
A miniature water bottle is a lot more convenient than you'd think. The Hydro Flask Micro Water Bottle is the perfect size for travel, allowing you to quench your thirst without lugging around a heavy bottle. It's particularly great for situations where you know you'll be near a refill station, such as a theme park, the zoo, a museum, and so on.
'1000 Record Covers' Coffee Table Book by Michael Ochs
On Sale 28% off
Coffee table books make for stunning holiday gifts—but they don't always meet the $25 limit. If your Secret Santa partner loves music and album covers, the 1000 Record Covers Coffee Table Book by Michael Ochs is currently on sale for under $20.
Anthropologie Greta Matcha Bowl
Many holiday gifts focus on coffee lovers, but what about us matcha drinkers?! The Anthropologie Greta Matcha Bowl is a gorgeous, under-$25 matcha bowl that the tea drinker on your list will appreciate—especially since it doubles as kitchen decor.
Version 1.0.0
Santa Cookie Elf Candy Snowman Holiday Card Game
Secret Santa gift-giving can get tricky when you get partnered with someone you don't know very well, but you can't go wrong with a festive game. The Santa Cookie Elf Candy Snowman Holiday Card Game is a fun holiday-themed game for just $10 that is fun to give to co-workers. You might even consider ordering two and adding one deck to your loved one's stocking.
Burt's Bees Hand Repair Gift Set
'Tis the season for dry, cracked hands. If you got paired with someone who loves skincare, the Burt's Bees Hand Repair Gift Set is a great gift to give. This set features four Burt's Bees products, including Almond Milk Beeswax Hand Creme, Lemon Butter Cuticle Cream, Shea Butter Hand Repair Creme, and cotton gloves.
Tumaz Yoga Strap for Stretching with Adjustable D-Ring
If your limit is a bit lower and you're looking for Secret Santa gifts under $10, a yoga strap is a great (and very useful) gift idea for the yogi on your list. The Tumaz Yoga Strap for Stretching with Adjustable D-Ring is only $7 and available on Amazon for last-minute gift-giving, too.
"I once participated in a Secret Santa gift exchange at my old office job and was gifted a yoga strap. As someone who regularly attends classes and practices at home, it's one of my most-used gifts to date." — Jessie Quinn , contributing writer
Craftsmans by Jonathon Pearl Sweater Pins Set of 6
On Sale 31% off
A sweater pin is such a chic and affordable fashion gift to give, and the Craftsmans by Jonathon Pearl Sweater Pins come in a set of six for just $11. Give the set to your most fashionable co-worker, or split it up and use the rest as gift toppers for your friends' holiday gifts this season.
Hobby Gift Sewing Pin Cushion
If you're not a crafter but trying to find a gift for someone who loves to sew—don't sweat it. A cute pin cushion is both functional and looks adorable perched on their sewing table. This Hobby Gift Sewing Pin Cushion from Anthro is shaped like a watering can and meets that $25 limit.
Lifepro Wool Sauna Hat
If you got paired with a wellness aficionado who loves to sweat it out in the sauna, the Lifepro Wool Sauna Hat is a fab $20 gift to give this holiday season. This sauna hat is made from felted wool and designed to balance head heat for more comfortable sweat sessions.
BoxLunch Gilmore Girls Lorelai & Rory Car Sunshade
Gilmore Girls fans will love this hilarious gift idea from BoxLunch. When popped open, the Lorelai & Rory Car Sunshade makes it look like Rory and Lorelai are sitting in the driver and passenger seat of your car.
Urban Outfitters Mini Plug-In Microphone
Give your karaoke-obsessed Secret Santa partner the gift of always being prepared to belt their favorite tunes with this Mini Plug-In Microphone from Urban Outfitters.
Baggu Puffy Earbuds Case
On Sale 33% off
The Baggu Puffy Earbuds Case is great for all kinds of Secret Santa scenarios, especially if you're participating in your office's gift exchange and looking for the best gifts for commuters. This mini pouch is cute and stylish, and it'll keep their AirPods case safe.
UO Beauty Essentials Gift Set
On Sale 50% off
The UO Beauty Essentials Gift Set is another one of the best Secret Santa gift ideas for those who love a little pampering. For just $20, you get a Boy Smells body mist, Fazit freckle patches, Lanolips lip balm, BYOMA cream, and more.
'Puzzle Mania!: Wordle, Connections, Spelling Bee, Minis and More!' by New York Times Games
On Sale 39% off
If the person you're assigned to loves a good puzzle, the Puzzle Mania!: Wordle, Connections, Spelling Bee, Minis and More! book by New York Times Games is a fun gift idea. This coffee table book turns digital games into a gorgeous, tangible gift that they can actually play.
Tamagotchi Original Fresh Strawberry
Psst: Tamagotchis are back! If the person you're partnered with lives for all of the 90s nostalgia, the Tamagotchi Original Fresh Strawberry is a fun Secret Santa gift to give for $20.
Pac-Man Arcade Game Keychain
The Pac-Man Arcade Game Keychain is another nostalgic keychain gift to consider gifting the gamer on your list. This under-$20 Secret Santa gift idea features a miniature Pac-Man game that actually works and offers plenty of on-the-go entertainment.
Never Have I Ever Love Island Adult Party Game
Fans of Love Island will go wild for this Never Have I Ever game . The interactive card game is based on the reality show and is such a fun gift to give the person who is always hosting game night.
Bombas x Susan Alexandra Embellished Ruffle Rib Quarter Socks
Socks are a classic holiday gift, but why not spice things up with a stylish twist? The Bombas x Susan Alexandra Embellished Ruffle Rib Quarter Socks are the ultimate practical accessory, inspired by Susan Alexandra's beaded designer handbags and jewelry.
Best of StyleCaster
Sign up for Stylecaster's Newsletter . For the latest news, follow us on Facebook , Twitter , and Instagram .
