Tractor Supply's $9 Christmas Cat Toy Pack Comes With 10 Sweet Surprises
PetHelpful and Yahoo may earn commission from links in this article.
Cats have a special talent for turning the smallest things into entertainment. A crumpled receipt can become prey, an empty box suddenly becomes prime real estate, and anything dangling from the Christmas tree is apparently there specifically for them. Giving them their own stash of festive things to chase might not save your ornaments, but it certainly can't hurt.
That's what makes Tractor Supply's Paws & Claws Candyland Plush Cat Toy Set such a fun little holiday find. The $8.99 pack includes 10 colorful toys inspired by Christmas sweets and decorations, giving your cat an assortment to bat, chase and carry around the house. At less than a dollar per toy, it's also an easy way to refresh the toy basket before the holidays without spending much.
🐶🐱 🐶 SIGN UP to get "pawsitivity" delivered right to your inbox with inspiring & entertaining stories about our furry & feathered friends 🐾🐾
Paws & Claws Candyland Plush Cat Toy Set, $8.99 at Tractor Supply
Tractor Supply
Instead of giving your cat 10 versions of essentially the same toy, the Candyland set mixes up the shapes and textures. The assortment includes playful designs inspired by gingerbread, peppermint candy, candy canes, sugar cookies and other holiday treats.
The toys are made from polyester velvet and felt for a soft texture that's easy for cats to grab. Some also incorporate rope and crinkle material, creating different sensations depending on which one your cat pulls from the pile. Catnip adds another reason to investigate, especially for cats that need a little encouragement before deciding a new toy deserves their attention.
Having 10 small toys also has a practical benefit. You don't necessarily have to dump the entire package onto the floor on Christmas morning. Rotating a few at a time can make an inexpensive variety pack last longer, since toys that disappear for a while may feel interesting again when they come back into play.
That can be especially useful in winter, when cold weather means more time indoors. Toss one down a hallway for a cat who loves to chase, tuck another near their favorite lounging spot or save a few as replacements for the tiny toys that inevitably vanish beneath the couch.
For cats who prefer interactive play, Five Below's fishing rod cat toy offers another way to get them moving while joining in on the fun.
Related: Target's $15 Highland Cow Costume Turns Dogs Into the Cutest Little Cows
A Variety of Toys Can Keep Indoor Play More Interesting
One of the easiest ways to make playtime more engaging isn't necessarily buying a bigger or more complicated toy. Sometimes it's simply changing what your cat has to choose from.
Different shapes can encourage different kinds of play. One toy might be perfect for carrying around while another becomes something to kick or chase across the floor. The Candyland pack's mix of plush textures, crinkle material, rope and catnip gives curious cats several options, so you don't have to expect one toy to hold their attention indefinitely.
You can also spread the toys throughout the house rather than keeping everything in one basket. Leaving a couple near places your cat naturally spends time creates small opportunities for spontaneous play throughout the day, which is especially handy when you're working from home or busy preparing for the holidays.
Another inexpensive refresh is Five Below's two-pack of pink and green cat toys , especially if your cat seems happiest when small toys are scattered around.
As with any pet toy, supervise play and regularly check for damage or loose pieces your cat could swallow. Tractor Supply specifically notes that no pet toy is indestructible and recommends replacing damaged toys.
Your cat may still decide the wrapping paper is the most exciting part of Christmas. But for $8.99, having 10 little Candyland surprises waiting nearby gives the paper some pretty adorable competition.
This story was originally published by PetHelpful on Oct 17, 2026, where it first appeared in the Shopping section. Add PetHelpful as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
