Quick Read
-
Progressive's variable payout jumped from $4.60 to $13.60 per share, while Travelers has already cut its personal auto book by 9.2%.
-
Hartford raised its dividend 12% to $0.67 per share while Cincinnati Financial extended its streak to 66 consecutive annual increases, now at $0.94.
-
Americans keep cars for many years, so self-driving vehicles will take decades to replace the existing fleet and erode insurer premiums.
-
Just released. Our analysts combed the entire stock market and named the ten best stocks to buy right now, and Progressive didn't make the cut. Enter your email to see the names that beat PGR. The report is free. Enter your email and see if any of your stocks made the cut.
Elon Musk weighed in on a question that matters to anyone who owns insurance stocks for income. On X, @CoFoundersNik posted that FSD "could literally free up OVER $1.5 trillion/yr" by reducing fatal and serious crashes. Musk replied with one word: "True."
Auto insurers make their money from crash costs. If serious crashes fall, claims shrink. Premiums follow them down over time, which leaves insurers less float to invest and less surplus to pay out. Retirement-income investors should ask which dividends lean heaviest on that premium pool.
Crash Frequency Is Already Falling at America's Biggest Auto Writer
Progressive( NYSE:PGR ) said at its second-quarter investor event that auto claim frequency fell about 2.5% in the quarter. Vehicle miles traveled dropped roughly 4% over the same period. Nobody at the event discussed autonomous driving. Progressive has also cut new-business auto rates this year in 30 states representing 63% of premium. Expect this pattern in a self-driving world: fewer crashes, and the savings passed on to drivers through lower rates.
Investors are not pricing in disruption yet. Year to date, Travelers( NYSE:TRV ) is up 38.55%, and Allstate( NYSE:ALL ) is up 23.95%.
Free Report, Just Released
Why Didn't PGR Make The Top 10 List?
24/7 Wall St has helped investors make money for over two decades, and our top analysts just finished ranking the definitive Top 10 Stocks To Buy Now . Not the ten biggest companies. Not the ten everyone is arguing about. The ten best stocks to buy right now.
And PGR didn't make the cut!
The report is free, and you can see why we think each stock is a top investment today.
Enter Your Email and See the Ten →
Dividend Safety, Insurer by Insurer
Progressive
The regular dividend of $0.10 a quarter costs Progressive very little and looks safe. Most of the income comes from the variable payout, which was $13.60 per share in January 2026, up from $4.60 a year earlier. That payout rises and falls with auto underwriting profit. In the third quarter, Direct Vehicles brought in $10.29 billion of revenue, and Agency Vehicles brought in $7.51 billion, according to its SEC earnings release. Of the five, Progressive has the most exposure.
Allstate
Allstate raised its quarterly dividend to $1.08 from $1, and holding-company available capital stands at $9.5 billion. Auto is its largest line, generating $9.64 billion in quarterly revenue, with an 83.3% combined ratio. Its Arity unit holds more than 2 trillion miles of driving data, which could help it price risk once cars are partly automated.
Travelers
The dividend rose to $1.25 from $1.10. Travelers is already shrinking its auto book: personal auto policies fell 9.2% to 2.769 million. Personal auto revenue of $1.89 billion is small next to $5.87 billion from Business Insurance.
Hartford Insurance Group
Hartford Insurance Group( NYSE:HIG ) raised its dividend 12% to $0.67. Its annual increases have averaged approximately 11% over the past decade. Personal auto revenue fell 8% to $582 million, while Business Insurance brought in $4.26 billion.
Cincinnati Financial
Cincinnati Financial( NASDAQ:CINF ) has raised its dividend for 66 consecutive years, putting it in the rare Dividend Kings club (we ranked ten of them by valuation in a free report). The current payout is $0.94, up 8%. About 60% of its personal lines business is high-net-worth, and the parent company holds $6.1 billion in cash and marketable securities.
Why Self-Driving Would Hit Insurers Slowly
Americans keep their cars for many years, so self-driving cars would take a long time to replace the existing fleet. Liability would shift to manufacturers and fleet operators, who would need commercial and product liability coverage, which Travelers and Hartford already write. Cars loaded with sensors also cost more to repair, so the cost of each claim could rise even as the number of claims falls.
Verdict and One Thing to Watch
Every regular dividend here looks safe for years to come. Progressive's variable payout would feel any change first. Cincinnati Financial, Travelers, and Hartford have spread their earnings well beyond personal auto. On Progressive's November 3 call, check whether frequency keeps falling while rates are being cut. Lower frequency combined with lower prices is the earliest sign of the trend @CoFoundersNik described.
Got $1,000? Before You Buy PGR, Read This
If you have cash sitting in your account right now, give this two minutes. After more than two decades of helping investors beat the market, our top analysts at 24/7 Wall St. put together a definitive report on the Top 10 Stocks To Buy Today. And PGR wasn't one of them.
They combed the entire market. It's not 10 ideas, not 10 stocks everyone is talking about, it's what their research points to as the 10 best stocks to buy right now, and it's free. Read more here and see which stocks made the list -->>
Contact editorial@247wallst.com for any questions or corrections.
