The best toilet plungers for 2026, tested and reviewed
Don't wait until it's too late! These hardworking picks from Korky, Luigi's, Clorox and Simplehuman are here to save the day.
Our experts independently review everything we recommend. If you buy through our links, we may earn commission.
A good plunger is sort of like good insurance in that you hope you won't need it, but are really glad you sprung for it when a crisis hits. Like me, you probably purchased this oft-overlooked household essential from a local store when you moved into your space, without much thought. But now that I've tested nine designs in a quest to find the best toilet plungers, I can tell you the right design and materials can make all the difference.
In this story
As one of Yahoo's resident home-goods testers, I spend a healthy portion of my time trying out bathroom products like grout cleaners and spin scrubbers . For this guide, I used each plunger to plunge a toilet full of water, noting how quickly and effectively each could get the water to recede. While in the trenches, I noted how comfortable the plungers were to hold and use, how close I had to get to the mess and how much splashing they caused. I also considered factors such as durability, versatility and cleanliness. Below are the four hardworking plungers I'd recommend — most are under $20, and I even found options for different aesthetics.
Best toilet plungers for 2026
Materials:Rubber and plastic| Plunger type:Beehive flange| Handle style:T-handle | Storage caddy?No
Why it's great:This plunger from Korky features a plastic handle and a rubber beehive-style flange. It came fully assembled, so I didn't need to worry about any setup (all I had to do was remove a tag, and it was good to go). ​When it came to performance, this plunger moved the most toilet water and did so the fastest. It was also the only plunger among those I tested that completely drained the toilet bowl in the allotted number of thrusts (see "how we tested" below).
The flange got a good grip on the bowl, and the T-shaped handle was comfortable to hold. I didn't notice any splashing, and the telescoping wand allowed me to get as close to (or as far from) the action as I needed to.
​While I tested these toilet plungers on water alone, it's worth noting that several friends swear by the Korky for heavier-duty jobs (you know what I mean). One had tried several plungers to no avail, and when ish really hit the fan, she says this plunger saved her from an expensive plumbing situation.​
Minor criticisms:The flange on this plunger doesn't fold under (or convert to a flat cup), so you won't be able to use it for flat shower and sink drains. The wobbly beehive also makes the Korky more susceptible to falling when standing.
- Comfortable, secure grip
- Telescoping wand/handle
- Works quickly
- Beehive style may be more prone to tipping when standing
Materials:Plastic| Plunger type:Accordion flange | Handle style:Knob | Storage caddy?Can be bought with or without it
Why it's great:This tiered, coned number from Luigi's looks less like a traditional plunger and more like a toy version of an instrument. It's made of plastic and arrived in two parts, with setup merely a matter of screwing the wand/handle into the bottom (flanged) portion.
The flange provided a good grip on the toilet's siphon jet (or "blow hole"), allowing water to move swiftly and in large volumes. It lowered the water level significantly within the first two thrusts, and to just 2 inches by the third plunging round.
Luigi's knobbed handle was easy to hold, and while not adjustable, I found the plunger length optimal for the task. The water was contained (no splashing), so I didn't need to worry about cleaning the surrounding area.
​ Minor criticism:While the plastic construction makes this plunger easy to rinse and quick to dry, you should ensure you rinse all the crevices after use. They can capture water and trickle (sort of like a fountain), so I'd recommend buying the option that comes with a holder to minimize the mess.
- Lightweight
- Comfortable handle
- Available with a vase-like holder
- Need to account for a lot of grooves when rinsing
Materials:Rubber and plastic| Plunger type:Flat cup with extendable flange | Handle style:Knob | Storage caddy?Yes
This plunger has a more traditional silhouette than those above, with a plastic handle and a rubber flange. You just screw the former into the latter using your hand (it took a matter of seconds) to set it up.
Why it's great:​Clorox's version trailed slightly behind my other top picks in terms of speed and overall efficiency, but was still impressive. It began lowering the water line immediately and brought it down to about 3 inches in the same number of tries. The handle has a knob, which I found helpful for maintaining a comfortable grip.
​Unlike some other plungers I tested, the rubber used for the flange seemed to strike the perfect balance between sturdy and flexible, with enough give to move water but enough stability to avoid caving in or flipping. And it's convertible: Just tuck the flange under to create a flat cup for plunging showers and sinks.
​With this plunger, you get a butterfly-style caddy that opens when you pull the handle and closes when you put the plunger back. What's more, it has a drip tray, so you don't need to worry about excess water leaking onto your floor or bath mat . Even without the caddy, this plunger is super affordable, but when you consider that it includes two pieces, it's even more of a bargain.
​ Minor criticisms:I experienced some plashing with this plunger. But it was lighter than others I tested and stayed in the bowl for the most part.
- Convertible flat/flange cup
- Includes hideaway caddy with drip tray
- Light splashing
Materials:Rubber, plastic and stainless steel| Plunger type:Flat cup with extendable flange| Handle style:Knob | Storage caddy?Yes
Why it's great:Simplehuman's plunger is similar in form and function to Clorox's. It boasts a convertible rubber cup/flange and comes complete with a covert caddy — in this case, fully assembled upon arrival. ​This plunger performed comparably in my plunger test, quickly clearing the toilet drain. It splashed a little, but any splashing was contained.
​Where the Simplehuman version stands out, however, is that the plunger features stainless steel along the wand and knob for a sleeker look and slightly heavier feel. Based on my testing, it seems like the most durable plunger of the bunch, but we'll use it long-term to confirm. The other difference is that the caddy, which is also brushed stainless steel, is open on one side, so you don't need to make sure the plunger is angled just right when putting it away.
​I found the knob — and, despite being slightly heavier, the entire plunger — comfortable to hold, and the length ideal for keeping a good distance from the toilet. You might not associate luxury with a plunger, but it works in this case.
​ Minor criticism:At $40, this plunger set is on the expensive side. And as the caddy isn't completely closed, you'll need to position the open side against a wall if you don't want the plunger flange on display. ​
- Materials feel durable
- Less utilitarian-looking than most
- Open caddy is easy to use
- Pricey
The potty posse, lined up for duty. I tested nine plungers to see which ones had the strength and agility to move water down a toilet with speed and force.
(Kristin Granero/Yahoo)Factors to consider when choosing a toilet plunger
✓ Materials:Most of the plungers I reviewed featured a rubber cup (flat or flanged), with a plastic or wooden handle. In my experience, plastic is lighter and quicker to dry, but can be slippery) Wood is durable but can develop splinters, whereas metal is sleek and durable (so long as it's rustproof).
✓ Plunger type:
-
Flat-cup plungershave a dome-like cup with a flat bottom. They're best for plunging flat sink and shower drains.
-
Flange plungersfeature a flap (also called a flange), either as-is or that flips out. They're ideal for achieving a tighter seal on toilets and other non-flat siphon jets or drains.
-
Beehive plungershave a beehive-like shape. This design is often regarded for its efficiency and minimal splash-back, which held in the case of the Korky .
-
Accordion plungershave multiple tiers, like the instrument they're named after. They're known for their ability to apply a lot of pressure at once to get water (and anything in it) down quickly, as exemplified by the Luigi's plunger I evaluated. However, their nooks and crannies may require more careful rinsing.
✓ Handle style:I found knobbed handles easier and more comfortable to hold. T-style handles, like the one on the Korky , give you an even more secure grip, while extendable handles (or poles) let you get as far from the action as you can.
✓ Accessories:Plunger caddies and holders offer more discretion for those who don't want to proudly display this type of tool. Many also come with drip trays.
How we test toilet plungers
Upon receiving each plunger, I logged its size, style and ease of assembly. Here's a breakdown of the other things I factored into my evaluations:
-
Comfort:I rated how comfortable each plunger was to hold and use based on weight, length and handle style.
-
Versatility:I gave bonus points to plungers that served more than one purpose (for example, if they could be converted from a flat-cup to a flange).
-
Splashiness:I deducted points for excessive splashing, especially when it reached or exceeded the toilet seat.
-
Cleanliness:I considered how easy each plunger was to rinse, and whether it had a caddy (or drip tray) for added cleanliness.
-
Plunging abilities:I filled a toilet bowl up with the same amount of water, then noted the water level after four, eight and 12 plunges to compare each plunger's effectiveness.
-
Durability:I noted each plunger's materials and whether they appeared to be well-made based on physical testing and visual assessments.
The Korky plunger is hard at work. As shown here, it reduced a full bowl of water significantly with just a few thrusts.
(Kristin Granero/Yahoo)Other toilet plungers we tested
OXO Good Grips Toilet Plunger and Holder : Like the Clorox, this plunger features a plastic, knobbed handle and rubber cup that can be used flat or with a flange. It similarly comes with a hideaway-style caddy and is similarly comfortable to hold. But it took slightly longer than the Clorox option to work, requiring more tries to get the water level down to the same place, and it costs more. (It also splashed slightly, but it was mostly contained to the toilet bowl.)
SteadMax Heavy-Duty Toilet Plunger :Featuring a wooden wand and a rubber cup, this plunger is straightforward in design and setup. I like that it's versatile (there's a lip tucked into the cup that can be flipped out to create a flange), but I found the plungers with knobs or T-handles in my testing to be more comfortable, and the rubber used for this plunger seemed kind of flimsy, caving in at some points and splashing water onto the toilet seat. Compared to my top picks, it took more effort (several more plunges) to get the toilet water down.
​ JS Jackson Supplies Accordion Toilet Plunger :This plunger is similar to Luigi's, with a two-part assembly and a plastic accordion design. It worked quickly, but Luigi's longer, narrower flange moved the toilet water more forcefully, bringing the water level to 2 inches (versus JS Jackson's 3.5) in the final plunge. Last time I checked, this plunger also retailed for $2 more than Luigi's when purchased without the holder.
​ Neiko 60166A Toilet Plunger All-Angle :Constructed of aluminum and rubber, Neiko's plunger is lightweight and easy to use (the top part screws into the flange). Its plunging performance was on par with that of the Clorox model, but I was able to get a slightly more secure grip with Clorox's flange. This plunger also doesn't convert to a flat cup or have a knob for holding, and it costs more.
​ Mr. Siga Toilet Plunger + Brush Bowl Combo :The plunger in this set from Mr. Siga can be used flat or flanged, and it comes with a caddy and a toilet brush, keeping all the essentials in one place. I appreciate that everything is compact for smaller bathrooms, but I found the plunger to be a bit small, forcing me to get closer to the action than I would have liked. It was also slow-going, bringing the water level down to about 4 inches, compared to my top picks, which were all in the 2-to-3-inch range, despite the same number of thrusts. (I plan to test more options in search of the best plunger and brush combo for comparison's sake.)
Toilet plunger FAQs
What is the best kind of toilet plunger?
Flat-cup plungers are ideal for plunging flat shower and sink drains, while flanged plungers are ideal for plunging toilets. Based on the tests above, beehive and accordion-flange toilet plungers move greater volumes of water more quickly.
How often should you replace your toilet plunger?
How often you should replace your toilet plunger depends on the materials and frequency of use. That said, as a general rule, you should aim to swap out your toilet plunger when it's compromised (such as cracked or broken) or not working effectively.
Update, May 15, 2026: We overhauled this story with testing and new reporting. A previous version of this article was written by Rob Webb.
