MTG Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Bonus Sheet: Top 5 Reprints & Prices

All of the source material bonus sheet cards from Magic: The Gathering's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set have been revealed. These source material bonus sheet cards are reprints of existing Magic cards that have art from previously published TMNT media. In Magic's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set, there will be a total of twenty cards that are part of the MTG TMNT bonus sheet.

The following are the most valuable MTG TMNT bonus sheet cards. I'm including cards on this list on their lowest median price on TCGPlayer. There's no telling if the MTG TMNT Bonus Sheet prices will be as valuable as other printings. However, it will be nice to know what the prices of the existing prints of the MTG Bonus Sheet cards are.

5. Doubling Season - Pre-TMNT Market Reference

Starting with the fifth most valuable reprint from the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set bonus sheet, we have Doubling Season . This green enchantment doubles the number of tokens its controller creates and doubles the number of counters they can put on their permanents. According to TCGPlayer, Doubling Season's Modern Masters print is priced at $30.58 USD in its cheapest version.

4. All Will Be One - Phyrexia Set Reprint in TMNT Bonus Sheet

Next, at number four on this list is All Will Be One from the Phyrexia: All Will Be One set. This red enchantment lets you deal damage to a player or a creature or planeswalker they control when you put one or more counters on a permanent or player. According to TCGPlayer, All Will Be One has a median price of $31.76 USD in its main set printing. This card hasn't had any other reprints besides its prerelease print and the reprint found in the set's promo packs. All Will Be One having only one printing thus far is probably what contributes to its current high pricing.

3. Trouble in Pairs - Commander Precon Reprint in TMNT Bonus Sheet

Thirdly, Trouble in Pairs is a white enchantment that makes opponents skip extra turns and gives you conditional card draw. This card has only had one other printing so far in the Blame Game Murders at Karlov Manor commander precon. According to TCGPlayer, the price of Trouble in Pairs is currently at $33.47 USD, probably due to the card's scarcity.

2. Shadowspear (Donnie's Bo) - Most Valuable Artifact from the MTG TMNT Bonus Sheet

The second most valuable reprint from among the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles bonus sheet is a reskinned version of Shadowspear . Originally seen in Theros Beyond Death, Shadowspear is a powerful artifact that's cheap to cast, equip, and has powerful abilities. Shadowspear has been reprinted a couple of times in other sets, and the TMNT version has been renamed Donnie's Bo. According to TCGPlayer, the cheapest version of Shadowspear is the original print seen in Theros Beyond Death whose price is $40.89 USD.

1. Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm (Splinter of the Shadows) - Most Valuable TMNT Bonus Sheet Card

Finally, the most valuable reprint from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' bonus sheet is a reprinted Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm . It is a Rat Warlock that synergizes well with other rat cards as a way of buffing and recurring them. The version found in the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set has been reskinned and renamed to Splinter of the Shadows. According to TCGPlayer, Ashcoat of the Shadow Swarm has a median price of $75.99 USD, probably due to its rarity. While this card is pretty niche, it's only been printed once so far as part of the Jumpstart 2022 set.

This wraps up the list of most valuable reprints in the Magic: The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles bonus sheet. While there's no guarantee that the TMNT will be as expensive as the current cheapest versions, they are nice pulls. At the very least, those lucky enough to pull these cards can save a lot of money from buying cards. The MTG TMNT bonus sheet source material cards can be pulled in non-foil from both Play Boosters and Collector Boosters. However, the traditional foil versions of these bonus sheet source material cards can only be pulled from the Collector Boosters.

The Magic: The Gathering Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles universes beyond set will have its prerelease events starting on February 27.

This story was originally published by GameDaily on Feb 24, 2026, where it first appeared in the Features section. Add GameDaily as a Preferred Source by clicking here.