MTG TMNT Chase Cards: The Most Expensive Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles MTG Cards

The MTG Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set includes a wide range of cards, but some stand out for their market value. In this article, we break down the most expensive Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles MTG cards you can pull from Play Boosters. We focus on the MTG TMNT chase cards and explain which ones are currently commanding the highest prices.

For this article, we're focusing on the chase cards from the TMNT MTG set that are valued at ten dollars or more. The cards are listed in an order that balances their base value with the price of their most sought-after printings, so readers can see both affordable pulls and the real collector hits.

Undercity Sewers

• Non-Foil Price: $10.94 USD

• Foil Price: $14.72 USD

Kicking off this list is Undercity Sewers, a surveil land that's part of the MTG TMNT set's Source Material cards. This card's current market price is $10.94 USD in non-foil and $14.72 USD in foil.

Donatello, Mutant Mechanic (Borderless)

• Non-Foil Price: $11.65 USD

• Foil Price: $13.30 USD

The next card on my list is the Borderless Silhouette print of Donatello, Mutant Mechanic. This card has strong synergies with +1/+1 counters and artifacts. This card's current market price is $11.65 USD in non-foil and $13.30 USD in foil.

Michelangelo, Weirdness to 11 (Borderless)

• Non-Foil Price: $14.21 USD

• Foil Price: $18.67 USD

The Borderless Scene print of Michelangelo, Weirdness to 11 is another chase card from the MTG TMNT main set. This card is effectively Hardened Scales on a creature. This card's current market price is $14.21 USD in non-foil and $18.67 USD in foil.

Michelangelo, Improviser (Borderless)

• Non-Foil Price: $14.47 USD

• Foil Price: $17.02 USD

Michelangelo, Improviser's Borderless Silhouette print is another valuable card from the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set. This creature lets you cheat in creature or land cards whenever it deals combat damage to a player. Its current market price is $14.47 USD in non-foil and $17.02 USD in foil.

Trouble in Pairs

• Non-Foil Price: $16.32 USD

• Foil Price: $24.02 USD

The next Source Material card in this list is Trouble in Pairs, a white enchantment that hinders and taxes opponents. This card's current market price is $16.32 USD in non-foil and $24.02 USD in foil.

All Will Be One

• Non-Foil Price: $17.68 USD

• Foil Price: $22.87 USD

All Will Be One is another valuable Source Material card from the MTG TMNT set. It's a red enchantment that burns opponents whenever you put +1/+1 counters on a permanent or player. Its current market price is $17.68 USD in non-foil and $22.87 USD in foil.

Donnie's Bo (Shadowspear)

• Non-Foil Price: $22.02 USD

• Foil Price: $25.28 USD

Donnie's Bo is another Source Material card that's a reskin of Shadowspear, a powerful legendary equipment. It's currently priced at $22.02 USD in non-foil and $25.28 USD in foil.

Dark Leo & Shredder

• Regular Print (Non-Foil/Foil): $11.90 USD / $14.00 USD

• Borderless Silhouette (Non-Foil/Foil): $24.83 USD / $29.85 USD

Dark Leo & Shredder is another valuable card from the MTG TMNT main set. It's a powerful creature that synergizes with ninjas. According to TCGPlayer, the regular print of this card is priced at $11.90 USD in non-foil and $14.00 USD in foil. Meanwhile, the Borderless Silhouette version commands a higher price at $24.83 USD in non-foil and $29.85 USD in foil.

Krang, Utrom Warlord

• Regular Print (Non-Foil/Foil): $21.20 USD / $23.21 USD

• Borderless Silhouette (Non-Foil/Foil): $26.54 USD / $31.25 USD

Krang, Utrom Warlord is one of the most expensive cards from the MTG Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set. It's a powerful artifact creature that serves as a finisher in artifact-based decks. The regular print is currently priced at $21.20 USD in non-foil and $23.21 USD in foil. Meanwhile, the rarer Borderless Silhouette version is more valuable at $26.54 USD in non-foil and $31.25 USD in foil.

Doubling Season

• Non-Foil Price: $30.47 USD

• Foil Price: $39.31 USD

The most expensive Source Material card from the MTG Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles set is Doubling Season. This powerful green enchantment doubles your tokens and counters. Its current market price is $30.47 USD in non-foil and $39.31 USD in foil.

Super Shredder

• Regular Print (Non-Foil/Foil): $34.76 USD / $38.79 USD

• Borderless Silhouette (Non-Foil/Foil): $48.72 USD / $58.25 USD

Finally, Super Shredder is the most expensive card overall from the set. It's a menacing ninja that grows stronger when permanents leave the battlefield. Its regular print costs a whopping $34.76 USD in non-foil and $38.79 USD in foil. Meanwhile, the Borderless Silhouette print is even more expensive at $48.72 USD in non-foil and $58.25 USD in foil.

This story was originally published by GameDaily on Mar 31, 2026, where it first appeared in the Features section. Add GameDaily as a Preferred Source by clicking here.