Quick Read
-
HDV currently offers the substantially higher yield. At today's 30-day SEC yields, $1 million would generate roughly $33,400 annually from HDV versus $19,500 from DGRO before taxes.
-
DGRO returned 13.38% annualized over the past decade with dividends reinvested, compared with 9.11% for HDV. $1 million would have compounded to roughly $3.51 million versus $2.39 million over 10 years.
-
For retirees with another 10 years before needing the money, I'd prioritize total return over maximizing distributions, but a 50/50 DGRO-HDV allocation can split the difference.
-
Just released. Our analysts combed the entire stock market and named the ten best stocks to buy right now. The report is free. Enter your email and see if any of your stocks made the cut.
Most of the big asset managers have complementary dividend ETFs aimed at slightly different types of income investors. Vanguard, iShares, Charles Schwab, and State Street all offer variations focused on dividend growth, high current yield, or some combination of the two.
For BlackRock's iShares lineup, two prominent choices are the iShares Core Dividend Growth ETF (DGRO)and iShares Core High Dividend ETF (HDV). Both charge a reasonable 0.08% expense ratio, and both can be fairly tax efficient because their methodologies exclude real estate investment trusts (REITs). That's about where the similarities end.
For retirees, I find the dividend ETF selection process often boils down to looking at the headline yield and picking whichever number is higher. The reasoning is understandable. Generate enough quarterly income to cover expenses, don't sell shares, and leave the principal alone.
But principal and income aren't economically separate buckets. Total return is what ultimately determines how much wealth you have available to spend. And if you're a retiree who doesn't expect to touch this portion of your portfolio for another 15 years, the comparison between DGRO and HDV illustrates why I'd prioritize compounding over the highest starting yield.
Free Report, Just Released
The Top 10 Stocks To Buy Now
24/7 Wall St has helped investors make money for over two decades, and our top analysts just finished ranking the definitive Top 10 Stocks To Buy Now . Not the ten biggest companies. Not the ten everyone is arguing about. The ten best stocks to buy right now.
The report is free, and you can see why we think each stock is a top investment today.
Enter Your Email and See the Ten →
HDV Pays Considerably More Income Today
If you're determined to fund expenses exclusively from dividends, HDV has the clear advantage. Its 30-day SEC yield is currently 3.34%, compared with 1.95% for DGRO. Assuming those yields remained unchanged, here's approximately what a $1 million portfolio would generate before taxes:
| ETF |
30-day SEC yield |
Annual income on $1 million |
Average per quarter |
|---|---|---|---|
| DGRO |
1.95% |
$19,500 |
$4,875 |
| HDV |
3.34% |
$33,400 |
$8,350 |
HDV produces about $13,900 more annual income, or an average of $3,475 more per quarter. That's a substantial difference for someone already retired and relying on distributions to pay expenses. HDV lets you extract more cash without selling shares.
But if you're not planning to spend the money for another decade, I'd argue that this comparison becomes much less important. What matters during accumulation is how quickly the entire investment compounds, including both dividends and share-price appreciation. And historically, that's where DGRO has pulled substantially ahead.
DGRO's Total-Return Advantage Has Been Significant
Over the past 10 years, with dividends reinvested and before taxes, DGRO compounded at 13.38% annually. HDV returned 9.11% annualized. A difference of 4.27% might not sound enormous in any individual year, but compounding magnifies it considerably. To illustrate, a hypothetical $1 million invested for 10 years at those historical annualized rates would have grown to approximately:
| ETF |
10-year annualized return |
Hypothetical ending value |
|---|---|---|
| DGRO |
13.38% |
$3.51 million |
| HDV |
9.11% |
$2.39 million |
That's a gap of roughly $1.12 million. Of course, those are historical returns rather than a forecast. HDV could outperform during a future period when high-dividend value stocks lead the market. But the comparison illustrates the opportunity cost of treating dividends differently from capital gains.
If DGRO produces less dividend income but leaves you with substantially more wealth, you can manufacture additional income later by selling shares. For taxable investors, realizing long-term capital gains can also receive preferential federal tax treatment, although the exact result depends on income, holding period, cost basis, and individual tax circumstances.
Selling shares can feel psychologically different from spending dividends. Economically, however, I'd rather own the portfolio producing the better risk-adjusted total return and sell a small number of shares when necessary than sacrifice substantial long-term compounding solely to avoid touching the share count.
Now, there's nothing inherently wrong with HDV. A retiree who strongly prefers living on distributions may reasonably prefer its 3.34% SEC yield. And if you really can't let go of that higher yield, splitting the allocation 50/50 between DGRO and HDV is perfectly reasonable. You'd increase current income relative to owning DGRO alone while retaining meaningful exposure.
Just recognize what that compromise has historically cost. Over the past decade, every dollar shifted from DGRO toward HDV reduced total return. For money I didn't expect to touch for another 10 years, I'd personally prioritize the stronger compounding potential and worry about converting that wealth into income when I actually needed it.
Got $1,000? Read This Before You Buy Another Stock
If you have cash sitting in your account right now, give this two minutes. After more than two decades of helping investors beat the market, our top analysts at 24/7 Wall St. put together a definitive report on the Top 10 Stocks To Buy Today.
They combed the entire market. It's not 10 ideas, not 10 stocks everyone is talking about, it's what their research points to as the 10 best stocks to buy right now, and it's free. Read more here and see which stocks made the list -->>
Contact editorial@247wallst.com for any questions or corrections.
